News

A Dish fit for an Emperor, a Cold October Hunt, and the Mysterious Fall of the House of Habsburg

 

The death of Holy Roman Emperor Charles VI is often attributed to accidental mushroom poisoning, but some historians believe he was the victim of something much darker.  Charles VI was born in the Hofburg Palace in Vienna on October 1, 1685 .  The infant Archduke was the second son of Emperor Leopold I and the ruler’s third wife, Princess Eleonore Magdalena of Neuburg.

Coming from such an influential family, Karl aspired to power from a young age .  As the second son, Charles was not first in line to inherit his father’s throne.  The young archduke longed to ascend the throne.  However, in 1700 he saw an opportunity.  After the premature death of his cousin, King Charles II of Spain, who had no male heirs, Charles VI decided that he was as suitable for this as anyone else.

Since both were members of the Habsburg dynasty, he boldly proclaimed himself King of Spain, causing immediate and lasting chaos.  These self-confident actions of Charles immediately provoked conflict in Spain over the Spanish inheritance, and it was by no means a short affair. The conflict lasted for almost 14 years, during which the French claimant Philip, Duke of Anjou, grandson of the King of France, attempted to wrest the throne of the late Charles II from the newly proclaimed Charles VI.

However, the Austrian king had his supporters.  Despite his unexpected announcement, Charles VI’s proclamation as king found powerful supporters in Europe.    The list of supporters included the kingdoms of England, Ireland, Scotland, Portugal, most of the German lands, the Netherlands, and a large part of the Holy Roman Empire, which supported Charles’s claims, making him a strong candidate.

Such strong support inspired him to move.  Although it took some time , Charles eventually moved to Spain in 1705 to take his throne.  He remained there for the next 6 years, where, oddly enough , he was known by the name of Charles III.  For the sake of clarity, we will continue to refer to him by his later title— Charles VI.

However, due to the long-running conflict in Spain, Charles could only effectively exercise his rule over the principality of Catalonia.  He also needed to find someone to sit next to him.  To consolidate the family’s power in the region, Charles’s father, the emperor, and his advisors set about arranging a marriage for the new Spanish king.

Charles’s own interest in marriage was probably limited solely to political considerations.  More about that later.  And from a short list of potentially profitable alliances, his suitors’ attention focused on one obvious favorite. Charles’ family ultimately settled on Elisabeth Christina of Brunswick- Wolfenbüttel, the eldest daughter of a powerful German duke.

After hasty preparations, they were married in 1708, giving Spain a new queen along with its new king. At only 23 years old, Karl achieved significant success.  Karl far exceeded expectations as a second son.  He not only became king, but also secured a marriage that strengthened his power in the region.

In terms of appearance, he also proved to be above his level. Contemporaries claimed that the new wife of the not-at-all- handsome Charles, Elizabeth, was extraordinarily beautiful.  But just as Karl was beginning to settle into life in Catalonia, an unexpected loss in his family forced him to return home. Despite his active participation in organizing the marriage, Karl’s father did not live to see his son’s wedding.

Emperor Leopold I died in 1705, opening the way for Charles’s brother, Joseph I, to rule. However, while Leopold’s reign was one of the longest among the Habsburgs, Joseph was less fortunate.    The new emperor died unexpectedly in 1711, changing Charles’s life forever. He hurried back to Vienna to carry out his unexpected ascension to the throne.

At the time of his brother’s death, Karl was first in line for the highest office.  Upon his return to Vienna in 1711, the King of Spain ascended the throne as Charles VI, Holy Roman Emperor and ruler of the Habsburg Monarchy. These were dizzying days for the new emperor, and the situation barely calmed down after his coronation.

Some were not at all impressed by the news of Charles’s accession to the throne of Holy Roman Emperor .  The Kingdom of Great Britain, in particular, was alarmed by the prospect of a personal union between Austria and Spain, i.e. rule by a single monarch, and withdrew its support for the Austrian coalition, causing yet another conflict in Europe.

Fortunately, it didn’t last long.  By 1713, the conflict caused by Charles’s accession to the throne had culminated in three different agreements that changed the balance of power in Europe. These were the Utrecht, Rastatt, and Baden peace treaties.  The last of these, in particular, brought Karl both expenses and gains.

The Treaty of Baden, ratified in 1713, contained strict conditions for Emperor Charles VI.  The most painful thing for him was the transfer of the Spanish throne to the newly recognized King of Spain, Philip.  However, although he had to give up his crown, Charles received in return vast territories of former Spanish possessions.

The Kingdom of Naples, the Duchy of Milan , the Austrian Netherlands, and the Kingdom of Sardinia now ceded to the Austrian monarchy.  Despite all these achievements, Charles was saddened by the loss of his first royal love.    The new emperor was reportedly extremely disappointed at the loss of dominion over Spain, as he had become attached to the region during his reign there.

Having secured the lands, Charles was able to turn his attention to future concerns. The death of his brother in 1711 placed the incoming Charles VI in a unique position.  He became the last male heir of the Habsburgs in the direct line.  This placed the monarchy in an extremely precarious position, guaranteeing a succession crisis if anything happened to the emperor.

With that in mind, Carl and his wife got down to business.  Charles and Elizabeth, like all good royal couples, began working to produce heirs to the Habsburg throne. In total, the couple had four children: the firstborn, Archduke Leopold Johann, born in 1716, and three daughters: Maria Theresa (1717), Maria Anna (1718), and Maria Amalia (1724).

Tragically, however, not all of their descendants survived to adulthood.  Sadly, only two of Karl’s children survived childhood. His youngest daughter, Maria Amalia, tragically died at the age of six.  And, most importantly for the Habsburg family, Charles’s eldest child, his son and heir Leopold Johann, lived only about seven months.

The only consolation in the face of this unthinkable tragedy were the other two children .  Karl’s two surviving daughters grew up to become interesting characters in their own right .  The younger, Maria Anna, became regent of the Austrian Netherlands.  His eldest daughter, Maria Theresa, also had an exciting life. Despite their successes, none of them solved the problem of the lack of a male heir , which prompted the emperor to take legislative action.

The Habsburg possessions were subject to Salic law, which meant that women of the Habsburg line could not inherit the throne as heiresses. Anticipating the interruption of the male line of heirs, Charles issued the “Pragmatic Sanction” of 1713, which abolished exclusively male succession within the monarchy’s possessions.

With one stroke of the pen, Charles secured the future of his daughters and angered many other royals.  Given Charles’s position as the last male heir in the line, it was obvious that the next Habsburg monarch after the emperor’s death would be a woman.  Karl, however, wanted to be sure that it was his direct line that would continue.

His late brother and predecessor, Joseph I, also had only daughters , who would have inherited the throne before Charles’ daughters.  The emperor, however, did not agree, even going so far as to break his promise. When Charles’s father, Emperor Leopold I, was still alive, even he saw an approaching succession crisis due to the acute shortage of males in the Habsburg line.

Before leaving for Spain, Charles’s father forced both of his sons to sign a mutual succession pact, guaranteeing Joseph’s daughters’ rights to the throne over Charles’s daughters.  However, when Leopold and Joseph were gone, Charles abandoned this arrangement.  To do this, he needed support.  With the birth of his first daughter, Maria Theresa, Charles disinherited both of his nieces, ensuring that the transition of power after his death would be anything but simple.

To bolster his daughter’s support, Charles spent much of his reign appealing to other European powers for help in implementing his Pragmatic Sanction .  He was in a vulnerable position, and other monarchies knew it. Other European powers understood that Charles VI was not in the best negotiating position.  On a global scale, they were almost indifferent to which Habsburg woman would eventually ascend the throne.

So they put forth harsh conditions to the desperate emperor.  Among them was Britain’s demand that Austria close the Ostend Company —a demand that personally offended the emperor.  With capitalism steadily developing in 18th-century Europe, Charles decided to seize the moment by founding the Ostend Company in 1722 —a chartered trading organization that competed with the British, Dutch, and French East India Companies .

However, eager to secure an inheritance for his daughter, Karl reluctantly agreed to close the company in exchange for British support.  The rest soon joined them. Karl’s appeals were quite successful, at least for a time, and the list of supporters he attracted to support his daughter’s claims was impressive .  The states that recognized the sanction were : Bavaria, Denmark, Norway, the Diets of the Holy Roman Empire, the Dutch Republic, France, Great Britain, the Papal States, Prussia, Russia, Savoy-Sardinia, Saxony-Poland, Spain, and Venice.

Oho!  They tipped the scales decisively against Karl’s nieces, but that didn’t stop the young women from fighting.  The foundations of Charles’s European support began to shake when both of his nieces agreed to political marriages.  One married the ruler of Saxony, the other a Bavarian nobleman.  And this subsequently prompted these rulers to reject the binding decisions of the Imperial Diet regarding succession.

But while his nieces were building their support base, Charles was also expanding his influence on the continent. Charles VI greatly expanded the Habsburg monarchy during his reign, especially after his success in the Austro- Turkish conflict of 1716–1718.    The Austrian victory annexed the Banat region of Hungary to the monarchy, and also established direct Austrian rule over Serbia and Oltenia as far as the lower Danube.

Even in compromises, Karl often emerged victorious.  After a dispute with Turkey, the conflict of the Quadruple Alliance began from 1718 to 1720.    The Austrian victory in this conflict led to the signing of the Treaty of The Hague, under which Charles exchanged Sardinia from the Duke of Savoy for the large, albeit difficult to defend, island of Sicily.

Indeed, Karl gained much, but it foreshadowed significant losses.  Despite his success in securing European support for his daughter’s succession, Charles’s “Pragmatic Sanction” did not work everywhere.  A total of five European monarchies ultimately rejected this agreement.  France, Spain, Prussia, as well as the two monarchies into which his nieces married: Bavaria and Saxony-Poland.

The reasons for these ruptures were varied, and some of them shook Europe to its very foundations .  After the Hague Treaty, a period of relative peace reigned in Europe. However, in 1733 all this was destroyed by the outbreak of conflict over the Polish inheritance.  In the disputes over the throne, Charles provided Austrian support to Stanisław Leszczyński.

France took the opposite side, supporting Augustus of Saxony .  This indirect conflict between the two monarchies forced France to abandon its previous adherence to Charles’s ” Pragmatic Sanction “.  Charles VI was a devout Catholic all his life and sought to revive religion in Europe after the Reformation.  After the Peace of Pozharevsky in 1718, by which the regions were liberated from the Ottoman Empire and annexed to the Habsburg territories , Charles supported the restoration of Catholic church structures in these newly conquered

lands.  However, he was less tolerant of other faiths. Charlemagne was not as enthusiastic about other Christian denominations and severely restricted the rights and freedoms of other faiths within the empire.  However, he later relented somewhat, returning old privileges to his subjects of the Orthodox faith. Perhaps he felt that he did not have long left and wanted to atone for his guilt.

He was far from the truth.  Throughout his life, Karl was an avid hunter and often went on long journeys to enjoy this activity.  In October 1740, he went hunting across the Hungarian border. The conditions were dangerous.  That month went down in history as the wettest and coldest October in human memory.

Karl’s entourage tried to warn him.  The day Karl went hunting was cold, with heavy rain.  By this time, the emperor had become much weaker than before, and doctors warned him that he was risking his health by setting out on a journey in such a state. Eager to hunt ducks, Carl dismissed any reservations.  This decision turned out to be fatal for the emperor.

Karl returned from hunting frozen and soaked to the skin. While staying at his country palace, La Favorita, the emperor quickly felt the heat and began to suffer from colic.  However, in the face of illness, Karl remained stubborn, believing that a hearty meal would put him back on his feet.  Despite his poor condition, Karl insisted that the chefs prepare him one of his favorite dishes—Catalan mushroom stew.

According to Voltaire’s memoirs, the cooks inadvertently prepared this dish with poisonous mushrooms.  Whether it was true or not, Carl soon learned what kind of flavor they had when they came back .  Whether it was the food , the fever, or a deadly combination of both , Karl was in for a tough evening. His illness worsened considerably, and he spent the entire night of October 10-11 in continuous vomiting, which brought little relief.

Unfortunately, his servants applied the best medical practices of the time, which turned out not to be the best idea.  As a darkly comical testament to how little medical knowledge existed at the time, some historians believe that Charles’s doctors may have treated him with the most deadly drug of the era— arsenic.  This dangerous substance was used to treat everything from fever to stomach aches, and many of Karl’s symptoms matched arsenic poisoning, including the lack of signs of liver failure, which is typical of mushroom poisoning.

Whether or not they used arsenic, things looked bad for Carl the next morning. His entourage understood that better conditions were needed to guarantee the emperor proper treatment.  They arranged for Karl to be transported to Vienna in a soft carriage. It was a long, exhausting journey that ultimately proved futile.

Although he reached Vienna barely alive, Charles VI died of his illness 9 days later, on October 20, 1740 .  Tragically, he was only 55 years old. Perhaps his premature death could have been avoided , but contemporaries could not even agree on the cause. Despite the view of some historians that Charles’s death may have been hastened by accidental arsenic poisoning, for most, the main suspects in Charles’s demise remained colds and mushrooms.

Many simply believed that the ailing emperor had been in the harsh, rainy conditions of the Hungarian countryside for too long , and his immune system could not cope with the strain.  However , others have blamed potentially poisonous mushrooms, and Karl is sometimes included in lists of famous victims of this product.

Be that as it may, after the emperor’s death, Europe exploded due to the precarious state in which he had left the question of succession.  After his death, Charles’s Pragmatic Sanction, the work of his entire life, became the subject of serious controversy.  Within weeks of the emperor’s death, an anti-sanctions coalition formed, consisting of Bavaria, France, Poland, Prussia, Saxony, and Spain, which rejected the agreement and launched attacks on the Austrian border, starting a costly conflict over the Austrian inheritance.

Charles left his daughter the kingdom, and with it a huge headache.  After her father’s death, the conflict over the inheritance haunted Charles’s daughter and heiress, Maria Theresa, for the next eight years. Thanks to her leadership qualities, she eventually saved the crown and most of the territory, but it came at a high cost, and the blame for this lies partly with her father.

The question of succession was not the only thing that Charles left without proper protection.  At the time of his death, the emperor left the Habsburg lands in debt, which put Mary in a difficult position.  Indeed, she inherited the Habsburg treasury with only 100,000 florins, and finances were not the only thing she lacked.

Charles VI also left his daughter the Austrian army in poor condition.  Disparate army units remained scattered throughout the empire, housed in small, mostly ineffective barracks.  As a result , morale among the soldiers was low, and desertion became widespread.  It’s amazing how Maria Theresa was able to survive, especially after eight years of struggle.

Her father’s legacy, however, remains largely untarnished .  In the centuries since his death, Emperor Charles VI has been consistently depicted on many collectible coins and medals. In particular, in 2006, Austria issued a commemorative coin of the Gottweig Abbey, on the reverse of which a portrait of Charles is clearly visible.

 

You Might Also Enjoy