Eddie Van Halen Rewired “Beat It” Without Asking — Michael Jackson Brought Him Onstage to Play It
Eddie Van Halen Rewired “Beat It” Without Asking — Michael Jackson Brought Him Onstage to Play It
October 4, 1982. West Hollywood, Westlake Studios, Studio B.
When Eddie Van Halen brought a razor blade down on the master tape of an unreleased Michael Jackson song, he hadn’t asked anyone’s permission. Michael was in the room at the end of the hall, and he had no idea his song was being cut.
Half an hour later, the door opened and Michael Jackson walked in. And in that half hour, a razor blade, a guitar, and the album that would outsell every record ever made were all sitting on the same table.
But the whole thing had started a day earlier with a phone call.
Sunday afternoon, in the living room of the house up in Coldwater Canyon, the phone rang. Eddie picked it up, told the man on the other end exactly what he thought of him, and hung up. It rang again. He hung up again.
On the fourth ring, the voice on the line was calm, and the man who’d just wrecked the first quiet day of his tour break introduced himself.
“It’s Quincy,” he said.
Eddie went through every Quincy he knew and came up empty.
“Quincy Jones, man.”
The color drained out of Eddie’s face. Valerie leaned out of the kitchen. Eddie held up a hand to stop her and gripped the receiver with both hands.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “What can I do for you?”
Quincy Jones was the biggest record producer in the world. He’d recorded Sinatra. He’d recorded Ray Charles.
Now he was making Michael Jackson’s new album, and on it there was a rock song with a hole in the middle where a guitar solo was supposed to go. Could he come by tomorrow?
Eddie stood there listening to the hum of the amp in the living room. It had been on since morning.
“I’ll see you at your studio tomorrow,” he said.
After he hung up, he just stood there. Michael Jackson, the kid who sang “ABC.” What was a Van Halen guitar player supposed to do on that record?
Valerie was leaning in the kitchen doorway.
“Who is that?”
“Quincy Jones,” Eddie said. “He wants a solo on Michael Jackson’s record.”
Valerie laughed. Then she saw Eddie wasn’t laughing, and she stopped.
“What’s Dave going to say?”
What Dave was going to say was obvious. Van Halen had an unwritten rule. Nobody did work outside the band unless all four of them signed off on it.
But that week, David Lee Roth was somewhere in the Amazon. Michael Anthony was at Disneyland with his family. Alex was up in Canada on the edge of some lake where nobody could reach him.
Eddie switched off the amp, and the room went quiet.
“Nobody’s going to find out,” he said. “It’s half an hour of work. Who’s going to hear it?”
When he pulled into the Westlake parking lot Monday afternoon, there were three things in the backseat: the red guitar he’d built himself, a British-made amp he’d borrowed from Allan Holdsworth, and a six-pack of beer.
He’d bought the beer himself. It hadn’t occurred to him to wait for somebody to offer.
Don Landy was with him, the man who’d recorded every Van Halen album. Eddie had the sleeves of his turquoise linen shirt rolled to the elbow, and the cuffs of his torn light blue jeans hung over a pair of beat-up white Converse.
He carried the amp in himself.
Quincy Jones was waiting at the door of Studio B. Tall, gray hair, glasses. The handshake was firm and short.
“You came,” he said. “Told you it wasn’t a joke.”
Eddie grinned, and while he was grinning, he looked down the hall. Behind the door at the end of it, in Studio A, was Michael Jackson.
But Michael wasn’t there for Eddie that day. Quincy explained, “Michael and Bruce Swedien were recording an album for Spielberg’s new movie, something called E.T. the Alien Kid.”
Thriller and E.T. were being made in the same hallway, the same week, by the same crew.
“You’re in here,” Quincy said, pushing open the door to B. “I’ll introduce you to Michael later. Right now, listen to the song.”
Studio B was cold, and it smelled like carpet. Swedien had set the air conditioning, and nobody touched it.
Behind the control room glass, two 24-track tape machines sat side by side. Two machines, two tapes, one song.
“Swedien’s system,” Landy said, keeping his voice down. “One’s the original, the other’s the copy. There’s an invisible thread between them that keeps them locked to the same second. Bruce never plays the original. He keeps it in the vault.”
Eddie nodded. He respected that. He was the same way. Build two of something so nothing breaks.
That’s when Bruce Swedien walked in. A short man, white beard, calm as a lake.
Eddie had the amp on and was tuning up, and the moment he hit the first note, Swedien’s face changed. He turned for the door.
“I’ll be in A,” he told Landy. “You’re taking this one. I can’t put my ears in front of that volume. I need them for another 40 years.”
And he left. Eddie watched him go. He wasn’t angry. He laughed.
The man had walked out of Michael Jackson’s studio to protect his own ears. Eddie understood that. A man who takes care of his tools is a man who takes care of his work.
Quincy played the tape. When the song came through the control room speakers, Eddie was sitting on top of the amp, guitar in his lap, tapping his foot on the carpet.
No drums yet, just Michael’s voice and the sound of a hand slapping a drum case on the two and the four.
The song was called “Beat It.” It was hard, harder than anything Michael had ever done. Eddie didn’t listen to the words. He listened to where the song was going.
And when the song reached the spot they’d left for the solo, it stopped going anywhere.
Sixteen bars, one note, the same riff, the same riff, the same riff. Eddie’s foot stopped tapping.
“What do you want me to do?” he asked Quincy.
“Whatever you want.”
Eddie got up off the amp and walked to the console without taking the guitar off his neck.
“Be careful how you say that,” he said. “If you know anything about me, be careful with ‘whatever you want.'”
Quincy laughed. He thought it was a joke. Eddie wasn’t joking.
He wanted to hear the solo section again. Landy rolled the tape back. Sixteen bars of one note. When it was done, he gave the neck a turn and looked through the glass at the machines.
“The solo’s got nowhere to go,” he said. “That’s a flat wall. Whatever I play over it, I’m playing against a wall.”
Something crossed Quincy’s face. He and Michael had picked those 16 bars together. They’d wanted something hard and repetitive, something like “My Sharona.”
To them, that was the most exciting part of the song. To Eddie, it was a parking lot.
“What are you suggesting?” Quincy said.
“Let me play over the verse. Give the solo somewhere to go, then let it land in the chorus. Change the middle.”
Quincy was quiet a second. Then he looked at his watch. At the other end of the hall, the alien kid was waiting.
“Talk to Landy,” he said. “I’m going back to A. I’ll be back in an hour.”
And he was gone.
When the door closed, there were three left in the room: Eddie, Landy, and the two tape machines.
Landy knew what was being asked. For 10 years, he’d understood what Eddie wanted before the sentence was over. Copy the verse, splice it into the middle, build a new 16 bars for the solo. He’d done it a thousand times on Van Halen tapes.
He opened the drawer by the console, took out the razor blade, and stopped.
“Ed,” he said, “this is Bruce’s tape.”
“I know.”
“It’s an unreleased Michael Jackson song.”
“I know.”
“The two tapes are tied together, Ed. If I cut one, the other—”
Landy didn’t finish the sentence. He didn’t know exactly what would happen. He only knew it wouldn’t be good.
Eddie took the razor out of Landy’s hand.
“If I don’t cut it, I’m playing against a wall. I cut it. If they get mad, they get mad.”
They pulled the tape off the machine, held it up to the light, marked the spot where the verse began. Eddie cut, Landy spliced.
The tape went back on the machine, wound up, and out of the control room speakers came a different “Beat It”: a longer middle, a song that moved under the solo.
Eddie listened and grinned.
“There,” he said, “now it’s going somewhere.”
The room smelled like hot tubes. Holdsworth’s amp had been on for 40 minutes, and it was cooking. Landy hit record, and Eddie played the first take.
When the solo came back through the control room speakers, the coffee cup on the desk was rattling.
The first take was good.
Eddie said, “One more.”
Landy rolled it back. The second take started. Eddie wasn’t looking at his own reflection in the control room glass; he was looking at the door behind it, where the red recording light was on.
And on the last note of the second take, with the red light still on, the door opened.
Light from the hallway fell into the control room. The man standing in the doorway wasn’t Quincy. It was Michael Jackson.
He was 24, and standing there with the hall light behind him, he looked thinner than he was. A dark, plain jacket. He’d arrived before his voice did, because when Michael Jackson walked into a room, the silence in it changed.
Landy pulled his hand back from the record button. Eddie rolled off the guitar’s volume, and the hum of the amp drew up into the ceiling.
Either he calls his bodyguards or he likes it. There’s no middle.
“I’m going to tell you something before you listen,” Eddie said. His voice was normal. He wasn’t grinning. “I changed the middle of your song.”
Michael closed the door behind him. He didn’t say anything. He walked to the console, looked at Landy. Landy looked at Eddie, and Eddie nodded.
“Play it.”
Landy rolled the tape. The new “Beat It” filled the control room. Michael’s voice, the hand on the drum case, then the stretched-out middle section, and over it a guitar climbing and falling, going somewhere.
Michael didn’t move while it played. Eddie sat on the amp and stared at a stain in the carpet.
Two smells in the room: the hot tubes and a faint cologne off Michael’s jacket that didn’t belong in a studio.
The solo ended. The chorus came in. Landy stopped the tape. Michael turned to Landy first, then to Eddie.
There was something on his face, but it wasn’t a smile yet.
“You cut the middle out,” he said.
“Yes.”
“Without asking me?”
“Yes.”
Michael touched the edge of the console like he was touching the tape itself.
“You could have come in here and just played a solo,” he said. “Everybody would have. Show up, play, leave. You listen to the song and you fix the part you didn’t like.”
He paused.
“You cared about the song. Thank you.”
Eddie didn’t answer. He turned the volume knob one full turn, then turned it back.
For him, somebody saying you cared was harder to take than somebody saying you were great. He knew how to wave off a compliment, not that one.
He stood up and lifted the guitar off his neck.
“It needed somewhere to go,” he said finally. “If a solo’s supposed to go somewhere, the song under it has to go, too.”
Michael nodded. Then he pointed at the guitar.
“What is that?”
“This?”
Eddie held it up. Red body, black and white stripes, a cable that looked like it had been pulled out from behind a closet.
“Built it out of parts. Body was 50 bucks, neck was 80. Put the pickup in myself. Sprayed the paint in the garage. It’s got one knob, and the knob says ‘tone,’ but it’s the volume.”
He grinned.
“Nobody gets it, and I don’t correct them.”
The thing on Michael’s face finally turned into a smile.
“I made the song at home,” he said, “in my own studio. Quincy came over and said, ‘The train’s leaving,’ and I said, ‘It’s not done, but listen.'”
Eddie laughed. Two men standing over things they’d built themselves, and neither one of them ashamed the thing wasn’t finished.
Michael looked at the razor blade sitting next to the console. It was still there, beside the coffee cup.
“Who cut the tape?”
Landy opened his mouth. Eddie spoke first.
“Me.”
“With your engineer right there?”
“It was my idea,” Eddie said. “You don’t let somebody else hold the razor for your idea.”
He shrugged.
“If it was wrong, I wanted it to be me who wrecked your tape, not him. It turned out right, so I guess it was me who did that, too.”
Michael didn’t say anything, but he didn’t look at the razor again. He looked at Eddie, and the look lasted a little longer than it needed to.
Landy, watching from behind, saw something he’d known for 10 years. Eddie’s best moments weren’t on the guitar. They were in the two minutes after he set it down.
When Quincy Jones came back in, he found two men laughing and an engineer.
He listened to the tape. He leaned over the console, listened twice, nodded on the third, and turned to Eddie.
“That was half an hour,” he said. “Half an hour’s plenty. Least I can do is buy you a beer.”
Eddie pointed behind the amp. The six-pack was sitting there, two missing.
“Brought my own,” he said. “Didn’t cross my mind that anybody’d offer.”
Quincy laughed, then stopped laughing and held out a piece of paper, a Musicians Union form. Everybody who played had to sign one.
Eddie took the pen and wrote his name. He didn’t look at the line for the fee. Nobody pointed it out to him, either.
Then Eddie carried the amp out himself, put the guitar in its case, and shook Michael Jackson’s hand. The handshake was soft and short, a singer’s hand.
As he went out the door, Michael called after him.
“Eddie.”
Eddie turned.
“Next time you want to change something,” Michael said, “don’t ask then, either.”
Eddie grinned and left. It was coming up on 5:00 when he got into his car in the parking lot.
Half an hour of work. Who was going to hear about it? For Eddie, the half-hour detour was over.
The real trouble would start the next morning when the doors at Westlake opened again.
Bruce Swedien started both machines at the same time, and something happened, something that wasn’t supposed to. The invisible thread that ran the two tapes together had snapped.
Michael’s vocal was playing in one place, and the music behind it was playing somewhere else entirely. The razor had cut that thread in two, and now the two halves didn’t recognize each other.
Swedien stopped the machines. He called Quincy. The two men stood behind the glass and looked at the tape.
Michael’s vocal and Eddie’s solo were sitting there safe and sound. Everything was there, except the song underneath.
“I’m not re-recording the vocal,” Quincy said. “First generation stays. The solo, too.”
Swedien agreed. He wasn’t going to have that tape recorded over, which left one road: rebuild the rest of the song around that tape, backwards.
Quincy picked up the phone and called Steve Lukather. Lukather, Toto’s guitar player, Eddie’s friend, the man Quincy had gotten Eddie’s number from.
He listened once, then asked again.
“What’s on the tape?”
Michael’s voice, Eddie’s solo, and the sound of Michael’s hand slapping a drum case on the two and the four.
“That’s it.”
That was it.
“And I’m building it backwards.”
“Backwards?”
“When?”
“Today.”
Westlake was full. E.T. and Thriller were sharing the hallway.
So Lukather took the tape to Sunset Sound, and with him went Jeff Porcaro, Toto’s drummer. Two men sat in an empty studio with a tape machine and Michael’s voice.
The situation was flat-out impossible. What they had was Michael’s naked vocal and Eddie’s solo. No drums, no bass, not a single beat to tell them the tempo of the song.
Porcaro put on the headphones and went quiet. A long time. Then he heard it.
Behind Michael’s vocal, far off, something bleeding through. When Michael sang, he’d been listening to the backing track in his own headphones. And a trace of it had leaked into the microphone.
Porcaro clicked his sticks together. He locked them to the bleed. A human metronome. Then he played his drums on top of that metronome. Two takes.
Lukather laid his rhythm guitar over it, then the bass. He wasn’t a bass player, but the song’s bass was simple.
By evening, “Beat It” existed again. Quincy came in and listened.
“Too hard,” he said. “I’m putting this on pop radio. Get out your little amp and don’t crank it all the way. Push, but don’t shove.”
Lukather understood. He pulled out the small Fender and played it again. The song softened. The solo didn’t.
In the middle, at the place Eddie had cut, a guitar was still going somewhere.
Eddie saw none of it. On October 7th, he was in New Haven, on stage. When Landy called him two weeks later and told him the whole thing, Eddie was sitting on the edge of a hotel bed.
And when the story was over, he didn’t talk for a while.
“Porcaro got the tempo off headphone bleed?” he finally asked.
“Yes.”
Eddie laughed. He pressed the receiver against his cheek and laughed.
“The man’s a drummer,” he said. “I couldn’t have found that.”
Then he went quiet.
“Is Quincy mad?”
He wasn’t. Nobody was. The song was finished and the solo was right where it belonged.
In July of 1984, Michael Jackson took the stage in Dallas with his brothers. The stadium was full and the Texas night was hot.
When “Beat It” started, a man walked in from the side of the stage: turquoise shirt, torn jeans, red guitar. Some of the crowd knew him. Most didn’t. A guitar player was walking onto Michael Jackson’s stage. That was all.
Michael didn’t even turn around. He knew where he’d be. The solo came, and Eddie Van Halen played it. Grinning, left foot up on the monitor, a solo going somewhere.
Seventy thousand people weren’t hearing him for the first time that night. He’d been on every radio for two years. But that night, for the first time, they saw who he was.
When it was over, Michael turned to him and said something nobody in the stadium heard. Eddie laughed. Nobody asked what it was.
The master tape of an unreleased song was still sitting in the vault at Westlake. A tape with a razor scar somewhere in the middle of it.