The Scandalous Life of Queen Victoria’s “Unstable” Granddaughter
In January 1891, a seemingly innocent gathering of German aristocrats at a hunting lodge outside Berlin would set off a scandal that lasted for years. What began that night would lead to a secret campaign of anonymous letters, a court-martial, a fatal duel, and revelations that sent shockwaves through the German royal court.
She was the eldest daughter and second child of Prince Frederick William of Prussia, who would later become Emperor Frederick III. Her mother was Victoria, a Princess Royal of Great Britain. Thus, Charlotte was a maternal granddaughter of Queen Victoria, the great monarch who ruled over the British Empire at its height between 1837 and 1901.
Charlotte’s older brother was the future Kaiser Wilhelm II. His birth had been difficult and had left him with a malformed left arm. This meant that in her early years, Charlotte was often overlooked in the family’s affairs, as Wilhelm’s health condition took precedence, as he was second in line to the throne and expected to become emperor one day.
Charlotte’s mother, who was affectionately known as Vicky, was initially very close to her eldest daughter, but as Charlotte grew older, their relationship began to change. By the age of two, Charlotte had earned the nickname “sweet naughty little Dita”, and she would go on to prove the most difficult of the family’s eventual eight children.
As a young girl, she was often nervous and easily agitated, sometimes pulling anxiously at her clothes. She also developed a habit of biting her nails so severely that her parents resorted to making her wear gloves to stop it, but such measures only offered temporary relief. The reports from letters and diaries at the time record a very difficult relationship between mother and daughter that did not soften as the months and years went by.
At just 21 months, for instance, which was obviously hardly an advanced age, Victoria was writing in a concerned manner about her daughter’s tantrums. Then, when she was 3 years old, she complained of hyperactivity and sudden mood swings. While later, she continued to argue that she was a difficult child. From London, Queen Victoria urged her daughter to be more patient with her granddaughter, though with little success.
Yet, as we will soon see, there may have been more to this behavior than simply a difficult temperament. Some historians have suggested that Charlotte may have inherited a medical condition from her British ancestors, one that could be traced back to the 18th century. But, her behavior was not Victoria’s only source of frustration.
Charlotte was also an indifferent student, which disappointed her mother, who placed great importance on education. Nevertheless, it wasn’t just Charlotte who received this harsh treatment. Victoria was extremely strict with her three eldest children. These were Wilhelm and Charlotte, as mentioned, and Henry, who was born in 1862.
After Henry came two more boys and three girls. Sadly, the boys, Prince Sigismund and Prince Waldemar, died in childhood. Sigismund died in 1866 before his second birthday, while Waldemar died in 1879 at the age of 11. Their deaths devastated Victoria, and over time, a noticeable difference emerged in the way she treated her children.
She remained strict with Wilhelm, Charlotte, and Henry, while becoming more affectionate and indulgent towards her three younger surviving daughters, Victoria, Sophie, and Margaret. The difference did not go unnoticed. Wilhelm, Charlotte, and Henry could sense their mother’s disappointment, and they grew increasingly resentful as they watched her shower their younger siblings with the affection they felt they had been denied.
For Charlotte, these tensions would leave a lasting mark. Her difficult relationship with her mother, combined with her own restless temperament, made her childhood far from easy. But childhood could not last forever, and soon Charlotte would enter a new world. In January 1871, the German Empire was formed under Prussian domination, and Charlotte’s grandfather became Emperor Wilhelm I.
Simultaneously, the Second Industrial Revolution was transforming Germany into an economic behemoth, and the new imperial power had quickly emerged as one of the world’s great powers. This new-found status meant that royal daughters like Charlotte were suddenly being courted by the governments of many of Europe’s royal houses as potential marriage partners by any country that wanted closer ties to the German Empire.
Thus, the details of Charlotte’s engagement, which was announced on the 1st of April, 1877, just before her 17th birthday, were perhaps a little surprising. She would not marry a foreign prince. Instead, she was to wed her second cousin, Bernhard, the Hereditary Prince of Saxe-Meiningen, a soldier who had fought in the Franco-Prussian War in 1870 to 1871, and who was also a scholar.
While the marriage didn’t unite Germany to a foreign power, it did serve a broader dynastic purpose. By marrying the heir of Saxe-Meiningen, Charlotte would strengthen the ties between the Prussian royal family and another German ruling house. This was particularly significant within the newly established German Empire, where Prussia dominated the imperial structure, but the individual German states and their ruling families still retained considerable influence.
Also, this was not an entirely arranged match between strangers. Charlotte already knew Bernhard, and their courtship had begun during a fairground trolley ride in Berlin. Charlotte’s older brother decided to speed up the ride, and when his frightened sister clung to Bernhard, an unlikely romance was set in motion.
During her teenage years, however, her difficult behavior had taken new forms. She was known for flirting, spreading malicious gossip, and stirring up trouble, traits her mother hoped she would eventually outgrow. Victoria now hoped that marriage might give her daughter some direction, writing that “At least her wicked qualities will not be able to cause any harm.
” Perhaps then, Bernhard seemed like a suitable match. Charlotte was strong-willed and knew what she wanted, while Bernhard was considerably more reserved. But not everyone believed the marriage was simply a good dynastic match. Princess Catherine Radziwill, who was familiar with the Imperial Court, later claimed that Charlotte herself had pushed for the marriage despite her young age because she wanted to escape her mother’s influence.
The journey from engagement to marriage took roughly a year. The wedding took place on the 18th of February, 1878, at the chapel of Berlin Schloss. Charlotte was 17, while Bernhard was 26. Strangely, some guests remarked on how well Charlotte looked, but behind closed doors she was said to have been quite ill and fainted several times during the day.
It was a sign of how fragile her health always was. Afterwards, the newlyweds settled at Potsdam, where on the 12th of May, 1879, Charlotte gave birth to her one and only child, a daughter whom they named Feodora. Notably, she was Queen Victoria’s first great-grandchild. Charlotte had come to relish Berlin’s glittering high society, where she was admired for her fashion, lively parties, and sharp tongue.
She resented anything that risked this freedom, and pregnancy had been something that she particularly disliked. After Feodora’s birth, Charlotte appears to have made a private decision. She would have no more children. Before long, she was back enjoying society life in Berlin and taking long holidays. However, in the coming years, a dangerous scandal would ruin her reputation and bring her lifestyle crashing down.
In March 1888, Charlotte’s father finally ascended the German throne as Emperor Frederick III. Tragically, his reign would last just 99 days before he died of throat cancer. His death brought Charlotte’s brother to the throne as Wilhelm II and Charlotte’s position at the Imperial Court became even more prominent.
However, it was a fateful event a few years later that would truly cement Charlotte’s notorious legacy. In January 1891, she hosted what was supposed to be an ordinary skating party and dance at the Jagdschloss Grunewald hunting lodge outside Berlin. The exclusive guest list included top-tier German aristocracy, notably Duke Ernst Günther of Schleswig-Holstein and Prince Frederick Charles of Hesse.
Much of what happened that night has been obscured by a rumor and legend. What is clear is that heavy drinking and various simultaneous illicit extramarital affairs, to put it lightly, turned a wild social gathering into the beginning of a scandal that lasted for years. In the days that followed the gathering, dozens of individuals began receiving blackmail letters, presumably from someone who had attended the event writing anonymously.
These described what had happened, dragged up old salacious gossip about some of the attendees, threatened to reveal the details of who had been present, and in some cases even included very explicit collages and images. Soon, word of the letters spread beyond the royal court and suspicion quickly fell on Charlotte.
Her reputation for sharp-tongued gossip led some contemporaries to believe that she was behind them. She herself had received letters from the anonymous sender, though several people believed at the time that she had merely sent these to herself in order to cover up her actions. The scandal escalated over a period of months and dragged on intermittently in the years that followed.
There was even a debate in the Reichstag on the letter scandal. Eventually, in June 1894, Liberet von Kotze, a master of ceremonies at the Imperial Court, who had attended the gathering that started the whole affair in January 1891, was arrested after suspicions emerged that he was at least responsible for the collages included with some of the letters.
Blotting paper was found in his desk and an examination determined that the handwriting was nearly identical, though late 19th century handwriting made it difficult to prove this beyond a reasonable doubt. He protested his innocence and was exonerated after being court-martialed. Eventually, Kotze reacquired his position at court, though not before fighting several duels against his accusers.
Despite the heavy suspicion on Charlotte, investigators eventually pinned the case on a different suspect. They concluded, perhaps wrongly, that the letters had been written by Ernst Günther’s mistress, who was deported to France and became an easy scapegoat. But Charlotte was far from escaping unscathed. The letter’s author had somehow obtained her personal diary, which contained intimate secrets about the Imperial family and the court.
Charlotte may not have written the letters, but her own carelessness had helped make the scandal possible. Wilhelm never fully forgave his sister. Bernhard was transferred to a regiment in Breslau, effectively exiling the couple from Berlin, while Wilhelm restricted their ability to travel abroad without giving up their royal privileges.
And the damage went far beyond Charlotte herself. The scandal had struck at the reputation of the German monarchy. Yet for Charlotte, another nightmare was taking root at home, a torment of mental breakdown, agony, and a terrifying royal disease. The letter scandal, or the Kotze affair as it is also sometimes known, was not the only difficulty for Charlotte in the 1890s.
Her relationship with her daughter was also increasingly tense. Charlotte was, by all accounts, not exactly a naturally affectionate mother. She had been happy to leave Feodora to be raised by her grandmother for protracted periods of time while she socialized in Berlin. Like mother, like daughter, Feodora began seeking out a husband so that she could escape her unhappy family environment.
In September 1898, the 19-year-old princess married 33-year-old Prince Heinrich XXX Reuss, a man who was neither wealthy nor particularly high-ranking. Because of this, the Imperial family considered the match beneath her, causing a serious rift between Charlotte and Feodora. This split grew increasingly bitter in the years that followed.
By 1900, Feodora was telling friends that her mother was actively spreading malicious gossip about her at court, including rumors that Feodora had contracted a venereal disease from her husband. In truth, Feodora was simply enduring a heartbreaking inability to conceive, undergoing a series of painful and dangerous procedures in a desperate bid to have a child.
What makes the feud between mother and daughter especially peculiar is that both women were seemingly quite ill in ways that were affecting their behavior towards each other. Charlotte’s catalog of health issues was recorded in detail over the years in her letters to her doctor. These included psychological symptoms such as fits of depression combined with physical issues like severe itching, rashes, swelling, nausea, and dizziness.
Later, she even reported occasional partial paralysis of her limbs while her urine color darkened. One night in 1909, she began screaming and ranting for hours until her doctor sedated her. Feodora suffered from many of the same symptoms, the only difference being that her condition appeared to be even more advanced at a younger age than it was with her mother.
Late 19th century medicine tended to characterize behavior like this as hysteria, especially when it was displayed by women. But modern analysis has looked at Charlotte and Feodora’s wider family background, in particular the case of their maternal ancestor King George III of Great Britain, to understand what was wrong with them.
George had suffered from bouts of hysteria and mania on and off from 1788 onwards, and had spent the last 10 years of his life between 1810 and 1820 in a world of his own. The most likely cause of what used to be termed the madness of King George was porphyria. This is a metabolic disorder whereby an enzyme deficiency creates porphyrins in the body that poison the system over time and lead to an array of both psychological and physical symptoms.
There is a convincing, though unprovable, case that both Charlotte and Feodora suffered from a hereditary form of porphyria, and that it explains both their tense relationship and Charlotte’s more problematic behavior throughout her adult life. Charlotte’s health continued to deteriorate through the 1900s and into the 1910s.
These were difficult years for the German Imperial family as a whole. Her brother, the emperor for instance, suffered a quasi-psychological breakdown in the late 1900s owing to the impact of the Eulenburg affair at court, which had seen questions raised about his own sexuality. His reckless foreign policy also drove Germany towards conflict with Britain and France and contributed in no small part to the outbreak of the First World War in the summer of 1914.
Right before that conflict erupted, Charlotte’s husband succeeded as Duke of Saxe-Meiningen. The New York Times would subsequently run a story with the headline “The Kaiser’s clever sister is now on a throne.” Charlotte’s health carried on declining during the war years. By the winter of 1917, she was reporting increased kidney pain and digestive disorders, and her mobility had become quite restricted.
A lot of her time was spent in a clinic where she was reliant to a growing degree on morphine for pain relief. She lived long enough to see her brother abdicates throne at the start of November 1918 and Germany’s defeat in the war. As the German Empire and its old system collapsed, her husband Bernhard relinquished his title under pressure from the Meiningen Workers and Soldiers Council as the German Revolution erupted.
Charlotte spent the next year between clinics and moving houses before suffering a heart attack on the 1st of October 1919. She was 59 years of age. Her husband died 9 years later aged 76 and was buried next to Charlotte at Schloss Altenstein in Thuringia. Sadly, there is no evidence that she and Feodora had ever reconciled after their earlier difficulties.
Despite her own poor health, Feodora lived down to 1945 when she, like her mother before her, died not long after a world war had ended. Despite Charlotte’s participation and contribution, the identity of the anonymous blackmailer in the letter scandal of the early 1890s has never been proven beyond a doubt.