News

Bloody Mary: The Tragedy of England’s First Queen

 

Her name was Mary, the first daughter of Henry VIII of England, and long before anyone called her Bloody Mary, she was a little girl who was promised to three different men before she was even old enough to understand what a promise was worth.

 

She would grow up to become the first woman ever to rule England in her own right, not as somebody’s wife, not as somebody’s mother, but as the crowned and anointed sovereign herself.

 

And she would die 42 years old without a single one of the things she had spent her whole life trying to hold on to.

 

Tonight is the whole of it.

 

Not the five facts people already have about her.

 

All of it, in order, the way she actually lived it.

 

Here’s where we’ll end up, so you know what we’re walking toward.

 

In the autumn of 1558, in a bedchamber at St. James’s Palace, a dying queen told the people around her that when she was gone, they should look at her heart.

 

She said they would find one word written on it.

 

Not her husband’s name, not God’s name, though she’d have said that was written there, too.

 

She said they would find the name of a city, a city she had never set foot in, a city her own kingdom had just lost.

 

We’ll get to why.

 

We’ll get to what that city meant, and why a woman on her deathbed was thinking about geography instead of her own soul.

 

That’s later.

 

Stay with me, and I’ll tell you.

 

Now, let’s go back to the beginning, because the beginning of Mary’s life is stranger than most people realize.

 

Here’s what I want you to sit with tonight.

 

How does a child who’s betrothed to three separate grooms before her 12th birthday and jilted by every one of them end up as a grown woman who still believes, against everything her own body is telling her, that she is carrying a child that does not exist?

 

How does a girl raised from the cradle to be the most important princess in Europe spend most of her adult life as what her own century bluntly called a spinster?

 

And how does the daughter of the most famously fertile disaster of a marriage in English history end up dying without ever managing to have a child of her own?

 

Those are tonight’s questions.

 

Let’s start where she started.

 

She was born on the 18th of February, 1516, at the Palace of Placentia in Greenwich.

 

And by the time she took her first breath, her mother had already buried three children who never lived past infancy, and one son, Henry, Duke of Cornwall, who lived only a few weeks.

 

Catherine of Aragon had wanted a prince more than she had wanted almost anything else in this world, and what she got, at last, was a girl who survived.

 

Mary was baptized three days later at the Church of the Observant Friars, not far from where she was born.

 

And the people standing over that font tell you something about how the child was regarded from her very first hours.

 

Lord Chancellor Thomas Wolsey stood as one godparent.

 

So did her great aunt, Catherine, Countess of Devon.

 

So did Agnes Howard, Duchess of Norfolk.

 

And the woman who stood sponsor at her confirmation, performed the same day, was Henry’s own first cousin once removed, Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury, a name you should hold on to because she is going to matter again, more than once, in ways nobody standing at that font could have guessed.

 

Her father’s public reaction to her birth is one of the strangest sentences anyone ever recorded about this family, and it is worth hearing exactly.

 

Speaking to the Venetian ambassador, Henry said that they were both young, and if it was a daughter this time, by the grace of God, the sons would follow.

 

That is a man consoling himself out loud in front of a foreign diplomat over the existence of his own living child.

 

It is also, in a way nobody in that room could have known, the sentence the next 20 years of English history would be spent trying to make true.

 

The sons did not follow.

 

There was one more pregnancy in 1518, and one more stillborn daughter.

 

And after that, Catherine’s body simply stopped giving Henry what he wanted from it, which meant that the small girl in the nursery at Greenwich, without doing anything at all, without being consulted, without even being old enough to walk steadily, had become the only legitimate child of the King of England, and would remain so for 17 years.

 

The following year, still an infant herself, Mary was named godmother to her cousin Frances Brandon.

 

Think about that for a moment.

 

A baby standing in as spiritual guardian to another baby.

 

It tells you something about how fast this family moved children into position, how early the machinery of dynasty started running through a life that hadn’t even learned to walk yet.

 

She learned to talk early, and what survives of her earliest recorded words is almost too fitting to believe.

 

At 2 years old, pointing at a musician who also happened to be a clergyman, she said one word, “Priest.”

 

It’s a small thing, a toddler’s observation, but if you know where this story ends, with a queen who would spend her adult life fighting with everything she had to put priests back at the center of English life, it’s hard not to feel a small chill reading it.

 

Her father adored her in the specific way Henry VIII was capable of adoring things, which is to say completely and for as long as it suited him.

 

He liked to show her off.

 

He would pull the cap from her head in front of foreign ambassadors just to let her long pale hair spill down her back, delighting in the reaction of the room.

 

He told people she never cried.

 

Whether that was true or simply the kind of thing a proud father says about his firstborn, it stuck.

 

When she was still small enough to be carried, he brought her out to an assembly of visiting dignitaries and, by one account, walked her around the hall in his arms so that every man present could look at her properly.

 

For those first years, Mary was not a bargaining chip yet.

 

She was just a small, clever, fair-haired girl who made her father happy.

 

She was also, from very early, being watched by men who wrote down what they saw and sent it abroad.

 

That is the peculiar condition of her childhood.

 

Almost nothing she did between the ages of 2 and 12 was private.

 

Ambassadors described her hair, her height, her manners, the quality of her Latin, the way she played the virginals when told to.

 

They measured her the way you would measure a horse you were considering buying.

 

Because that, functionally, is what they were doing.

 

And every one of those reports went into a diplomatic pouch and across the water to a court that was deciding what she was worth.

 

That didn’t last, meaning the innocence of it didn’t, because it never does in this family.

 

And the bargaining started almost immediately.

 

At 2 years old, the same age she was pointing out priests to the amusement of the court, Mary was formally betrothed to the Dauphin of France.

 

She was an infant.

 

He was an infant.

 

At the ceremony, a French admiral stood in as proxy for the groom and slipped a tiny ring onto the finger of a child who could not have understood one word of what was being said over her head.

 

Neither of them had any say in it, and neither of them would ever marry the other, but it set the pattern for the rest of her childhood.

 

Every few years, a new treaty, a new alliance, a new groom, and each time, Mary’s own preferences did not enter the conversation even slightly.

 

What did enter the conversation thoroughly was her education.

 

And here her mother made sure nothing was left to chance.

 

Catherine of Aragon had been raised by her own mother, Isabella of Castile, to believe that a woman could sit on a throne and hold it.

 

And she was determined that Mary would be prepared the same way, regardless of what her father assumed a daughter was for.

 

Thomas Linacre, one of the most respected scholars in England, was brought in as her first tutor.

 

Catherine oversaw the lessons herself for the first 11 years of Mary’s life, often keeping the girl close by her side, teaching her the same things Catherine herself had learned as a child in Spain.

 

She went further than that.

 

Catherine commissioned the Spanish humanist, Juan Luis Vives, to write a whole treatise on the education of a Christian woman, and then a companion plan of study specifically for her daughter.

 

And the reading list it produced was not the sort of thing anyone was handing to English girls in the 1520s.

 

Mary was to read the Gospels and the letters of St. Jerome and Plato and Cicero and Seneca.

 

She was to be kept away from romances and idle stories, which Vives considered poison for a young woman’s mind.

 

She was to write Latin every day and have it corrected.

 

It was, in its own severe way, an act of maternal love, and it produced exactly what Catherine intended it to produce, which was a girl who could hold her own in a room full of educated men and never once look for permission to be there.

 

By the time Mary was still quite young, she could already read and write in Latin, and the foundations were being laid for a woman who would eventually speak French, Spanish, and Italian as well, play both the lute and the clavichord with real skill, and carry herself, in the words of people who met her later in life, like someone who had never once doubted she belonged in a room full of kings.

 

She had, in other words, everything a princess of her century could be given.

 

Everything except the one thing that would have mattered most in the end, which was a say in her own future.

 

And that future was about to start moving very fast.

 

Two years after that first infant betrothal to the Dauphin, when Mary was 6 years old, she was promised again.

 

This time to a groom old enough to actually be a husband.

 

Her cousin, the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V, 22 years old at the time, agreed to marry a child 16 years his junior.

 

And for a while, it seemed to genuinely please both of them.

 

Charles sent gifts.

 

He wrote kindly of her.

 

There is a scene, recorded and probably at least half-staged, in which the child Mary was brought before her enormous cousin and asked to play for him.

 

And did.

 

And then asked him whether he intended to keep his promise and wait for her.

 

Which he assured her he did.

 

For a little girl who had already been handed off once on paper to a stranger she’d never meet, this at least came with the appearance of real regard.

 

It didn’t survive 3 years.

 

In February 1525, Charles won a crushing victory over the French at the Battle of Pavia, capturing the King of France himself on the field.

 

And overnight, the English alliance he’d been counting on stopped mattering to him.

 

He needed an heir quickly, not a 9-year-old bride he’d have to wait years to marry.

 

And so he broke the betrothal and married someone else entirely, his cousin Isabella of Portugal, who came with a dowry he could spend that year.

 

Mary, still a child, learned that the emperor of half of Europe had simply changed his mind about her.

 

That same year, her father made a decision that on its surface looked like an honor and in practice was something closer to a consolation prize.

 

He sent 9-year-old Mary to the Welsh border, gave her a household of her own, and installed her at Ludlow Castle to preside, at least in name, over the Council of Wales and the Marches.

 

People at the time and since have called her the Princess of Wales, though the title was never actually formally conferred on her.

 

What she got instead was the shape of the position without the paperwork behind it.

 

She would spend roughly 3 years moving between Ludlow, the manor at Bewdley, and the enormous Thornbury Castle, a property that had been confiscated from the Duke of Buckingham after his execution a few years earlier.

 

A small detail that says something about how casually the furniture of one destroyed noble life got handed to the next child in line.

 

It is worth stopping on what Ludlow actually was, because it was not a nursery.

 

It was a working seat of government, cold, defensible, sitting up over the River Teme on the frontier of a country that had spent centuries being hard to govern.

 

The Council of Wales and the Marches heard cases, settled land disputes, hanged people, and in the middle of that, Henry sent a 9-year-old girl and a set of household instructions running to pages, specifying what she should eat, how her clothes should be aired, that her chamber should be kept clean and sweet, that she should be exercised in the open air when the weather allowed, and that she should on no account be permitted to overexert herself at her books.

 

There is something almost tender in the fussiness of it, and something colder underneath, which is that every clause exists to protect an asset.

 

Keep her well, keep her healthy, keep her marriageable.

 

Her household there was staffed with people whose names will come back around later in ways that would have astonished Mary at 9 years old if she’d been able to see ahead.

 

Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury, the same woman who had sponsored her confirmation as an infant, became her lady governess, effectively raising her day-to-day.

 

And her chamberlain, the man managing her household’s affairs, was a rising courtier named John Dudley.

 

Neither one of these people would remain simple footnotes in Mary’s story.

 

One of them would go to the block for a crime that amounted, in the end, to being related to the wrong people.

 

The other would go to the block for trying to keep Mary off the throne entirely.

 

But at Ludlow, in the middle of the 1520s, they were just the people who ran her house.

 

Her studies didn’t stop the moment she left London.

 

Her Latin tutor at Ludlow, a scholar named Dr. Featherstone, kept her working.

 

And Catherine, even from a distance, wrote to her daughter asking to see copies of her Latin exercises so she could check the progress herself.

 

Read that again and notice what it actually is.

 

A queen of England in the middle of a court that was already beginning to turn against her, writing to her 9-year-old daughter on the Welsh border to ask for her homework.

 

The curriculum widened, too, adding history in the kind of study considered appropriate for someone who might genuinely be expected to rule one day.

 

Mary was being built, piece by piece, into a monarch, even while the men around her kept treating her marriage as the only part of her future that actually mattered.

 

And the marriage negotiations kept coming, faster now and less connected to anything resembling her actual life.

 

In 1527, with the betrothal to Charles dead and buried, a new treaty put Mary forward for the Duke of Orleans, a boy of only eight, far too young to marry for years yet.

 

And then, in one of those diplomatic turns that only make sense if you understand how little anyone was thinking about Mary as a person, the same treaty floated the idea of marrying her instead to the boy’s own father, Francis I, King of France himself, a man of 32, more than 20 years her senior, already notorious at his own court for his appetites.

 

Mary was 11.

 

Nothing came of that particular version either, but the treaty was signed all the same, and Mary was brought to London for the celebrations that went with it.

 

She was put through her paces for the French commissioners the way a promising instrument gets played for a buyer.

 

She spoke to them in French.

 

She spoke to them in Latin.

 

She played on the virginals, and the men sent home word that she was clever and graceful, and that they had been agreeably surprised.

 

Her father, proud as ever, pulled the cap from her head again in front of the visiting ambassadors, showing off the same cascade of pale hair he’d been showing off since she was small enough to sit in his lap.

 

And then, the same men, in the same reports, noted something else.

 

They wrote home that the young English princess looked strikingly thin for her age, and so small and slight that in their judgment she could not possibly be married and bedded for another 3 years at least.

 

It’s a small, unflattering detail, the kind no one would have thought worth recording if she hadn’t eventually become a queen worth writing about, but it sits there in the reports all the same.

 

A slight, watchful girl of 11, paraded in front of foreign dignitaries who were there to evaluate her as a piece of a treaty, and who noted, almost as an afterthought, that she didn’t look like she was eating well, and that her body was not yet ready for what they had planned for it.

 

By this point in her childhood, Mary had already been promised to a French prince, a Holy Roman Emperor, an 8-year-old duke, and briefly, absurdly, a king old enough to be her father, and not one of those arrangements had asked her a single question about what she wanted.

 

She was becoming, without anyone quite framing it that way, an expert in disappointment before she even reached her teenage years.

 

What she didn’t know yet, in 1527, dressed up for a French delegation and being talked about like livestock at auction, was that all of these broken engagements were about to look small, because her father had just met a woman named Anne Boleyn, and everything that had happened to Mary so far was only the warm-up.

 

Anne Boleyn had spent years at the English court already, first in the household of the queen she would eventually replace, then in her own right, a sharp, French-educated young woman with a gift for making herself impossible to ignore.

 

By the late 1520s, Henry had tired of waiting for Catherine to give him a son who lived, and he had fixed his attention on Anne with the same total, consuming focus he had once given his firstborn daughter.

 

The difference was that this time, what he wanted from a woman was something Catherine, now past her childbearing years, could no longer give him, and something an 11- or 12-year-old Mary could not begin to understand yet, except in its effects.

 

Those effects arrived slowly, then all at once.

 

In 1528, the marriage that had produced Mary, the marriage that had held for nearly 20 years, began coming apart in public.

 

Henry wanted an annulment.

 

He built his case on a single, devastating claim, that his marriage to Catherine had never been valid in the eyes of God in the first place.

 

Because Catherine had briefly been married to his own late brother, Arthur, before Henry ever took her as his wife.

 

Under one reading of scripture, that made their whole union something close to incest.

 

And if that reading held, then Mary herself, the child of that supposedly unlawful marriage, had never been legitimate at all.

 

Mary was 12 years old when this argument began circulating at court.

 

Old enough to understand exactly what was being said about her mother and about her.

 

It is worth being precise about what her father was actually arguing.

 

Because the cruelty of it is easy to miss under all the theology.

 

He was not arguing that the marriage had gone wrong.

 

He was arguing that it had never existed.

 

Not a failed marriage, a false one.

 

Which meant that Catherine, who had been Queen of England since Mary’s father was a boy of 17, had never been his wife at all.

 

But something the law of the time had a much uglier word for, and it meant that the girl born to them, who had been paraded in front of half the courts of Europe as the most valuable heiress in Christendom, was not a princess and had never been one.

 

Everything Mary had been told she was, from her first breath, rested on a marriage her own father was now standing up in public to say had been a lie the whole time.

 

In the summer of 1529, the whole question was heard in a legatine court at Blackfriars in London.

 

And Catherine did something in that room that nobody in England ever forgot.

 

She was summoned.

 

She came.

 

And instead of taking her assigned place and letting the lawyers speak for her, she crossed the floor of the court in front of the bishops and the cardinals and the assembled nobility of England and knelt at her husband’s feet and spoke to him directly.

 

She reminded him that she had been a true and humble wife to him for 20 years, that she had borne him children, and that when he had married her, she had come to him a maid without touch of man.

 

Then she rose, made her reverence to him, and walked out of the court.

 

And when they called her name to come back, she kept walking.

 

Mary was 13.

 

She was not in that room, but she grew up in a country where everyone had heard about it, and where the version of her mother that lived in public memory from that summer forward was a woman who knelt on a stone floor in front of the man destroying her, and refused absolutely to give him what he wanted.

 

Whatever else Mary inherited from Catherine of Aragon, and she inherited a great deal, that particular kind of stubbornness, the kind that gets mistaken for stupidity right up until it wins, came directly from that woman.

 

The court at Blackfriars broke up without deciding anything.

 

The case was recalled to Rome, and Cardinal Wolsey, the man who had stood godfather at Mary’s christening, and who had failed to deliver the annulment his king demanded, fell out of favor so completely and so fast that he died the following year on his way to answer a charge of treason.

 

Mary lost in that collapse one of the last people at the top of English government who had any reason at all to look after her interests.

 

Three more years passed with the question unresolved, years in which Mary watched her parents’ marriage disintegrate from the inside without any real say in what would happen to her when it finally broke.

 

Then, in 1531, her father made the separation total.

 

Henry ordered that Mary was no longer to see her mother at all.

 

She was 15 years old.

 

Catherine was sent to live apart from court, and the daughter who had spent her first 11 years learning Latin at her mother’s side was simply cut off with no warning that it would be permanent, and no way of knowing yet that it actually was.

 

It was permanent.

 

Mary never saw her mother again in this life.

 

The Pope in Rome refused to grant the annulment Henry wanted, no matter how the case was argued.

 

And so, in 1533, Henry stopped asking.

 

He broke with Rome entirely, declared himself the supreme head of a new Church of England, and had his own Archbishop, a man named Thomas Cranmer, formally pronounce the marriage to Catherine void, and the king’s new marriage to Anne Boleyn valid in its place.

 

It happened quickly, almost administratively, a stroke of the pen undoing 17 years of Mary’s life.

 

She was demoted overnight from Princess Mary to something with no real title at all, referred to from that point simply as the Lady Mary.

 

Her mother, once Queen of England, was redesignated Dowager Princess of Wales, a title she would only ever have properly held as the widow of Henry’s late brother Arthur, which was, in its own quiet way, its own kind of insult.

 

Anne gave birth that same year to a daughter, a healthy girl named Elizabeth, and Elizabeth, not Mary, was now the recognized heir.

 

Anne did not stop there.

 

She forbade Mary any access to her father.

 

She had Mary’s plate and jewels called in, and in December of that year, she arranged for the 17-year-old former princess to be sent, with almost no notice, into the household of her own infant half-sister at Hatfield.

 

Not as a visiting sister, not as a guest, but as a member of the baby’s establishment.

 

Her own separate household, the one she had kept since Ludlow, was dissolved.

 

Her servants were dismissed.

 

The people who had raised her, including Margaret Pole, who begged to be allowed to stay on and pay for her own service out of her own pocket, were refused and sent away.

 

You are 17 years old and you have been a princess of England every single day of your life and this morning that stopped being true by order of a document you were not shown.

 

Men you do not know are in your rooms packing your things into chests and the things are fewer than they were last week.

 

The women who dressed you since you were small have already gone and were not permitted to say goodbye properly.

 

There is a litter waiting in the courtyard to take you to a house you have never lived in where your father’s new daughter, 4 months old, is being raised as the heir to everything you were promised.

 

You are being sent there to serve her.

 

Nobody has asked whether you will go.

 

They have only asked, through an intermediary, whether you will call the baby princess because your answer to that question is the only thing anyone in this house still wants from you and you already know exactly what your answer is going to be.

 

She said the only princess in England was herself, the daughter of the king and queen.

 

She said it in 1533 at 17 with no household, no allies in the room, and no protection whatsoever.

 

And she went on saying it in one form or another for the next 3 years.

 

The household she was sent into was run by Anne Boleyn’s own aunt, Lady Shelton.

 

And the instructions Lady Shelton received were not gentle.

 

She was told that if Mary persisted in calling herself princess, she was to be treated as a bastard daughter of the king, given the worst room in the house, and disciplined accordingly.

 

Anne is reported to have sent word that her aunt should box the girl’s ears for the cursed bastard she was.

 

What actually happened, by the evidence that survives, is stranger and more human than that.

 

Lady Shelton did enforce the humiliations and Mary suffered them, but Lady Shelton also seems, over time, to have grown fond of the difficult, sickly, immovable young woman in her care, and to have quietly softened what she could, which is the sort of thing that happens when the person carrying out a cruelty has to look at the results of it every day at breakfast.

 

The humiliations were constant and small, and calculated to grind.

 

Mary was not to be addressed by any title.

 

When the court moved between houses, she was made to travel behind the infant, and on at least one occasion, when she refused to leave her chamber to take an inferior place in the procession, she was carried out bodily and put into the litter.

 

When Henry came to visit his younger daughter, Mary was confined to her room so that he would not see her, and there is a story which may be true, and which was certainly believed, that on one such visit she appeared on a terrace above the courtyard as he was leaving, and knelt, and that he saw her, and touched his hat to her, and rode away without a word.

 

Her health, which had never been robust, collapsed under all of it.

 

She was ill repeatedly through these years, with symptoms nobody could name, and she and her mother both suspected poison.

 

And modern readers can take that suspicion or leave it, but what is not in question is that a teenage girl was living in a house where everyone knew the queen wanted her gone, and where she was too frightened to eat food she had not seen prepared.

 

When she was seriously ill in 1534, Catherine begged the king to let their daughter be sent to her, offering to nurse her herself, and promising that she would answer for her with her own life.

 

Henry refused.

 

He said, through Thomas Cromwell, that he would not have the two of them together, because together they would be strong enough to raise an army against him.

 

That sentence is worth holding on to, because it is the closest her father ever came to explaining what he was actually afraid of.

 

Not that Mary would rebel, that Mary and her mother, in the same room, would be too much for him.

 

What kept Mary upright through these years?

 

By her own account, and by the accounts of those close to her, was her faith.

 

The same Catholic instruction her mother had drilled into her from childhood, held onto now with something closer to defiance than comfort.

 

And she was not entirely without allies.

 

The Spanish ambassador, a man named Eustace Chapuys, became a close and genuine friend during this period, repeatedly attempting to intervene on her behalf at court, almost always without success, but never without trying.

 

He wrote to the emperor about her constantly, in letters full of a real and increasingly personal anger.

 

He proposed, more than once, that she be smuggled out of England altogether, taken down a river to a ship and out to the continent, and he seems to have been perfectly serious about it, and Mary seems to have been willing.

 

Nothing came of it.

 

The plans were always one step behind the guards, and Mary, in the end, stayed where she was.

 

Mary and her mother, forbidden from meeting, forbidden even from writing openly, found ways around it anyway, passing secret letters back and forth through servants and physicians they trusted.

 

In those letters, by every account that survives, Catherine urged her daughter toward the same instruction she always had.

 

Obey your father in everything you can.

 

Hold to your faith in everything you cannot.

 

In one of them, she told the girl to keep her heart clean and her mind quiet, and to be sure that whatever came, God would not send her anything she could not carry.

 

Mary kept those letters.

 

She kept them her whole life.

 

Mary refused to accept any of it quietly, and it went further than refusing a title.

 

When the Act of Supremacy came before Parliament in 1534, requiring every subject to swear that Henry, not the Pope, headed the church in England.

 

Mary would not take the oath.

 

Under the law as it now stood, that refusal was treason, and treason carried the death penalty even for a king’s own daughter.

 

Men far more useful to the crown than she was were dying for exactly that refusal.

 

Thomas More went to the block for it.

 

John Fisher, Catherine’s old confessor, went to the block for it.

 

Henry, for reasons that seem to have had more to do with lingering affection than mercy in any general sense, did not act on it.

 

He let the refusal stand unpunished, though the threat never entirely lifted, and there were more than a few weeks in those years when the people around Mary genuinely believed she would be arrested, tried, and killed.

 

Catherine died in the winter of 1536 at Kimbolton, and Mary was not permitted to be with her.

 

There is no way to soften that fact, and I’m not going to try.

 

A daughter who had spent her whole childhood at her mother’s side, learning her letters from her, was kept away at the very end, and whatever grief Mary carried afterward, she carried largely alone.

 

Catherine wrote one last letter to Henry from her deathbed, forgiving him everything, and asking him to be a good father to their daughter, and signing herself still as his wife and queen.

 

She was buried at Peterborough with the honors due to a dowager princess of Wales, and not one honor more.

 

And at court, on the day the news arrived, Henry and Anne Boleyn dressed themselves in yellow and had the infant Elizabeth carried into chapel to the sound of trumpets.

 

That same year brought a second, sharper turn, one that arrived with almost no time to breathe between it and the first.

 

Anne Boleyn, the woman who had displaced Catherine and stripped Mary of her title, fell from the king’s favor with staggering speed.

 

In January, she miscarried a son.

 

In April, the machinery started moving against her.

 

And by the middle of May of 1536, she had been tried, convicted of adultery, incest, and conspiracy against the king’s life on charges that most historians since have found difficult to credit at face value, and beheaded on Tower Green by a swordsman brought over specially from Calais.

 

Mary’s own reaction to the news, by the reports that survive, was not grief.

 

If anything, it was something closer to relief, even satisfaction.

 

It would be dishonest to soften that, and I am not going to.

 

She had been given real reasons to feel that way.

 

The woman was dead, and the woman had spent 3 years trying to break her, and Mary was 20 years old, and she was glad.

 

That is what she felt.

 

A narrator who is fond of a person can still tell you plainly when that person felt something ungenerous.

 

And this is one of those moments.

 

The very next day, Henry was betrothed to Jane Seymour, and here, for once, something in Mary’s life shifted toward the kinder.

 

Jane treated her new stepdaughter with what the records describe as genuine warmth, and pressed the king, from the beginning, to bring his eldest daughter back to court and back into the family.

 

Mary, for her part, responded in kind, coming to refer to the new queen as her good mother, a phrase that carries its own quiet weight coming from a young woman who had lost the real one only months before.

 

But there was a price attached to that reconciliation, and it is worth being honest about what it cost her, because it was the highest price anyone ever charged her for anything, and she paid it in full.

 

Henry would not have her back on any terms except total surrender.

 

Not the softened, face-saving kind.

 

He wanted her, in writing, over her own signature to acknowledge him as supreme head of the Church of England, to repudiate the authority of the Pope entirely, and to declare that the marriage between her father and her mother had been, in her own words, by God’s law and man’s law incestuous and unlawful.

 

He wanted the daughter of Catherine of Aragon to put her name to a document calling her mother’s marriage unlawful and herself a bastard.

 

She refused.

 

Then she refused again.

 

Cromwell, who had been quietly working to broker the reconciliation, and who had staked his own position on delivering it, wrote to her in a fury telling her she was the most obstinate and obdurate woman in the world, and that he had never seen anyone so unnatural to their own father, and warning her, in terms nobody could misread, that she was walking toward her own destruction.

 

The men of the Privy Council came to her in person and hectored her for hours.

 

One of them said, in front of witnesses, that if she were his daughter, he would beat her head against the wall until it was as soft as a baked apple.

 

Her cousin, the Emperor Charles, urged her from a distance to simply give her father what he wanted.

 

Chapuys, the ambassador who had spent years defending her, and had once been ready to smuggle her out of the country, sat down and told her the same thing.

 

And he told her something else, too, which was that she could sign with her hand and hold her position in her heart, and that God, who saw both, would understand the difference.

 

Mary held out as long as she could bear to, and then, exhausted, isolated, frightened, and out of every ally she had left, she signed.

 

She signed on the 22nd of June, 1536.

 

And there is an account, credible enough that it has never been fully dislodged, that she did not read the document before she put her name to it, because she could not make herself look at the words while she did it.

 

It was, by her own later reckoning, and by the judgment of nearly everyone who has written about her since, the one act of her life she came to regret most deeply.

 

She wrote afterward to Rome in secret asking for absolution for it, and she got it, and it did not help.

 

She had spent 3 years refusing to say the words that would have made her life easier.

 

In the end, she said them anyway and lived with having said them for the next 22 years.

 

There was one more thing about that summer worth telling, and it is the kind of detail that says more than a page of description could.

 

Once she had signed, once she was restored to her father’s favor and invited back to court, Henry was generous with her.

 

He gave her money.

 

He gave her a household again.

 

He was, in his own enormous, absent-minded way, an affectionate father to her for the rest of his life.

 

And Mary took the money and ran the household and was a dutiful daughter to him.

 

And by every account, they got on well.

 

Whatever she felt about what he had made her sign, she kept it entirely to herself, and she went on being pleasant to him at close range for 11 more years.

 

That is not weakness.

 

That is a very particular kind of endurance, and it is the same endurance that would eventually put her on the throne.

 

The years that followed were, in most of the ways that make for dramatic telling, remarkably thin.

 

This is not a failure of research.

 

It is simply what her life looked like for the better part of two decades, a long stretch in which very little happened to her that was not, in some form, a continuation of what had already happened before.

 

She was at court, and she was well-dressed, and she gambled at cards, and she lost at cards constantly, according to the household accounts, which record with unsparing regularity how much the Lady Mary had dropped that week.

 

She kept a fool named Jane.

 

She kept greyhounds.

 

She paid out small sums to the servants of everyone who brought her a gift and to the poor women who came to her door and to the children who brought her flowers and the accounts are full of it.

 

Page after page of a woman being kind in small amounts to people whose names nobody would otherwise have written down.

 

Jane Seymour died in October of 1537, 12 days after giving Henry the son he had torn the contract apart to get and Mary was chief mourner at her funeral.

 

She had known her a little over a year.

 

She walked behind the coffin and she paid for masses to be said for her soul quietly in a country where saying so out loud was becoming dangerous.

 

She stood godmother to the boy, Prince Edward, born the 10th of October, half-brother to a young woman who had spent three years insisting on the legitimacy of a marriage his very existence depended on erasing.

 

Mary loved him.

 

There is no serious doubt about that.

 

She sent him presents.

 

She played with him when the household allowed it.

 

It says something about how tangled loyalty and family had become in this house that a woman could hold at the font the child whose birth confirmed her own displacement and mean every word of the vows she made over him.

 

And then in the spring of 1541, the past came back and took one more thing from her.

 

Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury, the woman who had stood sponsor at Mary’s confirmation as an infant, who had raised her at Ludlow, who had begged to be allowed to serve her for free when the household was broken up, had a son named Reginald Pole.

 

Reginald had gone abroad and from the safety of the continent he had written a treatise attacking Henry’s supremacy over the church in terms so violent that the king never forgave it.

 

Henry could not reach Reginald, so he reached the family instead.

 

Margaret Pole was arrested, held in the Tower for 2 and 1/2 years, an old woman in a cold room with no trial and no charge she was ever allowed to answer.

 

And then, on the morning of the 27th of May, 1541, taken out to the block.

 

She was 67 years old.

 

The regular executioner was away in the north.

 

The man they sent instead was, by the accounts that survive, young and inexperienced, and he made a horrifying job of it.

 

It took him several blows.

 

Some reports say more than several.

 

Whatever the precise number, an elderly woman who had committed no crime beyond being the mother of a man who had criticized the king in print was hacked to death in the Tower of London that morning, and the last governess of Mary’s childhood ended that way.

 

Mary was 25.

 

She said nothing publicly.

 

She could not afford to.

 

But, when she came to the throne 12 years later, one of the first things she did was to bring Reginald Pole home from exile.

 

And one of the last things she did was to die within hours of him.

 

Her own health, which had never been strong, remained a persistent shadow through all these years.

 

Contemporary physicians described a chronic condition involving a regular and painful menstruation, referred to at the time in language that has not aged well, a strangulation of the womb as one account put it.

 

Modern readers should take that description with real caution.

 

Tudor medicine understood very little about the female body, and much of what survives reads more like guesswork dressed as diagnosis than anything resembling a real condition.

 

What we can say with more confidence is that Mary suffered chronically and for years, that she was frequently unable to leave her bed for days at a time, and that whatever it was never fully left her.

 

Henry married three more times after Jane, Anne of Cleves, who was dismissed within months and who became, oddly, one of the few genuine friendships of Mary’s life.

 

The two of them visiting each other and exchanging gifts for years afterward.

 

Catherine Howard, a girl younger than Mary, who was beheaded before she turned 20.

 

And finally, Catherine Parr, who arrived in 1543 and who did for Mary something none of the others had managed, which was to put her back into the family in a way that stuck.

 

Parr brought all three of Henry’s children together under one roof, wrote to Mary as a friend rather than a superior, and encouraged her scholarship.

 

Mary spent part of those years translating a paraphrase of the Gospel of John from Latin into English, working through illness and having to hand the last of it to her chaplain to finish.

 

And when it was published, Parr made sure her name went on it.

 

In 1544, Parliament passed the Third Succession Act, restoring both Mary and her half-sister Elizabeth to the line of succession behind their brother Edward, though neither one had her legal status as legitimate actually restored alongside it.

 

It was a strange, halfway kind of justice, placing Mary back in line for a throne while still technically calling her a bastard in the eyes of English law.

 

She was, on paper, at the age of 28, both the heir presumptive to the crown of England and an illegitimate child.

 

Both of those things were true at once, in writing, in statute, and nobody involved seems to have thought it necessary to resolve the contradiction.

 

Suitors continued to be proposed for her throughout these years, one after another, and one after another they came to nothing.

 

The Duke of Orleans again, a Portuguese prince, a German duke.

 

Each time negotiations opened and each time they closed and by the time she reached her 30s Mary had become in the plain language of her own century a spinster, the most eligible and most permanently unmarried princess in Europe.

 

Those who described her in this period speak of a woman who, whatever her private sorrows, still carried herself with real presence, a fine singing voice in the contralto range, real skill with languages and a bearing that never once suggested she doubted her own right to be in whatever room she happened to occupy.

 

What she could never quite shake, no matter how the law had officially restored her, was the word that had followed her since she was 17 years old, bastard.

 

It clung to her long after Parliament had technically put her back in line for the crown she had once assumed as a child would simply come to her.

 

Henry died in the small hours of the 28th of January, 1547.

 

He was 55, enormous, ulcerated, and had to be moved through his own palace on a machine built to lift him.

 

Mary was 30.

 

She had spent her entire adult life being punished, restored, punished again, and finally tolerated by this man, and there is no record at all of what she felt when the news came.

 

She went into mourning.

 

She attended the funeral.

 

She said nothing anybody thought worth writing down.

 

His son, by Jane Seymour, 9 years old, became King Edward the Sixth, and the country he inherited was about to move further and faster away from everything Mary believed than it ever had under her father.

 

Under Henry, the break with Rome had been a change of management.

 

The doctrine, the mass, the ceremony, most of what actually happened inside an English church on a Sunday morning had stayed more or less where it was.

 

Under Edward, that stopped.

 

The men running the country in the boy’s name, first his uncle Edward Seymour, and then John Dudley, the same man who had once managed Mary’s household at Ludlow, and who was now climbing toward the top of English government, pushed the country into full Protestant reform.

 

Latin was replaced with English.

 

The old service books were burned.

 

Altars were pulled down and replaced with plain tables.

 

Images were smashed.

 

The chantries, where priests said masses for the souls of the dead, were dissolved and their money taken, which meant that all over England, prayers that had been paid for in perpetuity, simply stopped.

 

Mary would not give it up.

 

She continued to hear mass in the old form, in her own private chapel, in open defiance of her brother’s government, and she did not do it discreetly.

 

Her chapel became the loudest religious statement in the kingdom.

 

People came, household servants, neighbors, gentry from miles around, anyone who wanted the old religion and wanted to see somebody get away with it, and Mary let them in, and the council knew it, and it drove them to distraction.

 

They came at her again and again over four years.

 

They wrote to her.

 

They summoned her chaplains and arrested two of them.

 

They warned her that the new Act of Uniformity applied to her exactly as it applied to every other subject in England.

 

And Mary, who had learned everything she needed to know about being immovable from a woman kneeling on a stone floor at Blackfriars 20 years earlier, simply told them no, in every possible register, over and over.

 

Her defense was always the same, and it was clever, and it was not entirely honest, and it worked for years.

 

She said that her father, of blessed memory, had left the church in a certain state, and that she would keep it in that state until her brother came of age and could decide the matter for himself as a man.

 

She was, she said, obeying her father and waiting for her king.

 

What she was actually doing was running out the clock on a sick boy, and everyone involved knew it.

 

Her cousin Charles, still watching from abroad, backed her to the hilt.

 

And this is where the story of Mary’s survival stops being purely about her own courage, and starts being about the fact that she had the Holy Roman Emperor standing behind her with an army.

 

His ambassador told the English council, in as many words, that if the Lady Mary were prevented from hearing mass, the emperor would consider it cause for war.

 

That threat was not a bluff England could afford to test, and the council knew that, too.

 

In the summer of 1550, with the pressure closing in, Mary very nearly left England altogether.

 

The plan was serious, and it went further than anyone usually remembers.

 

Imperial ships were sent to the Essex coast, disguised as a corn fleet.

 

A boat was to come up the creek at Maldon.

 

Mary was at Woodham Walter, a few miles inland, and she was ready.

 

Her household began quietly selling off what could be sold.

 

She had money sewn into her clothes.

 

The plan was to get her down to the water at night, into a small boat, out to the ships, and across to Flanders and safety.

 

And she had agreed to all of it.

 

And then, on the night it was to happen, she did not go.

 

The accounts of why are frustrating because they are the accounts of frightened people writing quickly.

 

There were watchmen on the coast.

 

A local official had grown suspicious.

 

Her comptroller told her the countryside was awake, and it could not be done safely.

 

Mary, by the report of the man sent to fetch her, sat in her chamber that night, packed, with her rings and her money on her, and could not decide.

 

She said, “More than once, what shall we do?”

 

She said, “What shall become of me?”

 

And then she said she would go tomorrow, and tomorrow she said the same.

 

And then the moment closed, and the ships went home without her.

 

You are 34 years old, and everything you own that matters is in a box on the bed.

 

The tide is right tonight, and it will not be right again for days.

 

You have been told to walk to the water and get in a boat and never see this country again, and it is the safe thing, and it is very probably the sensible thing.

 

And there is a man downstairs waiting for you to come down the stairs so that he can save your life, and you cannot make your feet move.

 

Because if you get on that boat, you are no longer the daughter of the King of England.

 

You are a poor relation living on your cousin’s charity in a foreign city.

 

And the throne, which is the only thing you have ever been promised that hasn’t already been taken away from you, is on this side of the water.

 

She stayed.

 

She never explained it.

 

And in staying, she made the single most consequential decision of her entire life.

 

Because a Mary who sailed for Flanders in 1550 does not become Queen of England 3 years later.

 

She becomes a footnote in somebody else’s story, an exiled Catholic princess dying quietly in Brussels.

 

Everything that came after, the crown, the marriage, the fires, all of it, sits on top of a woman who stood in an upstairs room in Essex one night and could not make herself get on a boat.

 

The confrontation with the government came to its head in the spring of 1551, and she staged it beautifully.

 

Summoned to London, Mary rode into the city at the head of a procession of somewhere between 50 and 130 of her own gentlemen and ladies, and every single one of them, by prior arrangement, carried a black rosary at their belt, held where the crowds could see it.

 

They rode through the streets of a Protestant capital with the forbidden beads swinging in plain view, and the people came out to watch.

 

And Mary rode straight through the middle of them to her brother’s court.

 

The interview that followed was not a success for anybody.

 

Edward, 13 years old, brilliant, cold, and entirely sincere in his own faith, told his sister that he would not permit her to break his laws.

 

Mary told her brother that she would obey him in everything except her soul.

 

And that if he compelled her conscience, she would lay her head on a block.

 

She said, and it was reported at the time that she was ready to die, but that she would not consent.

 

And then the two of them, brother and sister, both of them stubborn, both of them completely certain they were right, both of them fond of each other in a way that made the whole thing worse, ended the meeting in tears, and nothing had changed at all.

 

Nothing changed for two more years.

 

Edward’s government kept pressing and kept stopping short because the emperor was still there, and Mary kept hearing mass, and the deadlock held.

 

And then, at the beginning of 1553, the boy king, only 15 years old, began coughing blood.

 

Edward did not get better.

 

Through the spring of 1553, what had started as a cough and a fever settled into something the doctors around him were increasingly unwilling to name out loud.

 

And by early summer, everyone close to the crown understood the boy was dying.

 

He was 15 years old, and he was, by every account, terrified less of death itself than of what would happen to the reformed church he had spent his short reign building if his Catholic older sister inherited it whole.

 

So, he did something about it.

 

Working with his chief minister, John Dudley, now Duke of Northumberland, the same man who had run Mary’s household on the Welsh border when she was a girl of nine and he was a rising young courtier looking for a foothold.

 

Edward drafted a document that came to be known as his device for the succession.

 

It set aside both of his half-sisters entirely, citing their old illegitimacy, and named instead his cousin, a sharp, deeply learned young Protestant noblewoman named Lady Jane Grey.

 

Northumberland had already married Jane to his own son, Guildford Dudley, a few weeks earlier in a match that made perfect sense to everyone involved except, by her own account, Jane herself.

 

The judges did not want to sign it.

 

The Lord Chief Justice told the boy to his face that the device was against the law, that an act of Parliament could not be overturned by a king’s letters patent, and that putting his name to it might be treason.

 

Edward, dying, furious, told him to sign, and he signed, and so did the rest of them, and so did the council, one by one, some of them weeping.

 

A 15-year-old who would be dead within weeks bullied the entire legal establishment of England into rewriting the succession, and the reason he could was that everybody in that room could see how frightened they should be of what came next.

 

Edward died on the 6th of July.

 

His death was kept quiet for 3 days while Northumberland arranged the pieces.

 

Word did not reach Mary immediately, and when it did, it came wrapped in a warning.

 

She had been summoned to London, ostensibly to see her dying brother, and she had actually set out, and she was somewhere on the road at Hoddesdon when a rider caught her, sent, by the most likely account, by Northumberland’s own son-in-law, and told her the summons was a trap, that the king was already dead, and that if she came any closer to London, she would be taken.

 

Mary did not go to London.

 

She turned around in the road in the dark with a handful of servants, and she rode east hard all night toward East Anglia, toward Kenninghall in Norfolk, and the estates and the loyal Catholic gentry she had spent years quietly cultivating in that part of the country.

 

She had no army.

 

She had no money to speak of.

 

She had a name, a few dozen loyal people, and a decision to make, and she made it before anyone could talk her out of it.

 

From Kenninghall, on the 9th of July, she did the thing nobody expected a woman in her position to do.

 

She wrote to the Privy Council in London, the same men who were at that moment preparing to proclaim someone else, and she informed them flatly, as a matter of settled fact, that the crown was hers by right and by act of Parliament, that they were her subjects, and that she was graciously willing to overlook their conduct so far if they proclaimed her queen immediately.

 

She was at that moment a lone woman in a house in Norfolk with no soldiers.

 

The letter is written as though she has 50,000 men outside.

 

That is either lunacy or one of the great nerve holds in English history, and the difference between the two turned out to be about 10 days.

 

The Council’s reply was contemptuous.

 

They told her she was illegitimate, that the crown belonged to Queen Jane, and that she should behave herself.

 

Mary moved to Framlingham Castle in Suffolk, a great old fortress with a curtain wall and 13 towers, and there she stopped running, and she stood, and she waited to see whether anyone in England would come.

 

They came.

 

That is the part that still surprises people, and it should not, because it is the clearest verdict the English people ever delivered on this woman, and they delivered it at the one moment when it cost them something to be wrong.

 

The gentry of Norfolk and Suffolk came in with their tenants.

 

The town of Ipswich declared for her.

 

Sailors on the ships sent to blockade the coast and cut off her escape mutinied against their own officers and went over to her, bringing their guns with them.

 

Men who had every reason to stay home saddled up and rode toward a castle in Suffolk to fight for a woman most of them had never seen because she was Henry VIII’s daughter and the other one was not.

 

Within a week she had perhaps 15,000 men camped around Framlingham and she rode out to review them on a white horse and the cheering was so loud that a horse shied and she had to dismount and walk among them on foot, which she did, bare-headed, thanking them by name where she knew the names.

 

Meanwhile, in London, on the 10th of July, Jane Grey was proclaimed queen and escorted by barge to the Tower, the traditional residence of English monarchs in the days between accession and coronation.

 

The proclamation was read in the streets to a silence that everybody present noticed.

 

One young man who shouted that the Lady Mary had the better title had his ears cut off for it the next day.

 

That is the entire temperature of London in that week in one sentence.

 

Northumberland marched out with an army to deal with Mary himself and as he rode out through the city he said to the men riding with him that the people were pressing to see them but that not one of them said Godspeed.

 

He was right.

 

It was over before it started.

 

Support for Jane, manufactured almost entirely from the top down by men protecting their own interests, evaporated within days.

 

Towns declared for Mary.

 

The fleet had already gone and in London, the Privy Council, sitting in the Tower with Jane, watched the reports come in and did the arithmetic that men like that always do in the end.

 

On the 19th of July, only nine days after Jane’s proclamation, the council reversed itself and proclaimed Mary Queen instead.

 

The bells of London rang for hours.

 

People lit bonfires in the streets and threw their caps in the air and roasted meat over the fires and gave away their own wine to strangers.

 

And the noise, by one account, went on so long into the night that a man could not hear his neighbor speak.

 

Jane Grey was told she was no longer Queen by her own father, who then left the Tower and went home.

 

She had been sovereign for nine days.

 

She was 16 years old, and she remained where she was, in the Tower.

 

Except that the rooms she was in had quietly stopped being royal apartments and started being a prison.

 

There had been no battle.

 

There had barely been a fight of any kind.

 

Northumberland, out in the field with an army that was melting under him, threw his own cap in the air in the marketplace at Cambridge and proclaimed Mary Queen himself, which fooled precisely nobody and saved him nothing.

 

A woman who had spent 20 years being told, in one form or another, that she did not matter had just taken the throne of England on the strength of her name and her nerve alone.

 

She rode into London on the 3rd of August in a procession of more than 800 nobles and gentlemen in a gown of purple velvet, and her half-sister Elizabeth rode near her, the two of them presenting, for this one carefully staged afternoon at least, a picture of Tudor unity that neither of them fully believed and both of them understood the value of performing anyway.

 

Mary’s first instincts as Queen leaned toward mercy, and this is worth saying clearly because of what comes later and how thoroughly it has buried this.

 

When a Tudor took a throne by force, the ordinary arithmetic was dozens of executions.

 

Mary executed three men, Northumberland and two of his officers.

 

That was all.

 

She understood correctly that Jane Grey had been a pawn in Northumberland’s ambitions rather than a willing usurper, and she spared the girl’s life and refused to move against her for months against the advice of nearly everyone, including her own cousin’s ambassador, who told her plainly that the girl would have to die eventually and that it would be easier now.

 

Northumberland himself was not spared.

 

He was executed on the 22nd of August, and he went to his death having publicly renounced his Protestant faith and declared himself a Catholic on the scaffold, which is not the ending anybody had written for him and which persuaded absolutely no one of anything.

 

The man who had once run a 9-year-old girl’s household on the Welsh border died on Tower Hill for trying to keep that same girl off the throne of England, brought full circle by the crown he had spent his whole career reaching for through other people.

 

Her coronation came on the 1st of October at Westminster Abbey, and it was, in the plainest sense, a ceremony that had never existed before.

 

Every coronation in English memory had been built around crowning a king or crowning a woman as a king’s wife.

 

There was no established ritual for crowning a woman as sovereign in her own right, and so the ceremony had to be assembled, in effect, from pieces never designed for this purpose.

 

Nobody could agree whether she should be girded with the sword of state.

 

Nobody could agree whether she should hold the spurs.

 

In the end, she was given everything, all the regalia of a king, because the alternative was to admit that the whole apparatus had never been built with her in mind.

 

She rode through the streets the day before in a carriage drawn by six horses in a gown of blue velvet trimmed with ermine, with a circlet of gold on her head so thick with jewels, by the accounts of those who watched, that Mary reportedly had to steady it with her own hands to keep the weight from tipping it.

 

And she also quietly had done something that morning that tells you what she thought was actually happening.

 

She had asked the bishop who anointed her to use holy oil sent secretly from Brussels because she did not trust the English oil in the English ampulla to be untainted by the schism.

 

The girl who had been declared a bastard at 17, who had been carried bodily into a litter and made to travel behind an infant, stood that morning in the same abbey where her father had once been crowned and had the crown of England set on her own head by her own right.

 

She was 37 years old and she had, by the standards of everything that had happened to her so far, already won.

 

There was one question in England that autumn that mattered more than any other and everyone in the kingdom was asking it, including the woman it belonged to.

 

She was 37 years old, unmarried, and the only thing standing between England and her Protestant half-sister was her own body, which had never been reliable and which had not much time left in which to produce an heir.

 

She had to marry and she had to do it quickly and every man in her council had an opinion about who.

 

The English candidate was Edward Courtenay, Earl of Devon, a young man with Plantagenet blood who had spent most of his life imprisoned in the Tower for the crime of his ancestry and who had emerged from it, at 27, charming, spoiled, and entirely unequal to anything.

 

Lord Chancellor Gardiner wanted him.

 

Half the council wanted him.

 

The country, in so far as it had a view, wanted an Englishman, any Englishman.

 

She did not choose him.

 

She chose Philip of Spain, son of her own cousin the Emperor Charles, 27 years old, a widower with a young son already, and the decision detonated almost immediately.

 

You have to understand what she was actually choosing, because it was not a political calculation dressed up as romance, and it was not romance dressed up as politics.

 

It was both, tangled beyond separating.

 

Charles V had been the one constant of her adult life.

 

When her father broke her, Charles’s ambassador was the man who sat with her.

 

When Edward’s council came for her mass, Charles’s threat was the thing that held them off.

 

Spain was her mother’s country and her mother’s language, and the half of herself that had spent 20 years telling her to be ashamed of.

 

When they showed her Philip’s portrait by Titian, she is said to have looked at it for a long time.

 

She was going to marry into the family that had never once abandoned her, and she was 37, and she was going to be loved, and none of the men shouting at her in the council chamber understood a single thing about why she was not going to be talked out of it.

 

Parliament sent a delegation to beg her not to marry a foreigner, warning of exactly the fears you’d expect that he might drag England into Spain’s wars, or try to remove her from the country, or seize the throne outright if she died first.

 

Mary heard them out, and then, furious at what she took to be an intrusion on the one decision in her entire life that had ever actually been hers to make, told the speaker of the House of Commons that if she were forced to marry against her will, she would not live 3 months, and that her marriage was a matter for herself and for God, and she sent them home.

 

She did agree to a marriage contract with real teeth in it, negotiated hard by Gardiner and swallowed whole by the Spanish.

 

Philip would be styled king, but only as her consort, and only for her lifetime.

 

He could make no appointments of foreigners to English office.

 

He could not take Mary, or any child of theirs, out of the country.

 

England would not be committed to Spain’s wars, and if Mary died childless, the crown would pass to her English heirs, and Philip would get nothing at all.

 

None of those safeguards did anything to calm the anger in the streets.

 

Within weeks of the announcement, boys in London were throwing snowballs at the Spanish envoys as they rode through the city.

 

A dead dog was thrown through the window of the Queen’s presence chamber with its head shaved like a priest’s and a noose around its neck.

 

By January of 1554, that anger had a face and a name, Thomas Wyatt the younger, a nobleman from Kent, the son of a poet, raised a force in his own county with the explicit purpose of stopping the Spanish marriage before it could happen.

 

Wyatt’s rising was meant to be one of four coordinated across the country, and the other three collapsed almost before they began.

 

Wyatt’s did not.

 

He came out of Kent with something in the region of 3,000 men, and he marched on London, and the force sent to stop him, 500 of the city’s trained bands under an elderly commander, went over to him in the field shouting that they were all Englishmen, which is the moment the rebellion stopped being a nuisance and started being a threat to the throne.

 

Mary’s council told her to leave London.

 

They told her to get out of the city, go west, get behind walls.

 

Her own ambassadorial protectors told her the same thing.

 

She refused, and then she did the bravest thing she ever did in her life.

 

On the 1st of February, she rode into the city of London, went to the Guildhall, stood up in front of the assembled citizens and their officers, and spoke to them without notes for the better part of an hour.

 

She did not have a great voice for it.

 

Contemporaries described her speaking voice as surprisingly deep and loud, almost like a man’s, and on this one afternoon, that was exactly the right instrument.

 

She told them she was their queen, that at her coronation she had been wedded to the realm, and she held up her hand and showed them the ring, and she told them she was married to England and had never had any other spouse, and that she loved them as a mother loves her children.

 

She told them that if they could show her that this marriage was to the hurt of the kingdom, she would abstain from it, and not only from this marriage, but from any marriage as long as she lived.

 

And then she asked them plainly to stand with her and to be good subjects, and to muster their men and pluck up their hearts and fight against these rebels.

 

London came out for her.

 

Not the council, not the nobility, the city itself, the guilds and the apprentices and the shopkeepers.

 

20,000 of them under arms within two days.

 

Wyatt got as far as Ludgate and found it shut against him.

 

He sat down on a bench outside the gate to rest, by one report, and after a while he stood up and surrendered, and the rebellion was finished.

 

Mary, throughout it, had stayed in the palace at Whitehall, within a mile of the fighting, and had not moved.

 

It did not collapse without cost, and the cost fell hardest on people who had already been forgiven once.

 

Jane Grey had never been part of Wyatt’s plot in any real sense.

 

She had been in the Tower the entire time, but her father, the Duke of Suffolk, had gone out for the rebels in the Midlands, and that was enough, because it demonstrated in the clearest possible terms that as long as Jane was alive, she would be the flag every rising in England would gather under.

 

The advice was unanimous, and Mary, this time, took it.

 

Jane Grey was executed on Tower Green on the 12th of February, 1554.

 

She was 17 years old.

 

Her husband, Guildford, was beheaded on Tower Hill an hour or so earlier, and Jane, watching from a window, saw the cart come back with his body in it.

 

She walked to the block with a prayer book in her hand, and her ladies weeping around her.

 

Made a short speech in which she said she died a true Christian woman, and asked the crowd to pray for her while she was alive.

 

And then, blindfolded, she could not find the block with her hands, and had to ask for help.

 

And for a moment, nobody moved.

 

And a man in the crowd came forward and guided her to it.

 

Mary had spared her for 7 months against the advice of everyone, and then killed her because other men made it impossible not to.

 

And there is no reading of that where anybody comes out clean.

 

Wyatt himself went to the block that April, and on the scaffold he said, to a crowd who had come to hear him accuse the Queen’s sister, that the Lady Elizabeth had known nothing about any of it.

 

It did not matter much.

 

Elizabeth was already in the Tower.

 

She had been arrested and brought down the river by barge, and she came in through the Traitor’s Gate in the rain.

 

And she sat down on a wet stone in the entryway and would not move.

 

And when the lieutenant told her she would take cold, she said she would sit there anyway, because better to sit here than in a worse place.

 

She had, before they took her, written her sister a letter, spinning it out as long as she could, filling the blank space at the bottom with diagonal lines so nothing could be added to it, purely to run out the tide so the barge could not leave that night.

 

It bought her a day.

 

It did not buy her anything else.

 

The letter went to Mary, and Mary refused to read it, and refused to see her.

 

And Elizabeth spent 2 months in the Tower waiting to find out whether her sister would kill her, which her sister was being urged to do daily in writing by men she trusted.

 

Mary did not do it.

 

There was no evidence, and she would not manufacture any.

 

And Gardiner could not get the council to move without it.

 

In May, Elizabeth was released into house arrest at Woodstock, where she stayed for the better part of a year under guard, and where she is supposed to have scratched a line onto a windowpane with a diamond, saying that much suspected of her, nothing proved could be.

 

The two sisters would go on circling each other, one on the throne and one in the shadow of it, for the rest of Mary’s life.

 

And neither of them ever fully trusted the other again, and both of them were entirely right not to.

 

The wedding went ahead anyway.

 

They met for the first time on the 23rd of July, 1554, two days before the ceremony at Winchester.

 

Philip had landed at Southampton in a downpour and had ridden through it, and when he came to her, he came in wet clothes, and she came down to meet him.

 

And the two of them sat together for perhaps half an hour with a room full of people watching every second of it.

 

You are 38 years old.

 

You have been promised to a French prince, an emperor, a boy of eight, and a man old enough to be your father, and not one of them ever came.

 

You’re standing in a hall at Winchester, and the man who did come is walking toward you, and he is 27, and you have seen his face already, but only in paint.

 

He speaks Spanish to you, which is your mother’s language, and which nobody in this country has spoken to you with any kindness in 20 years, and you answer him in French, because it is the ground you have in common, and neither of you has quite enough of the other’s tongue to say anything that matters.

 

So, you teach him something instead.

 

You teach him how to say good night in English, so that he can say it to the men in this room when he leaves, and he practices it, and he says it, and they laugh, and it goes well.

 

It is not love yet.

 

It is the first evening of the only thing in your life that has ever arrived when it was promised.

 

They were married on the 25th of July, the feast of St. James, patron saint of Spain, in Winchester Cathedral.

 

The emperor had made his son king of Naples the day before by hasty grant, so that a queen would not be seen marrying beneath herself.

 

The ceremony was staged with exquisite deliberate symbolism.

 

Both of them wore matching cloth of gold, richly embroidered, a visual statement of partnership and unity.

 

But at the wedding feast that followed, the careful equality of their dress gave way to something more honest about the actual balance of power.

 

Mary was seated in the place of higher honor and served her meal on gold plate.

 

Philip ate from silver.

 

The Spanish delegation noticed the difference immediately and noted it quietly for what it plainly was, a reminder dressed up as courtesy of exactly whose kingdom this was and whose it was not.

 

The Spanish in fact noticed a good many things that summer and they wrote them all down.

 

And their letters home are some of the most quietly brutal documents in this whole story.

 

They complained about the food, the weather, the beer, and the English habit of staring.

 

And about the queen, one of Philip’s gentlemen wrote to a friend in Spain that she was a good creature, though rather older than they had been given to understand, and that if she dressed in the Spanish fashion, she would not look so old and flabby.

 

Philip’s closest advisor wrote that the marriage had been made for no fleshly consideration, but to remedy the disorders of this kingdom.

 

Philip himself said nothing on the record at all, and was, by every account of his behavior, perfectly exhaustingly correct with her, always.

 

She fell in love with him anyway, completely and without any protection at all, and everyone around her could see it, and so, obviously, could he.

 

That autumn, the man Mary had been waiting for since she was 25 came home to England.

 

Reginald Pole, the son of Margaret Pole, the cousin whose criticism of Henry from abroad had cost his mother her head in the Tower, arrived in November of 1554 as papal legate.

 

He had been away for 20 years.

 

He came to a country that had killed most of his family.

 

And on the 30th of November, in the presence of the Queen, the King, and both houses of Parliament, he formally absolved the realm of England of its schism and received it back into the Roman Church.

 

Members of Parliament knelt on the floor to receive it.

 

Mary, watching, believed that this was the moment for which everything in her life had happened.

 

And there is a report that during the ceremony she said she felt the child move within her.

 

Though whether she said it or somebody wanted her to have said it, nobody can now tell.

 

Parliament, in the same session, restored the medieval laws against heresy.

 

They had been repealed under Edward.

 

Now they were law again, and they carried one penalty.

 

The burnings began in February of 1555, and they did not stop until the Queen was dead.

 

The first was John Rogers, a scholar and a preacher who had helped produce an English Bible.

 

He was taken to Smithfield on the 4th of February, and on the way to the fire he passed his own wife, who had come out to see him with their children around her, 11 of them, and one still at the breast that he had never seen.

 

He was not permitted to stop.

 

He went into the fire, and by the accounts of the crowd, he washed his hands in the flame as though it were cold water.

 

And the people watching, who had been expected to be sobered by all this, cheered him instead.

 

That is the number nobody in the government seems to have run before they started.

 

The English had not seen heretics burned in living memory at anything like this scale, and it turned out they had no stomach for it.

 

And worse, from the government’s point of view, they had a taste for the courage of the people dying.

 

John Hooper, Bishop of Gloucester, was burned in his own cathedral city so that the people who knew him could watch.

 

They stacked the wood green.

 

It would not take properly.

 

Three separate fires had to be lit under him, and by the accounts of the men who stood there, he was in the fire for something close to 3/4 of an hour before he died, praying for most of it and beating his breast with his hands until his arms would no longer move.

 

Roland Taylor was taken back to his own parish at Hadleigh to burn, and the people of the town lined the road weeping, calling out to him by name, and he told them he was going home.

 

That was the pattern over and over in market towns and city squares across the south and east of England for the next 3 and 1/2 years.

 

Nearly all of them were ordinary, weavers, tailors, laborers, servants, a fisherman, a barber.

 

56 of them were women.

 

Some of them were blind.

 

One of them was a boy.

 

In Guernsey, a woman gave birth in the fire, and the child, a living son, was pulled out of the flames by a bystander, and the officer in charge, on the authority of the law as he understood it, ordered it thrown back in.

 

287 people in something under 4 years.

 

It is a small number by the standards of what was happening on the continent in the same decades, where the killing ran into the thousands, and it is exactly the wrong argument to reach for, and I am not going to reach for it.

 

What matters is that it was a very large number for England in a short time in a country that had never done anything like it, and it happened in public, in the middle of towns, in front of neighbors, and every single one of those deaths was signed off by a government the Queen was running.

 

She never once wavered on it.

 

That has to be said plainly.

 

There is no letter in which Mary asks whether this is going too far.

 

There is a letter in which she instructs the sheriffs to make sure the executions are properly attended and properly explained to the people so that the crowd should understand what heresy is and be edified by seeing it punished.

 

She believed with total sincerity that a heretic left alive infected everyone around him and that a soul lost was worse than a body burned and that she was saving her people from something worse than fire.

 

She was wrong.

 

She was wrong in a way that cost 287 living human beings their actual lives in agony in front of their families.

 

And being fond of a person’s story does not mean pretending they did not do the thing they did.

 

Cardinal Pole for his part has been argued over ever since by historians who want to find someone in that government with clean hands and there is not much comfort there either.

 

He did not drive the policy.

 

He also did not stop it.

 

The most famous of those deaths belong to three men and it is worth slowing down here because this is where everything the rest of her reign will be remembered for crystallizes into a single afternoon.

 

Hugh Latimer, once Bishop of Worcester, nearly 70 years old and Nicholas Ridley, Bishop of London, in his early 50s were burned together outside the north wall of Oxford on the 16th of October, 1555.

 

Latimer wore an old shabby garment to the stake and then let it fall away to reveal a burial shroud underneath.

 

As the flames were lit, he is said to have turned to his fellow prisoner and spoken words that would outlive them both by centuries.

 

Be of good comfort, Master Ridley, and play the man.

 

We shall this day light such a candle by God’s grace in England as I trust shall never be put out.

 

Latimer, mercifully, was overcome by the smoke quickly and died without much apparent suffering.

 

Ridley was not so fortunate.

 

The wood beneath him had been stacked wrong, heaped too high above the kindling, and the fire burned fiercely below him without reaching him, and he suffered a long, agonizing death, calling out repeatedly for them to let the fire come to him.

 

His brother-in-law, trying to help, piled on more wood and made it worse.

 

Watching all of this from a window in his prison lodging nearby was the third man, Thomas Cranmer, Archbishop of Canterbury, the very man who, two decades earlier, had formally dissolved the marriage between Mary’s own parents and set her on the path to being declared a bastard in the first place.

 

Mary was never going to let Cranmer live.

 

That is worth being honest about, too.

 

His case was different from all the others because it was personal, and because he was the one man in England whose signature had unmade her mother.

 

He was kept alive 5 months after that October afternoon under enormous pressure, moved from a prison cell into comfortable lodgings, treated well, argued with by the best minds the restored church could send at him, and eventually, worn down, he broke.

 

He signed.

 

He put his name to a series of recantations, six of them in the end, each one going further than the last, renouncing the Protestant faith he had spent his entire career building, submitting himself to the Pope, and acknowledging himself as the worst of sinners.

 

By every law and precedent then in force, a heretic who recanted was not burned.

 

He was reconciled, and he lived.

 

Cranmer had done everything asked of him, and Mary ordered him burned anyway.

 

On the 21st of March, 1556, he was brought into the university church at Oxford in the rain to make his recantation in public one last time with a written speech already prepared for him to read out to the crowd.

 

He stood up in front of them and he began and then he did not read it.

 

Standing in front of the same church officials who believed they had already broken him, Cranmer set the prepared confession aside and told the crowd in his own words that he renounced every recantation he had signed, that he had written them for fear of death and to save his life and that they were contrary to the truth in his heart.

 

He said that his hand, the hand that had signed those false confessions, had offended most and that therefore it should be the first part of him to burn.

 

There was uproar.

 

They pulled him down from the platform and hurried him out to the same ditch outside the wall where Latimer and Ridley had died five months before and they chained him up and they lit the fire and he kept his promise.

 

He put his right hand out into the flame and he held it there steady and let it burn away before the rest of him followed and he is reported to have said more than once while it burned this unworthy right hand.

 

That is the candle Latimer had spoken of though neither man could have known it at the time.

 

Not a comforting flame at all in the end but something closer to a signal fire, one that would keep burning in English memory long after the actual fires at Oxford had gone cold, long after the woman who had ordered them lit was herself in the ground.

 

Whatever else the next three years of Mary’s reign would hold and there was still a great deal left to happen to her.

 

That wet March morning in Oxford was the afternoon that decided what she would be remembered as.

 

She had wanted more than anything to burn the man who unmade her mother and instead she had handed the English Reformation the single most useful martyr it would ever have.

 

But in the spring of 1555 in the middle of all of it, something else was happening inside the palace at Hampton Court that had nothing to do with heresy trials and everything to do with the one thing Mary wanted more than she had ever wanted the crown itself.

 

She was 39 years old and she believed, with everything in her, that she was pregnant.

 

In April, she went into what her century called confinement, the customary seclusion observed by expectant queens before a birth.

 

And for a while, the whole kingdom shared her hope.

 

Her body had changed in ways that seemed to confirm it.

 

Her belly had swelled, her monthly courses had stopped.

 

She reported morning sickness and the sensation, familiar to every mother, of movement within her.

 

The cradle was made and stood ready in her chamber, carved and painted with a Latin verse on it giving thanks to God for the child.

 

Letters announcing the birth were written in advance with a gap left blank where the word prince or princess would be filled in.

 

This was the child who would secure the Catholic succession, tie England permanently to Spain through blood rather than treaty, and make everything Mary had suffered to reach this point feel, at last, worth the cost.

 

At the end of April, the bells of London rang.

 

Word had come that the queen had been delivered of a son.

 

There were bonfires in the streets.

 

People sang in the churches.

 

Ships in the river fired their guns.

 

And then, over the course of a day, it emerged that none of it was true, that nobody knew where the report had come from, and the bells stopped, and the city went quiet, and stayed quiet, and nobody, in the weeks that followed, ever really explained it.

 

May passed.

 

The child did not come.

 

June passed.

 

The astrologers who had been so confident revised their calculations.

 

The midwives, who had been confident, too, began to hedge.

 

And by the time spring turned toward summer, the people closest to her were growing frightened, though not in the way anyone had expected.

 

It wasn’t the pregnancy that alarmed her physicians.

 

It was Mary.

 

She had stopped eating properly, to the point where her doctors worried, with an unbearable irony, given what we now understand, that the child they still believed existed might not survive her own decline.

 

Her ladies-in-waiting, kept close during the long weeks of confinement, began reporting behavior that frightened them more than any physical symptom could have.

 

They described the queen sitting on the floor of her darkened chamber for hours, with her knees drawn up against her chest, motionless, or rocking.

 

A posture that should have been physically impossible for a woman as heavily pregnant as everyone still believed her to be.

 

By August, 11 months from the wedding, and past every date anybody had proposed and then quietly re-proposed, Mary finally came out of the confinement chamber.

 

There was no child.

 

There had never been a child.

 

The court moved to Oatlands, and the cradle was taken away, and the announcement letters were burned unfilled, and the subject of the queen’s pregnancy simply disappeared from official conversation entirely, as though enough people had agreed, quietly and all at once, that the kindest thing left to do was to stop mentioning it in front of her.

 

What we understand today, looking back with medicine Mary’s own doctors had no access to, is that she likely suffered from a condition called pseudocyesis, a phantom pregnancy, in which the body produces nearly every physical sign of carrying a child in response to overwhelming psychological pressure, with no child ever actually there.

 

The belly swells, the period stop, the breasts change.

 

The woman feels movement.

 

It remains rare even now, and it is not madness, and it is not lying.

 

It is a body doing what it has been told by everything around it and everything inside it that it must do.

 

It happened to Mary Tudor in the one year of her life when she needed, more than she had ever needed anything, for it to be real.

 

Philip left England that September, sailing for the continent on matters of state that could not, by his own account, wait any longer.

 

He had done what he came to do, or discovered he could not do it, and there was an empire to run.

 

Mary begged him to stay.

 

She rode with him as far as Greenwich, and by one account, she stood at a window and watched his barge go down the river until she could not see it anymore, and then she wept, and then she went back to work.

 

She wrote to him constantly.

 

He wrote back rarely, and in the polite, correct manner of a man discharging an obligation.

 

She was reported as speaking of him to her women continually, and as being unable to bear the sight of his portrait, and as taking it out to look at it anyway.

 

She would not see him again for nearly 2 years.

 

The country he left behind him was one where the fires were still burning, where the harvests were failing 3 years running, where a strange sweating fever was going through the villages, and where the queen who had ordered the fires lit was, in the privacy of her own rooms, a woman who had just spent 11 months mourning a child who was never real.

 

He came back briefly in March of 1557, and stayed a little under 4 months.

 

And his reasons for coming had rather less to do with his wife than with his own kingdom’s finances.

 

Philip needed England in his war against France.

 

The marriage treaty said, in writing, that he could not have it.

 

Mary got it for him anyway.

 

She summoned her council and told them, and they told her no, and she called them in one at a time and worked on them individually until they said yes.

 

And by June, England was at war with France on Spain’s account, exactly as Parliament had warned her 4 years earlier that it would be.

 

It is the one clear case in the whole reign where she put her husband’s interests ahead of her country’s, and she did it with her eyes open, and it destroyed her.

 

He sailed in July.

 

The two of them never saw each other again.

 

It was after that second brief visit that Mary convinced herself, for the second time in her life, that she was carrying a child.

 

This time, almost no one around her believed it.

 

Her physicians looked at the same swelling, the same absence of her monthly courses, and quietly concluded that what they were looking at was very likely the onset of menopause or something worse, given her age and given what had happened 3 years earlier.

 

But something in the household had shifted since 1555, and this time, rather than correcting her, most of her ladies chose simply to go along with what she wanted to believe.

 

They performed the fiction back to her, month after month, letting her hold on to it, because the alternative, telling a queen the truth she could not bear, felt to nearly everyone involved like too cruel a thing to do.

 

Nearly everyone.

 

There was one woman in that household who would not do it.

 

A gentlewoman attending the queen named Freiswide Strelly refused to play along with the rest of the court and told Mary plainly, more than once, that she did not believe there was any child at all.

 

It cost her the queen’s displeasure in the moment, and it earned her, eventually, something rarer than comfort.

 

When the truth finally became undeniable, Mary is recorded as having turned to her and said, with a bitterness that reads, even 400 years later, like the words of a woman who has finally understood exactly how alone she has been.

 

“Ah, Strelly, Strelly, I see they all be flatterers, and none true to me but thou.”

 

There is a particular kind of loneliness in that sentence.

 

A queen surrounded at every hour of every day by people whose entire function was to attend to her, and only one of them, in the end, willing to tell her something true.

 

Meanwhile, the war Philip had drawn England into was going badly, and in January of 1558, it produced a wound that cut deeper into English pride than almost anything in a century.

 

Calais fell to the French.

 

It had been English territory for more than 200 years, since Edward the III took it, the last remaining piece of England’s old continental empire, a walled town on the other side of the water that generations of English kings had fought and bled and taxed to hold onto.

 

It was supposed to be impregnable.

 

The Duke of Guise came at it in the dead of winter, when nobody campaigned, with the garrison run down and the government in London slow to send money, and he took it in a week.

 

The loss landed on the country as a genuine national humiliation, and it landed on Mary, by every surviving account, as something closer to a private wound than a political setback, one she carried for the rest of her life, however short that life had left to run.

 

Everything else that had gone wrong in her reign, the fires, the failed pregnancy, the empty marriage, she could tell herself was God’s will or God’s test or someone else’s fault.

 

Calais was hers.

 

She had taken England into that war herself, over the objections of every man in her council, because her husband asked her to, and this was the bill.

 

By the autumn of that same year, the second phantom pregnancy had faded out of conversation the way the first one had, quietly, without a child, without even the dignity of a clean ending.

 

Except this time, unlike 1555, there would be no recovery afterward.

 

Whatever was swelling in her body was not going to become a child, and it was not going to go away, either.

 

By May of 1558, Mary’s health was failing in a way that was different from the chronic troubles she had carried most of her life.

 

This was something advancing, not something merely enduring.

 

In August, she came down with a fever, a strain of influenza her own century called the quartan ague, which was going through the country that year and killing people in numbers that emptied whole villages.

 

She seemed to fight it off.

 

She never got her strength back.

 

By the end of September, those close to her were describing a dropsy, a swelling of the body that nobody attending her could name more precisely than that.

 

Modern historians have proposed ovarian cancer, uterine cancer, and several other things, and none of it can be settled now, and none of it would have made any difference then.

 

There is a small exchange from this period that survives, and it is worth repeating exactly as it was recorded, because it tells you more about the woman than a page of description could.

 

One of her attendants, a gentlewoman named Jane Dormer, was asked by the queen whether she herself had recovered from a recent illness.

 

Dormer said that she was well.

 

Mary answered her simply, “So am not I.”

 

Two words apiece, and an entire truth sitting inside them.

 

She moved to St. James’s Palace and did not leave it again.

 

The government went on around her.

 

The war was still going.

 

The harvest had failed again.

 

The influenza was still killing people, including a great many of her own bishops, which meant that the Catholic Church she had spent 5 years rebuilding was losing the men she had built it with faster than they could be replaced in the same months she was dying herself.

 

On the 28th of October, Mary added a codicil to her will.

 

She had written the will in the spring in the confident expectation of a child, and it is full of provisions for that child, and every one of them had to be quietly set aside now.

 

She still could not bring herself to write her half sister’s name into the document.

 

What she wrote instead was that the crown would pass to her next heir by the laws of the realm, which meant Elizabeth, and everyone in that room, including Mary, knew precisely who it meant.

 

It was, in its own careful, wounded way, the closest thing to an acknowledgement she had left in her to give.

 

A few days later, she went further because the council made her.

 

She sent Jane Dormer to Hatfield with a message and with her own jewels, asking her sister for three things.

 

That she pay Mary’s debts, that she keep the Catholic religion as Mary had restored it, and that she be good to Mary’s servants.

 

Elizabeth agreed to one of those, and to precisely one, and everybody involved knew which.

 

The Spanish ambassador, the Count of Feria, arrived at court on the 9th of November, sent by Philip, and he did not go first to the dying queen.

 

He went to Hatfield, to Elizabeth, and had dinner with her, and came away from it thoroughly unsettled by how little she needed him.

 

Then he went and saw Mary, and by the 14th, he had written back to his king with a bluntness that left no room for hope.

 

“There is no hope of her life,” he reported.

 

“Each hour,” he wrote, he expected them to come and tell him she was dead, so fast was her condition falling away from one day to the next.”

 

Philip did not come.

 

He sent a message.

 

He was, he said, deeply grieved, and he was occupied with the affairs of his father, who was himself dying in a monastery in Spain, and he could not be spared.

 

In her final days, those who sat with her described a woman drifting at times into visions, speaking of small children she said she could see, and of music she said she could hear.

 

She had always loved music.

 

She had been playing since she was a child in her mother’s rooms.

 

And somewhere in that same fading stretch of days, she is recorded as having said something else, something that has outlasted nearly everything else she ever said.

 

She told the people around her that when she died, and they opened her body, they would find one word written on her heart.

 

Calais.

 

It is worth sitting with that now that you know what it means.

 

This was a woman whose entire life had been shaped by things taken from her without her consent.

 

A childhood full of betrothals broken by other people’s convenience.

 

A mother taken from her by law.

 

A title taken from her by her own father’s ambition.

 

A governess butchered in the tower for the crime of her own son’s opinions.

 

A husband who came late, left twice, and did not come back a third time.

 

Two pregnancies that her own body built out of nothing but longing, and then dismantled again twice in front of witnesses.

 

And in the end, on top of all of it, a city, a piece of ground she had never once set foot on, lost in a war she had entered for her husband’s sake more than her country’s.

 

And somehow, of everything this woman had lost in 42 years, it was the city she could not let go of, even as her own body was failing around her.

 

Not Philip.

 

Not the children who never came.

 

Calais.

 

She received the last rites around midnight on the 16th of November.

 

A few hours later, near 6:00 in the morning on the 17th, she heard mass in her own bedchamber.

 

And by every account, she was able to make the responses, still present enough in those final hours to take part in the ritual that had defined her entire life and cost her so much of it.

 

At the elevation of the host, she is said to have raised her eyes to it somewhere around 7:00 that same morning, quietly, without any of the drama her reign had so often produced, Mary the First of England, 42 years old, died.

 

There is a detail from that same day that neither Mary nor anyone standing near her body could have arranged.

 

Several hours later, that same afternoon, at Lambeth across the river, Cardinal Reginald Pole, Archbishop of Canterbury, the son of the governess who had raised her, the man who had come home from 20 years of exile to give her back her church, died as well of the same influenza that had been going through London all autumn.

 

He had been ill for weeks.

 

When they brought him word that the queen was dead, he is said to have gone silent for something close to a quarter of an hour, and then to have spoken about how alike their fortunes had been, hers and his, all their lives, and how alike they were even now.

 

He died that evening.

 

The two people who had spent five years trying, together, to turn England back into a Catholic country left the world within hours of each other, and the country they had built together did not last the week.

 

By noon that same day, Parliament had met and formally proclaimed Elizabeth queen.

 

In the streets of London, they lit bonfires again, the way they had lit them for Mary five years earlier, and set out tables, and gave away wine to strangers, and by every account, the noise went on into the night.

 

It is the same crowd.

 

That is the thing to hold on to.

 

It is the same city and largely the same people who had cheered themselves hoarse for her at Framlingham and at the Guildhall, and they were celebrating now that she was gone, and both of those things were completely sincere.

 

A rider named Nicholas Throckmorton carried Mary’s coronation ring out of London to Hatfield as proof, and by the time he got there, the news had already arrived ahead of him.

 

Word reached Philip in Brussels several days later.

 

What he wrote to his sister about the death of the woman he had married, left, come back to for money, and left again, has survived in a single line that tells you everything about what the marriage had actually been underneath the gold cloth and the matching robes.

 

He felt, he wrote, a reasonable regret for her death.

 

A reasonable regret, not grief, not loss.

 

A reasonable regret, the kind of phrase a man uses about the passing of a useful business partner.

 

And in some ways that is closer to what Mary had been to him than either of them would have wanted at the start to admit.

 

Within weeks, and I want to be exact about this because it is almost too much, he opened negotiations to marry her sister.

 

Her funeral was held in mid-December, and she was buried at Westminster Abbey on the 14th, not, as she had specifically asked in her will, beside her mother.

 

Catherine of Aragon’s remains stayed where they had always been, at Peterborough, and Mary was laid in the Abbey alone, and her grave was marked, according to at least one account, with stones taken from altars that had themselves been torn down in the upheavals of the century she had spent her whole life fighting against.

 

There is something almost too fitting in that detail to invent.

 

A woman who had given five years of her reign to putting the old altars back, finding her own grave marked, in the end, with the broken pieces of them.

 

The bishop who preached the funeral sermon praised her and said she had been a king’s daughter, a king’s sister, and a king’s wife, and a queen, and had been all of it well.

 

He was arrested afterward for saying so.

 

Word of her death did not travel through England as universal grief.

 

Some genuinely mourned her, particularly among the Catholic faithful who had seen her, rightly or not, as their protector.

 

Others, and there is no honest way to tell this story without saying so, felt something closer to relief.

 

The same complicated mixture of feeling Mary herself had once felt at another death years before in another palace, when another woman who had wronged her went to her own end.

 

What survived Mary longest, longer than her reign, longer than her marriage, longer in some ways than her own name, was the story other people told about her afterward, and that story did not take its lasting shape until several years after she was already in the ground.

 

In 1563, a Protestant writer named John Foxe, who had spent Mary’s entire reign living in exile on the continent, published a massive work called Acts and Monuments, better remembered today simply as Foxe’s Book of Martyrs.

 

It told, in vivid, unforgettable, name-by-name detail, the stories of the men and women burned during Mary’s reign.

 

It had woodcuts.

 

People who could not read could look at the pictures and understand exactly what they were being shown.

 

Copies were chained up in cathedrals next to the Bible.

 

It went through edition after edition for 300 years, and for most of English history, more households owned that book than owned any other book except scripture.

 

It is the most successful piece of political writing in the English language, and it did its work so thoroughly that the name it gave her, Bloody Mary, has outlasted almost everything else true about her.

 

Foxe was not lying.

 

That is what makes it so durable.

 

The people in his book were real.

 

They burned, and most of the details he gives can be checked against other sources and hold up.

 

What he did was not invention.

 

What he did was select and frame and stand at the shoulder of the reader and tell them what it meant.

 

And the woman who came out the other side of that process was not a woman at all anymore.

 

She was a warning.

 

And there were other things in those five years that the book had no reason to mention and that consequently almost nobody knows.

 

Roughly 800 English Protestants fled abroad during the burnings to Frankfurt and Geneva and Strasbourg.

 

And they came home again the moment Elizabeth took the throne.

 

And they came home radicalized having spent five years in the most rigorous Calvinist cities in Europe.

 

Those men became the Puritan movement.

 

The most consequential religious force in the next century of English history, the one that would eventually put an axe through a king’s neck, was assembled in exile by people running away from Mary’s fires.

 

There is also a quieter side to what she actually did with her five years.

 

One that has nothing to do with heresy at all.

 

And it took historians 400 years to start saying it out loud.

 

She rebuilt the navy that her sister would later use against the Armada, adding ships and more importantly overhauling how the fleet was funded and maintained.

 

She restored the Exchequer as the crown’s central financial institution, cleaning up the tangle of competing courts her father and brother had left behind.

 

She ordered a survey of crown lands in 1555 that got the rents in order.

 

In her final year, a new book of rates nearly tripled the crown’s customs revenue in a single stroke.

 

She chartered the Muscovy Company and opened English trade with Russia.

 

She had a plan drafted to reform the debased coinage her father had ruined.

 

These were not administrative footnotes.

 

They were the beginnings of a more organized, more solvent English state.

 

And by the cruelest kind of historical timing she died before any of it had time to bear fruit which meant that the credit for the recovery it produced went almost entirely to the sister who inherited it fully built without ever having to lay a single brick of the foundation herself.

 

The coinage reform went through in 1560.

 

Elizabeth’s government carried out Mary’s plan more or less as written and it worked and it is remembered as one of the great early achievements of the Elizabethan age.

 

Nearly 50 years after Mary’s death in the reign of James the first Elizabeth’s own remains were moved to join her sisters in the same vault at Westminster Abbey and a single monument was raised over both of them bearing an inscription in Latin that reads in translation that partners both in throne and grave here rest we two sisters Elizabeth and Mary in the hope of the resurrection.

 

The monument carries only Elizabeth’s effigy.

 

Mary even in death even sharing the same stone floor of the same vault was given no face of her own to look up at the visitors who came to see it.

 

It is a small lasting unfairness and it is not the only one.

 

Historians even now writing centuries after both women are gone still tend to call her Mary Tudor rather than Mary the first quietly withholding the regnal dignity that is never once withheld from her sister.

 

It is the kind of habit that reveals if you look closely enough exactly how thoroughly one woman’s reputation was allowed to calcify into caricature while the others was permitted to grow into legend.

 

There is a tomb at Westminster Abbey where two sisters lie together and if you go and stand over it today you will see the same thing visitors saw 400 years ago.

 

One face carved in stone looking up Elizabeth’s.

 

Mary is there, too, in the same vault, under the same floor, but she was never given a likeness of her own, only a name carved alongside her sister’s, sharing the honor without sharing the recognition.

 

It is such a small unfairness next to everything else that was taken from this woman over the course of her life, and yet it is somehow the one that lingers longest because it is the one that continues still every single day somebody walks over that stone and only really sees the one queen looking back.

 

I keep coming back to the heart, though, not the tomb, the heart and what she said would be written on it.

 

Most people who know anything at all about this woman know her by one name, the one Foxe gave her, and there is no honest version of tonight’s story that pretends the fires were not real or that 287 people did not actually burn, or that a woman who ordered that does not have to answer in whatever way history answers anyone for having ordered it.

 

I am not going to soften that on her behalf.

 

She would not have thanked me for it.

 

She believed she was saving souls, and she was wrong about that in ways that cost real people their actual lives in public, in front of their own families, and being fond of somebody’s story does not mean pretending they did no harm.

 

But, I don’t think that’s the truest thing about her, and I don’t think it is the thing she would have wanted written on her own heart, either, if she had been given any choice in the matter, which by the sound of it she believed she was not.

 

What she chose at the very end, with her body already failing and no reason left to perform anything for anyone, was a city, not her husband, who wrote of her death the way a man writes about a business arrangement that has concluded.

 

Not the children who were never real, though God knows she wanted them to be.

 

Her city she had never once seen with her own eyes, lost in a war that was never really hers to begin with.

 

And somehow, of everything this life took from her, that was the loss she carried into the dark.

 

I think about the little girl who pointed at a priest before she could properly talk, and said the one word that would end up defining the whole shape of her life.

 

I think about the string of grooms who promised her nothing and meant even less of it.

 

I think about a mother she was not allowed to sit beside while she died, and the letters that mother wrote her in secret, which she kept for the rest of her life.

 

I think about a night in an upstairs room in Essex with the tide going out and a boat waiting.

 

And a woman who could not make herself leave.

 

I think about a husband she begged twice not to go, and a gentlewoman named Strelly, who was the only honest person in a palace built to flatter.

 

The accounts of her reign do not agree with each other on very much.

 

They do not agree on what she looked like, or what she meant, or whether she was cruel or only certain, and they will not agree in another 400 years, either.

 

What she actually was, underneath the crown and underneath the name history gave her, is something closer to a woman who spent her entire life being told what she would receive, and receiving instead almost none of it.

 

She got the throne in the end, against every expectation stacked against her.

 

She never got the one thing she seems to have wanted more than the throne itself.

 

 

You Might Also Enjoy