News

“Buddy Rich Said Ringo Couldn’t Play, But He Was Completely Wrong!”: Phil Collins Names His Eight Favourite Drummers

“Buddy Rich Said Ringo Couldn’t Play, But He Was Completely Wrong!”: Phil Collins Names His Eight Favourite Drummers

The cultural renaissance surrounding Phil Collins in modern music history serves as a powerful reminder of his monumental impact on global percussion.

For decades, the public viewed him primarily through the lens of radio-friendly pop ballads and towering mainstream commercial success.

Yet beneath the glittering surface of his chart-topping solo career and his legendary tenure with Genesis lies a musician whose core identity has never wavered.

Phil Collins has always considered himself a dedicated drummer first and a pop singer second.

Even when global fame thrust him into the blinding spotlight following Peter Gabriel’s departure in the mid-nineteen-seventies, his heart remained firmly rooted behind the drum kit.

He has repeatedly confessed in candid interviews that standing at the front of the stage never felt as entirely natural as holding drumsticks in his hands.

This unwavering reverence for the rhythmic craft defines his entire artistic worldview and explains his lifelong admiration for the masters of his instrument.

When Collins recently opened up to name his eight absolute favorite drummers of all time, he offered a masterclass in music history and technical appreciation.

His selections trace a fascinating lineage from understated pop innovation to thunderous rock power and supernatural jazz discipline.

At the very foundation of his drumming education stands none other than The Beatles legend, Ringo Starr.

Mainstream music critics and hostile jazz purists during the nineteen-seventies frequently attempted to dismiss Ringo as a simplistic or unskilled performer.

Legendary big band bandleader Buddy Rich notoriously claimed that Ringo could not even play the drums properly.

Phil Collins has always fiercely rejected these absurd assertions with absolute conviction and unwavering respect.

In Collins’s experienced view, Ringo Starr was the brilliant unsung hero behind countless immortal songs that shaped modern popular culture.

While casual listeners focused entirely on John Lennon’s biting lyrics or Paul McCartney’s soaring melodies, Collins zeroed in on Ringo’s revolutionary approach to rhythm.

He points to groundbreaking tracks like Tomorrow Never Knows where Ringo’s hypnotic drumming creates an otherworldly sonic texture.

He marvels at the complex, unconventional drum fills painted across the canvas of Strawberry Fields Forever.

He highlights Rain as another prime example of Ringo’s astonishing ability to construct tricky feels that a normal drummer would never naturally think to play.

Ringo brought a level of sophisticated subtlety to pop music that continues to resonate profoundly decades after its initial recording.

Long before he ever sat behind a professional drum kit, Collins was already banging out complex rhythms on ordinary household objects in his childhood home.

The profound sense of wonder he felt upon realizing that drums could be just as crucial to a song as any electric guitar riff stayed with him forever.

Ringo made the backbeat genuinely cool and something essential to listen for rather than something merely to be ignored in the mix.

For a young Collins fighting to elevate the status of the rhythm section, that paradigm shift was nothing short of absolute revelation.

In stark contrast to Ringo’s understated, mathematically precise style stands The Who’s immortal powerhouse, Keith Moon.

Keith Moon operated as a terrifying tornado of reckless energy and unrestrained creative anarchy.

Pop culture lore is permanently saturated with wild stories of Moon’s legendary hotel room destructions, exploding toilets, and setting drum kits ablaze on live television.

Yet Collins understands that the true genius of Keith Moon resided far away from his offstage theatrical antics.

The real magic lived inside Moon’s completely unconventional and boundary-pushing approach to rhythmic construction.

Collins fondly remembers witnessing Moon perform Won’t Get Fooled Again live with his headphones securely taped to his head.

Watching Moon tear into his massive drum kit with wild abandon felt precisely like witnessing a bolt of lightning strike the stage.

His performance style was entirely unpredictable, wildly erratic, and utterly mesmerizing to every musician watching from the wings.

Traditional drummers construct predictable rhythmic patterns, but Keith Moon actively smashed them to pieces.

His explosive fills did not merely punctuate a song structure; they completely reimagined it from the ground up.

He transformed even the most straightforward rock rhythms into a frenetic, pulsing lifeblood that drove the entire band forward.

This was never a display of sterile technical precision, but rather an exhibition of pure, unadulterated primal instinct.

For Collins, who has always championed drumming as a deeply visceral and emotional experience, Moon’s liberating influence was immeasurable.

Moving from anarchic fury to thunderous, disciplined might brings us to the legendary Led Zeppelin powerhouse, John Bonham.

John Bonham stands forever as the ultimate archetype of heavy rock drumming.

His uncompromising playing style operated as a physical force of nature and a relentless machine of sonic devastation.

Collins remembers watching Bonham perform live with an intensity that felt almost primal and terrifying.

It seemed as though the acoustic drums were not merely musical instruments, but direct physical extensions of Bonham’s massive body.

Armed with his legendary iron-footed bass drum technique, Bonham introduced an unprecedented level of raw power to rock music.

He turned the drum kit into an offensive weapon just as much as an expressive musical instrument.

While Collins deeply admired Bonham’s staggering rhythmic ferocity, he held an equal appreciation for his astonishing technical finesse.

Bonham was never merely loud for the sake of noise; he possessed an impossible level of physical precision.

His razor-sharp drum fills could easily cut through even the densest, most thunderous walls of sound created by Led Zeppelin.

The direct influence of John Bonham echoes clearly across the early studio recordings of Genesis.

During those formative years, Collins channeled that exact same muscular drive and heavy-handed authority into his own playing.

Bonham fundamentally taught him that drumming was about much more than simply keeping steady time for the band.

It was about actively shaping time and bending rhythmic pulses to serve the emotional needs of the song.

Collins has frequently recounted watching Bonham and realizing that the bass drum could operate as a central, melodic voice in an arrangement.

He incorporated that profound lesson into his own drumming with a fierce and unwavering determination.

That booming, full-bodied bass drum sound eventually became an unmistakable Hallmark of Collins’s signature style.

It served as a permanent personal tribute to Bonham’s enduring legacy as the undisputed master of rock percussion.

From the raw energy of rock halls, Collins’s musical education also embraced the refined, jazz-inspired brilliance of Buddy Rich.

Growing up with an omnivorous appetite for big band jazz as well as rock and roll, Collins viewed Rich as the high priest of percussion.

Buddy Rich’s technical skills were so alarmingly advanced that they frequently bordered on the supernatural.

A self-taught prodigy who began drumming before he could properly walk, Rich completely redefined what human hands could achieve on a drum kit.

Collins first encountered Rich’s breathtaking mastery through his iconic West Side Story medley.

That jaw-dropping exhibition of technical execution left the young Collins sitting in stunned silence.

Buddy Rich could execute lightning-fast fills at breakneck speeds without ever sacrificing a single ounce of acoustic clarity.

Every single beat remained surgically precise, and every drum roll flowed with liquid smoothness.

Collins has repeatedly referred to Buddy Rich as the greatest drummer who ever lived, a monumental title he refuses to bestow lightly.

To Collins, Rich represented the absolute pinnacle of relentless discipline, technical perfection, and fierce work ethic.

The profound influence of Buddy Rich is vividly evident in the complex rhythmic intricacies of Collins’s later work.

This influence shone particularly bright during Collins’s ambitious big band touring era in the late nineteen-nineties.

Collins admired Rich so deeply that he spent years preparing himself to step up and lead his own professional big band.

He famously worried initially that he might embarrass himself or the professional jazz musicians by stepping onto their turf.

When he finally took his big band on the road in nineteen-ninety-six, he did so to honor heroes like Buddy Rich and Count Basie.

Rich taught him that even the fastest and most complex rhythms should ultimately feel completely effortless to the listener.

Yet despite his profound love for virtuosic showmen, Collins maintained an equally deep reverence for understated masters of taste.

Chief among these quiet masters is The Rolling Stones’ legendary percussionist, Charlie Watts.

Charlie Watts operated as the serene, zen-like anchor of the otherwise unruly Rolling Stones machine.

His minimalist approach to drumming stood as the absolute antithesis of flashy stage excess.

Watts’s style was defined by strict restraint, surgical precision, and an unflappable internal calm.

In later years, Collins and Watts struck up a genuine personal friendship based on mutual respect.

Collins admired the unique way Watts injected profound subtlety into straightforward rock and roll music.

That specific artistic trait remains exceedingly rare in a genre historically built on loud bombast and visual spectacle.

Charlie Watts never played for the glaring spotlight or sought adoring applause from the front rows.

His drumming was entirely dedicated to supporting the song and allowing the musical arrangement room to breathe.

For Collins, the quiet career of Charlie Watts served as a powerful masterclass in musical humility.

It provided a constant reminder that sometimes the greatest thing a drummer can accomplish is knowing when to step back.

The lineage of drumming greatness also extends directly into Collins’s own family bloodline through his talented son, Nick Collins.

When Phil’s own physical health and neurological issues sadly deteriorated, preventing him from playing live, Nick stepped up to the kit.

Though barely in his early twenties at the time, Nick rose to the monumental challenge with astonishing maturity and technical poise.

Watching his own son take center stage to perform legendary Genesis tracks was a deeply bittersweet experience for Phil.

It marked the definitive end of one golden era while simultaneously sparking the exciting beginning of another.

Nick’s uncanny ability to capture the exact emotional essence of his father’s drumming provided both immense personal comfort and overwhelming paternal pride.

The young drummer infused fresh youthful energy into songs Collins had spent decades mastering.

He proved conclusively that a deep passion for rhythm and that unmistakable legendary Collins sound was genetically coded in his blood.

Another crucial figure in the Genesis family tree is the brilliant Chester Thompson.

When Phil Collins made the massive transition from behind the drum kit to front-stage lead vocalist, he needed someone he could fully trust.

He entrusted Chester Thompson with the daunting responsibility of sharing and maintaining the Genesis drum throne.

Their very first meeting took place on the opening day of band rehearsals for an upcoming tour.

Collins often reflects on how drastically different history might have turned out if they had failed to hit it off musically.

Thompson brought a rich jazz background and extensive experience playing complex compositions with Frank Zappa.

That elite progressive pedigree made him an instantaneous, natural fit for the sophisticated musical demands of Genesis.

Collins recalls an immediate, almost telepathic creative connection with Thompson from the very first minute they played together.

Thompson slipped into the Genesis lineup so seamlessly that it felt as though he had been there from the very beginning.

His extraordinary drumming became a foundational pillar of the band’s massive live arena shows.

That vital rhythmic security allowed Phil Collins to step away from the kit and connect directly with the audience without sacrificing musical integrity.

Finally, the elite roster of influences culminates with the ultimate session legend, Steve Gadd.

Steve Gadd stands globally as a undisputed master of jazz-rock fusion and high-end studio recording.

He brought a level of intellectual sophistication and smooth groove to every single track he ever touched.

Gadd’s legendary career remains a shining testament to unmatched adaptability and creative versatility.

Collins has frequently praised Gadd’s peerless drumming on Steely Dan’s landmark album Aja.

He marvels endlessly at the breathtaking complexity of Gadd’s drum fills and the effortless swing he injected into the music.

Gadd’s revolutionary approach taught Collins the critical importance of pocket and groove.

He learned how to make the acoustic drums feel genuinely alive and breathing underneath a pop arrangement.

During the more experimental musical phases of Genesis, sharp-eared fans can easily detect subtle nods to Steve Gadd’s influence.

Gadd proved to the entire music world that percussion could be simultaneously intellectually intricate and commercially accessible.

For Phil Collins, these eight extraordinary drummers were never mere professional colleagues or passing acquaintances.

They operated as visionary storytellers, each bringing something entirely irreplaceable to the global language of rhythm.

They taught him that drumming transcends physical skill to become a profound, transcendent art form.

Collins’s own celebrated style stands as a magnificent synthesis of these diverse masterclasses.

It represents a unique, powerful fusion of rock muscle, jazz complexity, and a relentless personal drive for innovation.

Even though he achieved global fame and commercial success far beyond what most musicians could ever dare to dream, his core remains unchanged.

He remains at his heart a humble drummer with an enduring love and fierce respect for the ancient craft of percussion.

He remains eternally grateful to the legendary masters who walked the path and laid down the beat long before him.

The history of modern music is filled with fleeting stars who burn brightly for a single season before fading into permanent obscurity.

Phil Collins avoided that tragic fate by anchoring his immense pop success in the unshakeable bedrock of rhythm and groove.

He never allowed the glittering trappings of pop stardom to detach him from his foundational love for the drum kit.

Whenever young musicians ask him for the secret to his longevity, he invariably points them back toward the masters who inspired him.

He encourages every aspiring percussionist to study the past and understand the unique contributions of those who forged the trail.

The eight iconic drummers he chose to honor represent the absolute gold standard of human creativity and technical execution.

From Ringo Starr’s deceptively simple genius to Buddy Rich’s blinding speed, each legend brought a vital ingredient to the table.

Keith Moon injected reckless abandon, while John Bonham provided unmatched thunderous weight.

Charlie Watts demonstrated the supreme power of quiet restraint, and Steve Gadd perfected the ultimate studio groove.

Chester Thompson and Nick Collins proved that rhythm is both a collaborative bridge and a sacred generational inheritance.

Together, this elite pantheon forms the invisible blueprint behind every fill, groove, and beat that Phil Collins ever recorded.

Their collective spirit lives on every time a pair of drumsticks strikes a snare drum with passion and purpose.

Phil Collins ensured that their contributions would never be forgotten by carrying their lessons forward into his own immortal music.

His story stands as permanent proof that true greatness always recognizes and honors the giants upon whose shoulders it stands.

The rhythmic journey of Phil Collins is a testament to the profound emotional power locked inside simple percussion instruments.

Drums do not possess notes or traditional melodies, yet they carry the heartbeat of every musical composition ever written.

The masters he chose to celebrate understood this fundamental truth better than anyone else in the history of audio recording.

They treated every cymbal crash and snare hit as an opportunity to speak directly to the human listener’s spirit.

Phil Collins absorbed those invaluable lessons during his formative years and translated them into chart-topping gold.

He took the complex discipline of jazz and combined it with the raw, driving energy of stadium rock and roll.

The resulting sonic fingerprint became one of the most recognizable and beloved sounds of the twentieth century.

Even as the physical challenges of aging forced him to step back from active touring behind the drum kit, his passion remained undimmed.

He watches with pride as new generations discover his legendary recordings and trace the roots back to his own musical heroes.

The circle of rhythm remains unbroken, passing seamlessly from Buddy Rich and Ringo Starr down through Phil and his son Nick.

It is a glorious continuum built on sweat, wood, metal, and an unyielding dedication to the pursuit of rhythmic perfection.

When we listen to the thunderous intro of In the Air Tonight, we are hearing the direct distillation of a lifetime of studying greatness.

We are hearing the echoes of Zeppelin, The Who, The Beatles, and the greatest jazz halls blended into one singular masterpiece.

Phil Collins named his eight favorite drummers not merely to compile a list, but to pay homage to the architects of his soul.

That profound act of gratitude cements his own legacy as one of the most thoughtful and respected musicians of our time.

The beat goes on forever, driven forward by the eternal ghosts of rhythm and the living legends who keep their fires burning bright.

As long as humanity seeks comfort and expression through music, the foundational beats laid down by these masters will continue to shake the earth.

You Might Also Enjoy