“HE APPEARS TO BE DOING SOD ALL”: Ian Paice Finally Names 8 Drummers He Calls Untouchable
“HE APPEARS TO BE DOING SOD ALL”: Ian Paice Finally Names 8 Drummers He Calls Untouchable
When rock historians dissect the thunderous foundations of heavy metal and hard rock, Ian Paice stands as an untouchable titan.
As the solitary continuous member of Deep Purple across nearly six decades, his scorching single-stroke rolls and relentless swing powered immortal masterpieces like Smoke on the Water, Highway Star, and Space Truckin’.
Paice earned a legendary reputation for possessing some of the fastest hands in rock history, blending big-band jazz fluidity with explosive amplifier volume.
Yet behind that ferocious left-handed precision sits a musician who views the drums not as an athletic circus stunt, but as the sacred architectural engine of an entire band.
Paice has never cared about hollow technical shredding that merely impresses spectators for five fleeting minutes.
To him, real drumming greatness belongs exclusively to the players who know exactly what to leave out, how to lock into an infectious groove, and how to serve the song above all else.
When reflecting upon the masters who built the modern drumming vocabulary, Paice assembled a pantheon of eight players he considers truly untouchable.
His reflections challenge conventional rock journalism, offering surprising defenses of minimalists, deep bows to unsung groove pioneers, and a shocking revelation about who truly invented the heavy rock drum sound.
Here is the definitive, unfiltered breakdown of the eight drummers Deep Purple’s Ian Paice worships above all others.
8. Charlie Watts: The Master of Subtraction and the Relentless Backbeat
Opening Ian Paice’s sacred countdown at number eight is the understated gentleman of British rock and roll, Charlie Watts.
To the casual listener who judges drummers by lightning-fast fills and marathon twenty-minute solos, Charlie Watts often looked like a man doing very little behind his modest four-piece Gretsch kit.
Yet Ian Paice, a drummer world-renowned for his dazzling speed, has spent decades defending Watts as one of the most brilliant musicians to ever lift a pair of sticks.
Back in 1971, Paice delivered a legendary assessment to Record Mirror that remains one of the sharpest quotes in rock journalism.
Paice stated bluntly that when you listen to Charlie, that offbeat never falters, even though he appears to be doing sod all.
Paice followed that observation with an undeniable truth, stating that without Charlie Watts and bassist Bill Wyman holding down the groove, The Rolling Stones simply would not exist.
Watts grew up obsessed with jazz icons like Jelly Roll Morton, Charlie Parker, and Chico Hamilton, learning how to stroke the snare with brushes long before he ever heard a rock-and-roll record.
When he joined the Stones in 1963, he imported that sophisticated jazz sensibility into raw Chicago blues.
Watts held zero interest in flashy drum solos, viewing them as completely unnecessary displays of ego.
From roughly 1969 onward, Watts developed an idiosyncratic habit that became his sonic signature: he would completely lift his right hand off the hi-hat whenever he struck the snare on beats two and four.
That subtle physical absence opened up acoustic space for the snare drum to breathe, giving classics like Wild Horses, Monkey Man, and Let It Bleed their lazy, irresistible swagger.
Watts never tried to rush ahead of Keith Richards’s rhythm guitar; he followed Keith from behind with a laid-back snare strike that made the Stones virtually impossible for other musicians to replicate.
For Paice, Watts proved that true greatness is defined not by how many notes you can squeeze into a measure, but by having the supreme discipline to let the groove speak for itself.
7. Ringo Starr: Absolute Perfection That Nobody Could Ever Improve
Perhaps no drummer in popular music history has endured more lazy, uninformed ridicule from casual critics than Richard Starkey, known to the world as Ringo Starr.
For generations, skeptics have repeated the tired myth that Ringo was merely a lucky bystander who stumbled into the greatest songwriting partnership in human history.
Yet when Ian Paice talks about Ringo Starr, he shuts down the skeptics with fierce, uncompromising authority.
Paice does not judge Ringo through the narrow lens of double-stroke rolls or mathematical time signatures.
He listens to the sheer perfection of Ringo’s parts on every single Beatles recording, from the early pop innocence of She Loves You to the sprawling masterpieces of Sgt. Pepper, the White Album, and Abbey Road.
When analyzing Ringo’s playing on Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, Paice openly calls it brilliant, absolutely perfect, and completely unimprovable.
Paice argues with passion that you could assemble the most technically dazzling conservatory drummers on earth, and not a single one could improve upon Ringo’s choices.
Ringo possessed an uncanny melodic instinct, acting as a left-handed drummer playing a right-handed kit, which forced him to lead his fills with his left hand.
That physical quirk resulted in unconventional, tumbling tom-tom fills that arrived with breathtaking originality and emotional resonance.
Ringo never overplayed, never got in the way of Lennon and McCartney’s vocal harmonies, and consistently invented drum hooks that became as memorable as the vocal melodies.
While Ringo himself was notoriously modest, once describing his role on Sgt. Pepper as feeling like a session player, Paice hears a master who gave each individual track its exact heartbeat.
To Paice, Ringo’s genius was pure musicality, proving that playing the right four beats for the song is infinitely more profound than showing off empty technique.
6. Clayton Filio: The Unsung Architect Who Put the Funk in James Brown
The third legend on Paice’s countdown takes us to the historic night of October 24, 1962, inside Harlem’s legendary Apollo Theater.
James Brown had defied his record label boss, Syd Nathan, by personally funding the live recording of his own revue because executives believed a live album would never sell.
Leading the furious, sweat-drenched orchestra from the drum throne was a native of St. Petersburg, Florida, named Clayton Filio.
Most listeners know the earth-shaking voice and electrifying footwork of James Brown, but few know that the revolutionary rhythmic framework underneath that voice was constructed by Filio.
Filio had spent years touring the American South with Silas Green from New Orleans, absorbing the rolling second-line parade rhythms of the Crescent City.
When he joined James Brown’s band in 1961, Brown was so awestruck by his timing that he nicknamed him “Big’un” and introduced him on stage as the man who put the funk in the funk.
Filio actively rebelled against the standard shuffles of the late 1950s, stating that he hated straight shuffles and preferred dense, syncopated polyrhythms.
That bold rhythmic choice led directly to the creation of the classic James Brown funk beat, heavily accenting the downbeat on the “one.”
On groundbreaking cuts like I’ve Got Money and the legendary Live at the Apollo LP, Filio drove the entire ensemble with an infectious, volcanic energy that never wavered for a second.
Ian Paice speaks of Filio with pure, unvarnished reverence, marveling at how Clayton hit the groove and held that massive band together in such a vibrant, swingy, and funky way.
Live at the Apollo went on to spend sixty-six weeks on the Billboard charts and was eventually named by Rolling Stone as the greatest live album ever recorded.
Paice recognized that the funk-rock crossovers of the late 1960s owed an eternal debt to the swinging syncopation pioneered by Clayton Filio’s hands.
5. Bobby Elliott: The Clean, Cutting Precision of The Hollies
To understand Ian Paice’s own early musical evolution, one must examine what he describes as an unbroken relay race of British drumming influence.
In the middle of that historic relay stands Bobby Elliott, the legendary powerhouse behind Manchester pop-rock giants The Hollies.
Born in Lancashire, Elliott taught himself the instrument using homemade sticks and brushes on metal tins, obsessively studying American jazz heroes like Chico Hamilton and Gene Krupa.
When Elliott joined The Hollies, he brought that sharp, jazz-trained dynamic range to massive international hits like Bus Stop, Carrie Anne, and He Ain’t Heavy, He’s My Brother.
Elliott’s drum sound was an absolute revelation to a young Ian Paice, who was still trying to carve out his own identity on the UK club circuit.
Paice recalls that Bobby Elliott possessed a clean, razor-sharp sound that cut through the mix like an acoustic scalpel, separating him from the muddy, muffled tones of his peers.
More importantly, Paice noticed that Elliott was one of the few British rock drummers who was genuinely thinking about the structure and narrative of the song he was accompanying.
Paice openly confesses that he consciously patterned his own early playing style after what Bobby Elliott was doing with The Hollies.
Elliott’s reputation for peerless musicianship was so immense that in September 1973, Sir Paul McCartney personally invited him to take over the drum throne in Wings, an offer Elliott turned down to remain loyal to The Hollies.
Elliott passed that stylistic baton directly forward, profoundly influencing both Ian Paice and the legendary Cozy Powell.
To Paice, Elliott remains a towering example of crisp elegance, proving that pop music could accommodate sophisticated, jazz-rooted drum arrangements without losing its radio appeal.
4. Gene Krupa: The Flash, the Thunder, and the Invention of the Drum Solo
Every great artist possesses a singular initial spark that ignites their lifelong passion, and for Ian Paice, that spark was the cinematic spectacle of Gene Krupa.
Paice remembers watching Krupa in vintage motion pictures and being utterly mesmerized by the man’s dazzling physical charisma and larger-than-life presence.
Paice admits that it was the visual theatrics and kinetic flash of Krupa that first drew him into the world of drumming, long before he fully understood the mechanics of the music.
Yet behind that slick hair, chew-gum swagger, and flying drumsticks sat the man who literally invented the modern drum kit as we know it today.
In the late 1920s, Krupa became one of the very first jazz drummers to dare to record with a bass drum, defying engineers who claimed low frequencies would cause phonograph needles to skip.
When Krupa joined Benny Goodman’s orchestra in 1934, he transformed the drummer from an anonymous background timekeeper into a national superstar.
His thunderous, floor-shaking tom-tom rhythms on the 1937 classic Sing, Sing, Sing are universally recognized as the very first extended drum solos commercially captured on vinyl.
Krupa actively collaborated with the Slingerland Drum Company to develop tunable tom-tom heads, creating the mechanical hardware that every modern rock drummer relies upon.
Buddy Rich famously canonized Krupa as the beginning and the end of all drummers, recognizing that Gene had cleared the path for every percussionist who followed.
Paice acknowledges that while visual flair opens the door to an audience’s heart, it is Krupa’s foundational musicality that kept listeners hooked for a lifetime.
Gene Krupa gave rock and roll its very permission to be loud, dramatic, and unapologetically explosive.
3. Buddy Rich: The Inhuman Phenomenon Nobody Could Match
When musicians assemble to debate the greatest technician to ever hold a pair of wooden drumsticks, the conversation inevitably arrives at one solitary name: Buddy Rich.
Ian Paice does not merely admire Buddy Rich; he stands in complete, jaw-dropping awe of his impossible physical mechanics.
Of all the big-band drummers who ruled the twentieth century, Paice states without hesitation that Buddy stood head and shoulders above the entire field.
Paice points specifically to Rich’s legendary single-stroke roll, which could glide seamlessly from a whisper-quiet ghost note to an ear-splitting dynamic explosion at lightning speed.
With total humility, Paice—himself considered one of the fastest players on earth—delivers a stunning admission of his own limitations.
Paice confesses that while he can execute that single-stroke roll at the exact same speed as Buddy, he cannot maintain that velocity for anywhere near as long before his muscles seize up.
Buddy Rich was a true child-prodigy force of nature, headlining vaudeville stages as “Baby Traps the Drum Wonder” at the age of four without ever learning how to read sheet music.
His technique was completely organic, relying on supernatural reflexes, immaculate ear training, and photographic musical memory.
The list of witnesses who bow before Rich’s supremacy spans every era of music, from Gene Krupa calling him the greatest drummer to ever draw breath to Queen’s Roger Taylor calling his technique unmatched.
Travis Barker has repeatedly cited Buddy as the undisputed king of all time, while Mel Brooks spent six months taking drum lessons directly from Rich as a teenager.
Paice recognizes that Buddy Rich occupied a celestial tier of physical virtuosity that ordinary mortals simply could not inhabit.
Rich was living proof that when raw natural genius is paired with an uncompromising, ferocious work ethic, the drum kit can produce miracles that defy human explanation.
2. Earl Palmer: The New Orleans Patriarch Who Invented Rock and Roll Drumming
When Ian Paice sits down to discuss the origins of rock and roll, he bypasses the glamorous guitar heroes to focus on a New Orleans studio titan: Earl Palmer.
Paice makes a staggering statement that cuts straight to the core of music history, asserting that Earl Palmer did nearly everything and likely invented rock-and-roll drumming single-handedly.
Born in New Orleans in 1924, Palmer began his career as a tap dancer at age five, internalizing complex rhythmic syncopation through the soles of his shoes.
After studying formal composition at the Gruenewald School of Music, Palmer entered the studio with producer Dave Bartholomew and Fats Domino in 1949 to cut The Fat Man.
On that historic recording, Palmer made the conscious decision to replace the traditional jazz shuffle with a driving, heavy backbeat on the second and fourth beats of the bar.
That single decision marked the official birth of the modern rock-and-roll drum pulse.
Palmer went on to power Little Richard’s most explosive hits, laying down the volcanic, driving rhythm on Tutti Frutti, Long Tall Sally, and Lucille.
When he relocated to Los Angeles in 1957, Palmer became the backbone of the legendary session collective known as The Wrecking Crew, completing an astonishing 450 recording sessions in the year 1967 alone.
His drum tracks anchor Sam Cooke’s You Send Me, Ritchie Valens’s La Bamba, Eddie Cochran’s Somethin’ Else, and Ike and Tina Turner’s monumental River Deep – Mountain High.
He even supplied the unmistakable theme songs for television staples like The Flintstones, The Brady Bunch, and Mission: Impossible.
Paice marvels at how a solitary, humble session musician could sit behind hundreds of wildly different recordings and provide the definitive heartbeat for American culture.
Without Earl Palmer’s relentless New Orleans groove, the entire global phenomenon of rock and roll would have had no foundation upon which to stand.
1. Carmine Appice: The Heavy Metal Architect and the Unspoken Bonham Debt
Standing proudly at number one on Ian Paice’s pantheon of untouchable drummers is the Brooklyn-born powerhouse who birthed the hard-rock drumming dialect: Carmine Appice.
Paice does not hold back when evaluating Appice’s towering impact on the rock world, stating flatly that there is not a single great rock player alive whom Carmine has not influenced.
Appice first detonated across the international music scene in the late 1960s with psychedelic heavyweights Vanilla Fudge, blending classical training with the ferocious power of big-band jazz.
Paice credits Appice with completely rewiring his own conceptual understanding of rhythm during the formative days of Deep Purple.
Paice explains that Carmine taught him to stop thinking in predictable, straight four-four patterns, demonstrating instead how to construct drum parts around dramatic accents, pauses, and pushes.
Yet the most explosive revelation Paice delivers concerns the physical transformation of the rock drum kit itself in the early 1970s.
Paice reveals that his own decision to abandon a small, standard jazz kit in favor of an oversized, thunderous bass drum setup was a direct copy of Carmine Appice’s rig.
Paice then drops a verbal bomb that shatters classic rock mythology, stating point-blank that Led Zeppelin’s legendary John Bonham was massively influenced by Carmine Appice, even though Bonham never publicly admitted it.
Paice asserts with total certainty that both he and Cozy Powell openly credit Carmine for their heavy sound, while Bonham quietly adopted Appice’s massive drum sizes, acoustic tuning secrets, and triplet foot patterns without giving credit.
Following Vanilla Fudge, Appice continued to pioneer blues-rock with Cactus and joined forces with Jeff Beck in Beck, Bogert & Appice, before co-writing global anthems like Da Ya Think I’m Sexy? with Rod Stewart.
His 1972 instructional volume, The Realistic Rock Drum Method, became the definitive educational manual for generations of stadium drummers.
Paice concludes his tribute with the highest compliment a musician can offer, stating that Carmine Appice came the absolute closest to what Paice considers the perfect drum sound.
By mastering the balance between crushing arena power, intricate polyrhythmic accents, and pure showmanship, Carmine Appice cemented his status as the true godfather of heavy metal drumming.
The Unbroken Pulse of the Sacred Craft
Looking across Ian Paice’s definitive list of untouchable drummers, a profound and inspiring truth immediately crystallizes.
The man who provided the ferocious pulse for Deep Purple across six decades never viewed himself as an isolated genius working in a vacuum.
He recognizes that his own legendary hands are merely the conduits for a rich, vibrant tapestry of rhythm passed down through generations of masters.
Charlie Watts taught him the profound value of silence, discipline, and letting the groove breathe.
Ringo Starr showed him that melodic perfection and serving the song always conquer empty technical flash.
Clayton Filio demonstrated the undeniable, swinging power of New Orleans syncopation inside James Brown’s soul machine.
Bobby Elliott gave him the crisp, clean precision and intellectual approach of the British Invasion.
Gene Krupa provided the theatrical spark that proved a drummer could command the spotlight like a movie star.
Buddy Rich set an impossible, godlike standard of physical single-stroke endurance that humbled every player on earth.
Earl Palmer engineered the foundational backbeat that allowed rock and roll to conquer the planet.
And Carmine Appice provided the colossal volume, oversized kits, and rhythmic pushes that built the entire temple of heavy metal.
At the summit of hard-rock history, Ian Paice remains a humble, dedicated student of the groove, still listening, still marveling, and still proving that the drums remain the true, beating heart of rock and roll.