News

Elvis Refused a Million-Selling Song From Roy Orbison — The Real Reason Took 16 Years to Come Out

The Song Elvis Gave Back — Roy Orbison and “Only the Lonely”

At 10 minutes past 3:00 in the morning, in March of 1960, a dusty two-tone Ford pulled up to the musical gates of Graceland, and two young men in wrinkled shirts sat in the front seat with the engine running, arguing about whether to ring the bell. In the back seat, on top of a pile of road maps and empty Coca-Cola bottles, was a battered acoustic guitar. And in the head of the young man behind the wheel was a song. It was the best thing he had ever written.

Both of them knew it. Within a few months, it would sell more than a million copies, go to number two in America, and number one in Britain, and turn a shy, half-forgotten singer from a Texas oil town into one of the most famous voices in the world. But on that cold March night, he had not driven to Memphis to sing it himself. He had driven there to give it away, to Elvis Presley.

And what Elvis said to him, sitting at a piano in the music room at Graceland a little after half past 3:00 in the morning, was the last thing either of those young men expected to hear. It would take one of them almost 16 years to find out why Elvis had said it. The young man behind the wheel was named Roy Orbison. He was 23 years old that spring, and as far as most of the music business was concerned, his career was already over.

Four years earlier, it had looked like it was just beginning. Roy had grown up in Wink, a dusty, windblown oil town out in the flat west of Texas. A skinny, nearsighted, painfully shy kid with thick glasses who could sing like nobody anybody in Wink had ever heard. He had formed a little band in high school, played dances and radio shows, and in 1956, he had made his way to Memphis, to a little studio on Union Avenue called Sun Records, the same place where a truck driver named Elvis Presley had walked in 2 years before.

Sam Phillips, who owned Sun, signed him. Roy cut a rockabilly song called Ooby Dooby, and it sold a couple of hundred thousand copies. And for a few months, Roy Orbison toured the South on the same package shows as Johnny Cash and Carl Perkins and Jerry Lee Lewis. And then, it all just stopped.

Roy was not a rockabilly singer. Everyone could hear it, even Roy. His voice wanted to do something else. It wanted to climb.

It wanted to go up and up into notes that rock and roll singers never went near. High and pure and aching. More like an opera singer than a hillbilly. Sam Phillips kept telling him to sing it rougher, faster, wilder.

Roy tried. It never sounded like him. By 1958, Sun had let him go. He had moved to Nashville and was writing songs for other people for a few dollars here and there, sleeping on friends’ couches, trying to keep a young wife and a new baby in groceries.

A small record label in Nashville called Monument had signed him, run by a quiet, stubborn producer named Fred Foster, who believed in Roy’s voice when almost nobody else did. But the first records on Monument had gone nowhere. That winter, Roy had started to believe the thing that every struggling singer eventually starts to believe. That maybe the problem was not the songs.

Maybe the problem was him. So, when he and his writing partner, a young Texan named Joe Melson, sat down one night and wrote a song that made the hair stand up on both their arms, Roy did not think, “This is my hit.” He thought, “This is a hit for somebody. For somebody with a real voice. Somebody people already wanted to hear.” And there was only one somebody like that in the whole world.

Elvis Presley had been home from the army for less than 2 weeks. He had spent 2 years in Germany as a private in the third armored division, driving a Jeep and sleeping in barracks, and the entire music business had held its breath the whole time, waiting to see whether he would still matter when he came back. Nobody knew. That was the truth of it.

Rock and roll had changed while he was gone. Buddy Holly was dead. Little Richard had quit to become a preacher. Jerry Lee Lewis had been run out of the business by a scandal.

Chuck Berry was in trouble with the law. The radio was full of smooth, clean-cut teen idols that the record companies could control. People in the industry were saying, quietly, that rock and roll had been a fad, and the fad was over. And Elvis had come home to an empty house.

His mother had died while he was in uniform. Graceland still had her things in it. He walked around the rooms at night, unable to sleep the way he had in Germany. Colonel Tom Parker, his manager, had wasted no time.

There was a recording session booked in Nashville in a few days. There was a television special with Frank Sinatra in a couple of weeks. There were movies lined up for the rest of the year. Everything depended on the first record Elvis made after the army being a smash.

So, Elvis needed songs. Great ones. Everybody in Nashville knew it. And at 3:00 in the morning, two broke young songwriters sat outside his gates with the best song either of them would ever write.

Roy almost drove away. He had his hand on the gear shift. Joe Melson, beside him, said, “Roy, we drove 300 miles. He’s asleep.” Roy said, “It’s 3:00 in the morning.

Nobody’s awake at 3:00 in the morning.” “Elvis is.” Joe said, “Everybody knows Elvis is.” Roy sat there for a long moment staring at the gates. They were the famous ones put up 3 years earlier, wrought iron with musical notes worked into the bars and the figure of a guitar player. In the headlights, they looked like something out of a dream. Then he got out of the car and walked up to the little gatehouse.

The man inside was in his 40s with a lean face and a cigarette and a look that said he had seen every kind of fan, salesman, crank, and hopeful there was. His name was Vester Presley. He was Elvis’s uncle, his father’s brother, and he would guard those gates for most of the next 20 years. “Help you, son?” Vester said.

Roy told him who he was. “Sun Records. Ooby Dooby. Monument.” Vester’s face did not change.

Then Roy said he had a song for Elvis. Vester had heard that sentence perhaps 10,000 times. He started to shake his head and then from the darkness up the long curving drive, there came the sound of a screen door banging shut and footsteps on gravel and a voice called down, “Uncle Vester, who’s that out there?” Vester turned around. “Some boys with a song, Elvis.

Orbison, he says. Used to be at Sun.” There was a pause up in the dark. Then the footsteps started coming down the drive. He came into the light of the gatehouse in a pair of slacks and an untucked shirt and a dark sweater with his army haircut still growing out, black and short at the sides, and his hands in his pockets against the cold.

He looked younger than his pictures. He looked tired. He looked at Roy through the bars of the gate and then at Joe and then past them at the dusty Ford with the guitar in the back seat. “Ooby Dooby,” he said.

Roy blinked. “Yes, sir. I remember you. Sam’s Place, ’56.

You were on that show with Johnny in Texarkana.” Elvis tilted his head. “You sang a ballad at the end. Everybody else was jumping around and you stood there and sang a ballad, like a church.” Roy had no idea what to say. He had not thought Elvis Presley knew his name.

“Uncle Vester,” Elvis said, “let them in.” Vester opened the gate. He did not look happy about it. Elvis walked back up the long drive beside the two young men, past the dark lawn and the big white columns, and in through the front door of Graceland, and none of them said anything at all. The house was very quiet.

A single lamp was burning in the living room. Elvis led them through it, past the long white couch and the big console television, into the little music room at the side, where there was a black piano and a couple of chairs and a stack of records on the floor. “Y’all want a Pepsi?” Elvis said. “Something to eat?

There’s ham.” They said no. They were too nervous to eat. Elvis sat down on the piano bench, turned sideways with his back to the keys and his elbows on his knees. “All right,” he said, “let’s hear it.” Roy went back out to the car for the guitar.

When he came back, his hands were shaking so badly that it took him two tries to get the strap over his head. Joe Melson stood beside him. He was going to sing the low part. Roy took a breath, and then, at about 20 minutes to 4:00 in the morning, in the music room at Graceland, Roy Orbison sang “Only the Lonely” for Elvis Presley.

It started low and simple, with Joe’s voice underneath doing a little rhythmic doo-wop figure, almost like a heartbeat. And then Roy’s voice came in over the top, and it was not like anything Elvis had heard from him at Sun. It was not rockabilly. It was not pop.

It was a lonely man walking down an empty street in the middle of the night telling you quietly about the girl who had gone and the hurt he could not hide. And then, near the end, Roy’s voice did the thing it had been trying to do since he was a boy in Wink. It climbed. It went up into a falsetto so high and so clear and so exposed that it sounded almost like it might break.

And then held there at the very top trembling like a man standing on a ledge. And then it came back down softly to the bottom again. The last chord faded. Nobody moved.

Elvis was sitting exactly as he had been, sideways on the bench, elbows on his knees. But his face had changed. He was looking at Roy the way people looked at Elvis Presley. “Sing it again.” He said quietly.

Roy sang it again. This time he was not shaking. This time, when he got to the high part, he closed his eyes and let it go all the way up. And the note hung there in that small room.

And Elvis Presley did something Joe Melson remembered for the rest of his life. He put one hand over his mouth. When it was over, Elvis was quiet for a long time. Then he said, “Who’s that song for?” Roy swallowed.

“For you.” He said. “If you want it. We wrote it with you in mind, Joe and me. You need songs for your session.

Everybody knows it. We figured” He stopped. “We figured you could sing it better than anybody.” Elvis did not answer right away. He knew exactly what he had just heard.

He had been making records for six years. He had heard a few thousand songs pitched to him by now in offices and hotel rooms and backstage corridors. And he knew the way you know when a song was a hit. This one was not just a hit.

This one was a monster. This was a song that would go to the top of the charts anywhere in the world it was released. It was precisely the kind of song the Colonel had been telling him he needed. A big emotional grown-up ballad to prove that the kid who had gone into the army had come out a man and a singer and not a fad.

And these two broke boys from Texas were handing it to him for nothing. For a songwriting credit and whatever the publisher paid them. Standing in his music room at 4:00 in the morning with their hearts in their hands. All he had to say was yes.

Elvis looked at the floor for a while. Then he looked up. “Roy,” he said, “sing me just the high part, the top, just that.” Roy sang it. Just the climb and the falsetto at the very top without the guitar.

Elvis listened with his eyes closed. Then he opened them. “I can’t sing that,” he said. Roy laughed nervously.

“Sure you can. You can sing anything.” “No,” Elvis said. “I mean, I could hit the notes, probably. I could make a record of it.

It would sell.” He shook his head slowly. “But I can’t sing that. Not like that. Nobody can sing it like that.” He looked at Roy steadily.

“Roy, that ain’t my song.” The room was very quiet. “That’s yours,” Elvis said. Roy stared at him. “Elvis,” Joe Melson said carefully, “with respect, we’ve been trying to get Roy a hit for 2 years.

It ain’t happened. We need this to be on a record somebody buys.” “Somebody will buy it,” Elvis said. “Millions of somebodies, as long as it’s him singing it.” Roy found his voice. “I can’t,” he said, and it came out rougher than he meant it to.

“Elvis, you don’t understand. I’ve got a wife and a baby boy. I’ve got about $11. Sam Phillips let me go.

I’ve got one more chance at Monument and if this record don’t hit, I’m going back to Texas to work in the oil fields like my daddy. I can’t take a chance like that on my own voice. Nobody wants to hear my voice. They want to hear yours.

Elvis looked at him for a long moment. Then he said something Roy Orbison told only a handful of people in his whole life. “When I was 19,” Elvis said, “I sang at the Grand Ole Opry one time. They told me my voice was wrong.

A man there told me I ought to go back to driving a truck. I cried all the way home to Memphis in the back of the car.” He shrugged. “If Sam Phillips hadn’t let me sing it my way, the way it come out of me, I’d still be driving that truck. You know that?

I’d be driving it right now.” He nodded at the guitar in Roy’s hands. “You go sing it the way you just sang it for me, son. You don’t hide that high part. You don’t make it sound like me.

You make it sound like you were scared to death when you sang it because you were. I watched you.” Nobody said anything. “If I take that song,” Elvis said quietly, “I’ll have a hit for a couple of months and you’ll spend the rest of your life writing songs for other people to sing because you’ll believe the thing they told you, that your voice ain’t good enough.” He shook his head. “And it’d be the biggest lie anybody ever told in this house.” He turned around on the bench, faced the keys, and played a few slow chords, the opening of the song, picking it out by ear, the way he picked out everything.

Then he stopped. “You know what Sam told me the first day?” he said without looking up. “I’d been singing all these Dean Martin songs and Ink Spots songs, trying to sound like somebody on the radio. And Sam said, ‘Son, I already got all those records.

I don’t need another one. I need to hear what you sound like when you ain’t trying to sound like nobody.'” He played one more chord and let it ring. Took me all night to figure out what he meant. Roy said nothing.

He was holding the guitar against his chest like a shield. Elvis stood up from the piano bench. Go on home, Roy, he said gently. Go to Nashville.

Tell Fred Foster you’re singing it yourself. And if anybody tells you different, you tell them Elvis Presley turned it down because he couldn’t sing it as good as you. It was almost 5:00 in the morning when the two young men walked back down the drive to their car. Elvis walked with them as far as the gate.

The sky over Highway 51 was just beginning to go gray. Vester Presley opened the gate without a word and closed it behind them. Elvis stood on the other side of the bars with his hands back in his pockets. Roy, he said.

Roy turned around. When you cut it, Elvis said, don’t let them put a bunch of strings all over the top part. Let it be naked up there. Let people hear you.

Roy nodded. He could not trust himself to say anything. Then Elvis turned and walked back up the long drive toward the house and the two young men stood beside the dusty Ford and watched him go until he disappeared around the curve under the trees. Joe Melson said, did that just happen?

Roy didn’t answer. He got in the car and put the guitar on the back seat and sat behind the wheel for a long time without starting the engine. They drove to Nashville without the radio on. Somewhere past Jackson, Tennessee, with the sun coming up over the flat brown fields, Joe Melson finally said what both of them had been thinking.

He could have had it, Roy, for nothing. It would have been number one by summer. I know. So why did he give it back?

Roy kept his eyes on the road for a long time. I don’t know, he said at last. I think maybe he wasn’t talking about me. Joe looked at him.

What’s that mean? I don’t know what it means, Roy said. It’s just how it felt. They stopped for gas and coffee in a little town off highway 70.

While Joe paid, Roy went to the payphone on the wall outside and called home collect. Claudette answered on the first ring. She had been up all night waiting. Well, she said, did he take it?

No, Roy said. There was a silence on the line. He could hear the baby fussing in the background. Oh, honey, Claudette said softly.

I’m so sorry. Don’t be, Roy said, and he was surprised to hear that his voice was steady. He said I should sing it myself. Another silence.

Elvis Presley said that? Elvis Presley said that. Claudette started to laugh and then to cry and then to laugh again, and Roy stood at a payphone outside a gas station in the middle of Tennessee at 7:00 in the morning grinning like a fool while a farmer in a pickup truck stared at him. Fred Foster at Monument Records was a careful, quiet man, and when Roy walked into his office 2 days later and told him he wanted to record the song himself and why, Fred took off his glasses and cleaned them very slowly with his handkerchief and put them back on.

Elvis Presley told you that, he said. Yes, sir. At 4:00 in the morning. About 4:00.

Yes, sir. Fred thought about it. Then he picked up the telephone and booked the studio. The studio was RCA’s Studio B on 17th Avenue, a plain brick building on what people were starting to call Music Row.

Some of the best musicians in Nashville played there almost every day, and it happened to be the very same studio where, in a matter of days, Elvis Presley was booked to record his first songs since coming home from the army. Roy’s session was a long one. The song was harder in a studio than it had been in a music room at 4:00 in the morning. The musicians kept wanting to play it bigger.

The engineer kept wanting to tuck Roy’s voice down into the mix, safe and comfortable, the way records were made in Nashville in those days. And every time Roy heard a voice in his head saying, “Let it be naked up there. Let people hear you.” So, he asked them to take things away. Fewer strings on the top.

Let the backing singers do the heartbeat. Let the falsetto stand alone. On the last take, near the end, when Roy’s voice climbed to the very top and held there, trembling, the engineer took his hands off the faders. Nobody in the control room breathed.

Fred Foster said afterward that he knew at that exact moment that Roy Orbison was going to be a star. There is a story that people in Nashville told for years afterward, and like a lot of good Nashville stories, nobody can quite agree on who saw it first. The story goes that a few evenings later, during a break in one of Elvis’s own sessions at Studio B, somebody put a reel on the playback machine in the control room, a rough mix of a new song somebody had cut there that week for a little label called Monument. And Elvis Presley, who had been joking around with the Jordanaires and drinking a Pepsi and eating a cheeseburger, stopped what he was doing and listened to the whole thing, standing very still in the doorway.

When it ended, one of the musicians said, “Man, who is that? That kid can sing.” And Elvis said, “That’s Roy Orbison.” And smiled a little and went back into the studio to cut his own record and never said another word about it. Only the lonely came out that spring. It went up the American charts like a rocket, all the way to number two.

In Britain, it went to number one. It sold more than a million copies. And for the first time in his life, Roy Orbison heard his own voice coming out of car radios and jukeboxes and drug store speakers all over America, climbing up to that impossible high note and holding it there. And people turning their heads to listen.

Nobody had ever sung like that on a pop record before. Disc jockeys did not know what to call it. Critics did not know what to call it. Teenagers did not care what it was called.

They just bought it. Within a year, Roy Orbison had another hit, then another. Running Scared, Crying, In Dreams. He started wearing dark glasses on stage, partly because he had left his regular ones on an airplane once and had nothing else to wear, and the look stuck.

He became, within a few short years, one of the most famous and most imitated singers in the world. And he never once forgot who had told him to sing it himself. The first check went out in the autumn of 1960. Roy had just received the first real royalty statement of his life.

He sat at the kitchen table in a small rented house outside Nashville with his wife Claudette and stared at the number on it for a long time. Then, he took out his checkbook and wrote a second check for a little less than half of the amount and made it out to Elvis A. Presley. On the memo line, he wrote, “For the song you gave back.” He mailed it to Graceland. 10 days later, it came back.

It was in a plain white envelope addressed in handwriting Roy did not recognize, probably one of the secretaries in the office behind the house. Inside was his own check, uncashed. Clipped to it was a small piece of Graceland notepaper with three words written on it in a looping hand. “Wrong address, Roy.” And underneath, a single letter, E.

Claudette laughed until she cried. Roy did not think it was funny at all. He was a careful, proper man, raised to pay his debts, and he did not like owing anybody anything. So, the next spring after the next royalty statement, he wrote another check and mailed it again.

It came back again. Same envelope, same handwriting. This time the note said, “Still the wrong address.” That Christmas, Roy tried something different. He wrote a check for $1, one single dollar, made out to Elvis A.

Presley with the same words on the memo line, “For the song you gave back.” He figured nobody could refuse a dollar. It came back in January with a note that said, “Too much.” And so, it became a kind of ritual between them, a private joke between two of the most famous singers in the world that almost nobody else knew about. Every Christmas, a check for $1 would go from Roy Orbison’s house to Graceland, and every January it would come back uncashed with a new note, “Nice try. Not this year, either.” “Buy yourself some new glasses.” The year Roy’s “Ooh, Pretty Woman” went to number one on both sides of the Atlantic, the note said only, “Told you.” There were hard years in between, terrible ones.

Roy lost his wife Claudette in a motorcycle accident in 1966. Two years later, a fire took his home in Hendersonville and two of his young sons with it. For a long time after that, Roy did not write songs, and he did not send checks. And his career, which had once seemed unstoppable, slowly slipped out of the charts.

He told a friend years afterward that during those years, the strangest thing kept arriving in his mailbox every January, even though he had not sent anything in December, a plain white envelope from Memphis. No check inside, just a small piece of Graceland notepaper, and on it, every year, the same three words, “Still the wrong address.” He kept every one of them. Back in Memphis, the ritual had not gone unnoticed. 1 January, Colonel Tom Parker happened to be in the office behind Graceland when the secretary was putting one of Roy’s dollar checks back into an envelope.

The Colonel picked it up, read it, read the note clipped to it, and walked straight into the house to find Elvis. “Son,” he said, holding up the check, “I have been in this business for 30 years and I have never once seen anybody mail money back. Not once. What in the world are you doing?” Elvis looked at the check and started to laugh.

“It ain’t money, Colonel,” he said, “it’s Roy. It’s a check. It’s a joke,” Elvis said, “between me and Roy. You wouldn’t get it.” The Colonel, who had a carnival man’s instinct for when a conversation was not going to make him any richer, put the check down on the table and walked out shaking his head.

Elvis’s cousin, Billy Smith, who was sitting on the couch, said later that it was the only time he ever saw anybody leave the Colonel without a word to say. It was December 1976 at the Las Vegas Hilton. Elvis was 41 years old and he had been playing that showroom for 7 years, two shows a night, thousands of shows by now. He was heavier than he had been, more tired, but when the curtain went up and the band hit the first notes, the room still came out of its seats for him.

Roy Orbison was sitting at a table near the back. He was 40 years old. His hair was still jet black, his dark glasses still on even in a night club at midnight. He had come with a few friends quietly without telling anyone.

The way a man goes to see an old acquaintance he is not sure will remember him. Somewhere in the middle of the show, between songs, while Elvis was wiping his face with a towel and drinking a glass of water and making jokes with the band, one of the backup singers leaned over and said something in his ear. Elvis looked up and shaded his eyes against the spotlight. He squinted toward the back of the room.

Then he grinned. “Ladies and gentlemen,” he said into the microphone. “I’ve just been told we have somebody very special here tonight. And I want y’all to do me a favor.

I want everybody in this room to stand up.” 2,000 people stood up, confused, looking around. “Because sitting back there,” Elvis said, “in the dark glasses, trying real hard not to be noticed, is the greatest singer in the world, Mr. Roy Orbison.” The spotlight swung to the back of the room and found Roy sitting very still at his table, looking like a man who would rather be anywhere else on Earth. The room went wild.

Roy stood up slowly and lifted one hand, and the applause went on and on. “Come on up here, Roy,” Elvis called. “Come sing one.” Roy shook his head firmly and stayed exactly where he was. The audience laughed.

Everybody who knew anything about Roy Orbison knew he would sooner walk through fire than get up on somebody else’s stage uninvited. “No?” Elvis said. He put his hands on his hips and looked out at the room with mock outrage. “16 years I’ve been waiting, and he says no. All right, then.” He turned to the band.

“Then I’ll just have to sing his.” The room laughed again, not understanding the joke, and Roy, at the table near the back, put his face in his hand because he understood it perfectly. And while it was still going, Elvis turned to the band and said something. And the piano player grinned and started playing a soft, slow figure that everybody in the room over the age of 30 recognized immediately. Only the lonely.

The Sweet Inspirations came in on the backing part, the little heartbeat rhythm underneath, and Elvis Presley stepped up to the microphone and sang the first verse of Roy Orbison’s song low and easy in front of the man who wrote it. He sounded good, better than good. The room went quiet to listen. And then he got to the part near the end, the climb, the place where the voice goes up and up into that impossible falsetto and holds there trembling at the very top.

Elvis took a deep breath. He went for it, and his voice cracked so completely, so loudly, so spectacularly that it sounded like a goose stepping on a rake. The band fell apart laughing. The Sweet Inspirations had to turn around.

2,000 people roared, and Elvis stood there in the middle of the stage in his white jumpsuit holding the microphone at arm’s length and staring at it as if it had betrayed him. And then he pointed straight at the back of the room. “See?” he shouted. “I told him.

I told him in 1960. I told him I couldn’t sing it.” At the table near the back, Roy Orbison, the most famously serious man in rock and roll, had taken off his dark glasses and was laughing so hard he had to hold on to the back of a chair. After the show, Roy went backstage. Elvis was sitting in the dressing room in a robe with a towel around his neck.

When Roy came through the door, Elvis stood up and threw his arms around him, and the two of them stood there for a moment, two men from the same little studio on Union Avenue, 16 years and a whole lifetime later. Then Roy reached into the inside pocket of his jacket and took out a folded piece of paper. It was a check, $1 made out to Elvis A. Presley.

On the memo line, in Roy’s neat handwriting, the same words he had written every year since 1960, “For the song you gave back.” “I came to deliver it in person,” Roy said. “So you can’t say it went to the wrong address.” Elvis looked at the check for a long time. Then he looked at Roy. “You want to know why I did it?” he said.

“That night?” Roy nodded. He had wondered for 16 years. Elvis sat back down on the edge of the dressing table. “I’d been home from the army 10 days,” he said.

“My mama was gone. Everybody in the business was saying I was finished, that rock and roll was over, that nobody’d want to hear me anymore. I was walking around that house every night scared to death they were right, that my voice wasn’t enough without all the rest of it.” He shrugged. “And then you came up my driveway at 3:00 in the morning, scared to death of exactly the same thing, about your voice.

And I figured if I could make you believe yours was good enough, maybe I could believe it about mine.” Roy did not say anything. “Worked, too,” Elvis said. “Went to Nashville a week later and cut my first record after the army. Number one.” He grinned.

“So I reckon we’re even.” Then he took the $1 check out of Roy’s hand, turned it over, took a pen off the dressing table, and wrote something on the back. He handed it back. Roy turned it over and read it. “Pay to the order of Roy Orbison for the best song I never sang.

E.” And this time, both of them were laughing too hard to argue about it. Behind this story sits a real piece of music history. Only the lonely was real, and so was the night it changed Roy Orbison’s life. He wrote it with Joe Melson, a young songwriter from Texas, and recorded it in the spring of 1960 at RCA’s Studio B in Nashville for Fred Foster’s small Monument label in the same building where Elvis was recording his first songs after the army that same season.

It went to number two in America and number one in Britain. Roy later said that he and Joe had thought about offering the song to Elvis and to the Everly Brothers before deciding Roy should record it himself. Nobody can say for certain what Elvis would have done with it, but we know what Roy did with it. He became, almost overnight, a singer unlike anyone else on the radio.

His voice could move across a range that most pop singers never attempted, from a soft, low murmur up to a soaring falsetto. And he built song after song around that climb. Crying, In Dreams, Running Scared, Oh, Pretty Woman. Singers who came after him, from The Beatles to Bruce Springsteen, spoke about him with something close to awe.

And Elvis himself is widely quoted as having called Roy Orbison the greatest singer in the world. They came from the same place, in a way. Both of them walked through the door of Sam Phillips’s little Sun Studio on Union Avenue in Memphis in the mid-1950s. Both of them were told, early on, that their voices did not fit what the business wanted.

Elvis was too strange for country music. Roy was too pure, too operatic for rockabilly. One of them found his way out of that box first. The other followed.

That is what this story is really about, not money, not a song changing hands or not changing hands. It is about the moment when one person who has already been through the fire looks at someone standing where he once stood and tells him the truth. The thing that makes you different is not the problem. It is the whole point.

Elvis Presley is remembered for a great many things. The voice, the hips, the jumpsuits, the screaming crowds. He is less often remembered for how generous he could be toward other singers and for how much doubt he carried about his own gift even at the height of it. In March of 1960, he had just come home from 2 years in the army to a house without his mother and the whole industry was openly wondering whether he still mattered.

He did. His first single after the army, Stuck on You, went straight to number one. But nobody knew that on the night he came back, including him. There is something worth sitting with in that.

The people we admire most often seem certain from the outside. From the inside, they are frequently just as frightened as the rest of us. And the bravest thing they do is not to perform. It is to tell someone else, quietly, at 4:00 in the morning that what they have is enough.

You Might Also Enjoy