Clint Eastwood CHALLENGED Jerry Lee Lewis to a Piano-Off — The Crowd Couldn’t BELIEVE Their Eyes
On a warm October evening in 1969, inside the Ryman Auditorium in Nashville, Tennessee, Clint Eastwood ended up flat on his back on the stage floor.
A wooden piano bench rolling slowly away from him across the boards, while more than 2,000 people laughed so hard that the sound engineers later said the needles on their meters simply gave up.
Standing over him, laughing hardest of all, was Jerry Lee Lewis.
And watching from the side of the stage with his hand over his face, trying and failing to look like a host who had everything under control, was Johnny Cash.
It was the single funniest thing anyone who was in the building that night ever saw on a television stage.
And it all started with eight words said backstage by a man who had no idea what he was starting.
The Johnny Cash Show had been on the air since June of that year, taped in front of a live audience at the Ryman, the old red brick tabernacle that had been the home of the Grand Ole Opry for a quarter of a century.
It was, even in its first season, a strange and wonderful program.
Cash booked whoever he wanted, and what he wanted was range.
Folk singers sat next to rockabilly legends.
Gospel quartets followed protest songs.
A young songwriter from the Midwest who barely gave interviews had played that stage in the very first episode.
Cash liked the collisions.
He liked putting people in a room who had never been in a room together, and then standing back to see what happened when the tape was rolling.
That October, he had two guests booked for the same taping who could hardly have been more different if he had designed them in a laboratory.
The first was Jerry Lee Lewis, 34 years old, the man they called the killer, the wildest piano player rock and roll had ever produced.
12 years earlier, he had been one of the most famous young men in America, a blond whirlwind from Ferriday, Louisiana, who played piano as if it had personally insulted him.
Then, scandal had knocked him almost completely out of the business for the better part of a decade, the kind of fall that ends most careers for good.
And in 1968, he had clawed his way back, not through rock and roll, but through country music, with a run of records that put back on the charts and back on stages like this one.
He was on the show to sing his new country material.
Everyone in the building knew that sooner or later, he would forget all about the country material and start pounding the keys the old way.
The second guest was Clint Eastwood.
He was 39, fresh off Where Eagles Dare, a year past Hang ‘Em High, and in Nashville, mostly because Cash, a lifelong fan of westerns, had personally asked him to come on and talk about his new picture.
The new picture was Paint Your Wagon, a lavish, expensive gold rush musical opening that very month, in which Clint had done something no one expected of the man with no name.
He had sung, not dubbed, himself, his own voice, a few quiet songs to a campfire and a pine tree.
Early word from the critics who had seen it was not kind about the singing, and Clint knew it.
He had agreed to come on the show on one condition, which he had made very clear to Cash’s producers over the phone.
He would talk about the picture.
He would not sing anything from it.
That, he said, was a mercy to everybody.
What nobody on Cash’s staff knew, and what almost nobody in the entertainment business knew in 1969, was that Clint Eastwood could play the piano.
Not in the way a lot of actors could pick out a tune for a scene.
Properly.
He had grown up in and around Oakland in the 30s and 40s in a house where his mother played jazz records in the evening.
Fats Waller and Duke Ellington and the big dance bands.
And he had learned by ear at an old upright trying to make his hands do what the records did.
As a teenager, he had played in a club in Oakland for tips and the occasional free meal.
He still played nearly every night at home.
Slow blues and old standards, mostly alone.
It was the most private thing about him.
He had never once played in public as Clint Eastwood.
He was about to.
And it was going to be Jerry Lee Lewis’s fault.
Before we dive in, tell us where in the world you’re watching from and press subscribe.
Clint arrived at the Ryman a little after 3:00 that afternoon for the rehearsal in a tan jacket and boots with no entourage beyond one publicist from the studio who spent most of the day on the backstage payphone.
The old building had never been designed as a television studio and it showed.
Cables ran everywhere.
Cameras had been bolted into positions where church pews used to be.
The dressing rooms were small and hot and shared.
And the corridors behind the stage were narrow enough that two people passing each other had to turn sideways.
In one of those corridors, pushed against a wall under a bare bulb, stood an old upright piano the house band used to warm up on.
It had cigarette burns along the lid and two keys in the upper octave that stuck.
Clint found it about 20 minutes after he arrived while the crew was still arguing about the lighting.
Nobody was around.
He sat down on the stool the way a man sits down in his own kitchen, tested the keys, winced at the two that stuck, and then started to play.
Slowly.
An old blues, the kind that sounds like somebody talking to himself late at night after everyone else has gone to bed.
Spare in the right hand.
The left hand walking steady underneath, patient, never in a hurry.
He played the way some men whittle.
Not for anyone.
Just to think.
He did not hear the footsteps behind him.
He did not notice, for a good two minutes, that he had an audience of one leaning against the far wall of that corridor with his arms folded and an expression on his face somewhere between curiosity and outright suspicion.
“Well, I’ll be.”
Said Jerry Lee Lewis.
Clint stopped playing and turned around.
Jerry Lee was already in his stage clothes, a loud jacket and his hair combed high and golden in the way that had made mothers across America nervous 12 years earlier.
He pushed himself off the wall and ambled over, grinning, and looked down at the keyboard as though it had personally betrayed him by letting a movie cowboy touch it.
“Now I’ve seen everything.”
Jerry Lee said.
“Cowboys don’t play piano, they sit on them.”
It was meant as a joke, and Clint took it as one.
He didn’t get up.
He just looked at Jerry Lee for a long, level moment with the expression audiences had been watching on cinema screens for five years, and then said, very quietly,
“That’s so?”
“That’s so.”
Said Jerry Lee, grinning wider.
“Man plays piano, he plays it.”
“He don’t pet it.”
“That thing you were doing just now, that was nice.”
“That was real nice.”
“That was the kind of thing a fellow plays in a hotel lobby while folks check in.”
“I’m talking about playing a piano, making it holler, making the people in the back row stand up whether they want to or not.”
“There’s more than one way to play a piano.”
Clint said.
“There’s one way.”
Jerry Lee said cheerfully.
“Mine.”
“Everything else is just typing.”
Clint considered that for a moment.
Then he played a single low note, let it ring down the corridor until it disappeared, and said,
“Tell you what.”
“Why don’t we let the people in the back row decide.”
Jerry Lee’s grin changed shape.
It got sharper and a great deal happier.
There was nothing in the world the killer loved more than a challenge, and in 12 years nobody had been fool enough to challenge him at the piano to his face.
“You mean on the show?”
He said.
“In front of all them people?”
“On television?”
“I mean on the show, Mr.”
said Jerry Lee Lewis.
“You have just made the worst mistake of your entire life, and I have seen your hat.”
They shook on it right there in the corridor.
Neither of them, at that point, had asked Johnny Cash.
Johnny Cash found out about 40 minutes later from his stage manager, who had heard it from a lighting technician, who had heard it from a young man in the house band, who had been standing at the other end of the corridor the whole time and could not stop talking about it.
The stage manager expected Cash to be annoyed.
The show had a running order.
Guests had assigned segments.
Television, even television taped in an old church in Nashville, ran on a schedule measured in seconds, and a piano duel that nobody had planned was the kind of thing that made network executives in New York reach for their antacid.
Cash was not annoyed.
Cash, by the stage manager’s later account, laughed so hard he had to sit down on an equipment case.
Then, he went and found both men, one at a time.
He went to Jerry Lee first, because he had known Jerry Lee since the two of them were young and broke and recording for the same little label in Memphis in the ’50s, and he knew there was no talking Jerry Lee out of anything once his blood was up.
“Is it true?”
Cash asked.
“It’s true,”
said Jerry Lee.
“The cowboy called me out.”
“I’m going to play him right off the stage and into the parking lot.”
Cash nodded slowly, as if considering a serious legal question.
“Just don’t set anything on fire,”
he said.
“The Ryman’s older than both of us put together.”
Then, he went to find Clint, who was sitting in a folding chair in the corner of his tiny dressing room, reading the newspaper as though nothing unusual had happened all afternoon.
Cash leaned in the doorway with his arms folded.
“You know who that is, don’t you?”
Cash said.
“You know what that man does to a piano.”
“I’ve seen it,”
said Clint, not looking up from the paper.
“And you still want to do this?”
Clint folded the newspaper, set it on his knee, and looked up.
“He said cowboys sit on pianos,”
he said.
“Seemed like somebody ought to say something.”
Cash looked at him for a long moment, and something in his expression shifted from amusement into genuine curiosity.
He had spent his whole career watching people who were very good at one thing in public and quietly, secretly, very good at something else in private.
And he had learned to recognize the look of a man who was holding a card nobody knew he had.
“Can you actually play?”
Cash asked.
Clint was quiet for a moment.
“I can play,”
he said.
“I just don’t play loud.”
That, Cash decided on the spot, was going to be the best segment of the entire season.
He rearranged the running order that afternoon.
The producers in New York were informed by telephone, and objected by telephone, and were overruled by telephone, because it was Cash’s show, and Cash’s name was on it, and Cash had a way of saying,
“We’re doing it.”
that ended most conversations.
The stage crew wheeled a second piano out of storage, an old black grand that had been sitting under a dust cover since some earlier concert, and tuned it as best they could in 2 hours.
The plan, such as it was, was simple.
Cash would introduce Jerry Lee to sing his new country single, the way the segment had been booked.
Then, Cash would bring Clint out to talk about his picture, the way that segment had been booked.
And then, somewhere in the middle of the conversation, Cash would mention, as if it had only just occurred to him, that he had heard a rumor about a disagreement backstage.
After that, nobody had the faintest idea what would happen, which was exactly the way Cash liked it.
The doors opened at 7:00.
The Ryman filled, pew by pew, the old curved balcony packed with faces, over 2,000 people who had come expecting country music and a little rock and roll, and a chance to see Johnny Cash in the flesh, in the building where Hank Williams and Patsy Cline had stood.
They had absolutely no idea what they had really bought a ticket for.
Almost nobody backstage did, either.
The taping began at half past 7:00, and for the first 40 minutes, it went precisely according to the plan nobody had written down.
Cash opened with a song of his own, dressed in black, the band behind him chugging along in that famous rhythm like a freight train on a long, straight track.
A folk duo played, a comedian told stories.
Then Cash introduced Jerry Lee Lewis, and the Killer walked out to a roar that shook dust off the rafters, sat down at the house piano, and sang his new country single with a restraint that was almost suspicious.
He sang it beautifully.
He sang it like a man who had been through hell and was grateful to be allowed back on a stage.
The audience gave him a long, warm ovation, and Jerry Lee took it with a small bow, walked off, and winked at Clint in the wings as he passed.
“Just warming up the room for you, cowboy,”
he said.
“Get it nice and cozy before I burn it down.”
Cash brought Clint out about 10 minutes later.
The reaction was different in kind from the one Jerry Lee had gotten.
A big welcome with a note of surprise inside it.
The sound of 2,000 people discovering that the man with no name was a real person who could walk across a stage in a tan jacket and shake hands with Johnny Cash like anybody else.
They sat down on two stools at the front of the stage, and for about 5 minutes, it was an entirely ordinary interview.
Cash asked about the new picture.
Clint said it was a musical, which got a laugh.
Cash asked whether it was true that he did his own singing in it.
Clint said it was true, and that he would be happy to answer any further questions about it after the critics had finished with him, if there was anything left.
That got a bigger laugh.
Then Cash leaned back on his stool, looked out at the audience with a completely innocent face, and said,
“Now, I heard something backstage this afternoon.”
“I heard there was a little bit of a disagreement.”
He let that sit.
“Jerry Lee, you want to come on back out here?”
Jerry Lee came out of the wings like a man arriving at his own birthday party.
The audience, sensing something, began to buzz.
Cash explained the situation in his slow, dry baritone, as though he were reading a legal deposition.
A remark had been made concerning cowboys and pianos.
The cowboy in question had taken exception.
A wager had been proposed.
Terms had been agreed in a corridor.
“Now, I don’t know about y’all,”
Cash said to the crowd,
“but I think the people ought to decide this one.”
The Ryman went up like a haystack.
2,000 people who had come to hear country songs had just been told they were going to be the judges of a piano duel between Jerry Lee Lewis and Clint Eastwood, and the noise they made in response rattled the stained glass in the windows.
Jerry Lee went first.
Of course, he went first.
He had never gone second at anything in his life, and he was not about to start in front of Johnny Cash’s audience.
He walked to the black grand piano, the one the crew had rolled out that afternoon, looked at it the way a bull rider looks at a bull, and sat down.
What followed was about 4 minutes of pure, concentrated Jerry Lee Lewis.
He started with one of the rock and roll songs that had made him famous in 1957, and within eight bars, he was no longer sitting down.
He stood up and played standing.
The bench kicked back behind him with the heel of his boots so hard that it skidded halfway across the stage.
His left hand pounded out a boogie line like a steam hammer.
His right hand ran up and down the keyboard in glissandos so fast they sounded like a handful of marbles thrown down a flight of stairs.
He hit a chord with his elbow.
He hit another with the flat of his palm.
At one point, to a scream from the balcony that the sound crew said was the loudest single noise they recorded all year, he lifted his right boot and played a run of notes with his heel without missing a beat.
His hair came loose from its careful sculpture and fell across his face.
The piano shook.
The stage shook.
For the last 30 seconds, most of the audience was on its feet, clapping, stomping, shouting, entirely without having decided to be.
When Jerry Lee hit the final chord with both fists, he stood there breathing hard with his hair in his eyes, turned to the audience, spread his arms, and then turned to Clint with a look that said, as plainly as if he had painted it on a sign,
“Follow that.”
The ovation went on for almost a full minute.
Cash, standing at the side of the stage, just shook his head and grinned.
And every one of those 2,000 people, including most of the band, turned to look at Clint Eastwood, who was still sitting quietly on his stool at the front of the stage with his hands on his knees, and wondered what on earth he was going to do now.
Clint stood up slowly.
He did not hurry.
He crossed the stage to the grand piano, stopped on the way to pick up the bench Jerry Lee had kicked halfway to the wings, carried it back without comment, set it down precisely in front of the keyboard, and adjusted it a quarter of an inch.
That alone got a laugh, the specific laugh of an audience that has just realized the man in front of them understands timing better than it expected.
Then, he sat down, put his hands in his lap, and waited.
He waited until the room was quiet.
Not mostly quiet, completely quiet.
It took about 10 seconds, and it felt like a great deal longer.
2,000 people who had been stomping and shouting a moment before slowly realizing that the man at the piano was not going to begin until they stopped and deciding, one by one, to stop.
Then, he played.
He did not try to answer Jerry Lee.
That was the first thing everyone who was there remembered.
He did not play faster or louder or stand up or reach for anything flashy.
He played an old slow blues, the same one Jerry Lee had caught him playing in the corridor that afternoon.
Only now on a proper grand piano in a room built for sound.
And he played it with so much space between the notes that the silence became part of the music.
His left hand walked, steady and patient, like a man walking home down a long road at night.
His right hand said almost nothing.
A phrase here, a single bent-sounding note there.
And then long pauses where it simply rested and let the left hand carry on alone.
It was the exact opposite of what had come before.
Where Jerry Lee had filled every second of his 4 minutes with sound, Clint seemed to be making music out of what he left out.
And the Ryman, which had been a thunderstorm a minute earlier, went so still you could hear the old wooden pews creak as people leaned forward.
In the balcony, a man who had been on his feet screaming for Jerry Lee sat slowly back down without seeming to know he was doing it.
Down front, an older woman in a church hat put her hand to her chest and kept it there.
The members of Cash’s house band, working musicians who had seen every kind of player walk through that building, looked at each other with the particular raised eyebrows of professionals who have just heard something they did not expect.
He played for about 3 minutes.
Near the end, he slipped without warning into a few bars of a Fats Waller tune his mother used to play on the record player in the evenings.
A little bright figure that sparkled for just a moment and then settled back down into the blues again, like a smile that someone decides not to finish.
Then, he let the last chord ring until it faded into the old wooden walls, lifted his hands and put them back in his lap.
For about 2 seconds, nobody made a sound.
Then, the applause came and it was a completely different animal from the ovation Jerry Lee had gotten.
It started slower and built longer and it had something in it besides excitement.
People were not screaming.
They were clapping the way you clap in a church when you are not sure you are allowed to and then deciding you do not care.
It went on for a long time.
Jerry Lee Lewis, standing at the edge of the stage with his arms folded and his hair still in his eyes, was not clapping.
He was staring at Clint with his mouth very slightly open.
Then, slowly, with visible reluctance, as if his hands were doing it against his will, he started to clap, too.
If this story’s got you grinning right now, drop a comment and tell us who you’d have voted for and hit subscribe if you haven’t yet.
Cash walked back to center stage and raised his hands for quiet and it took him a while to get it.
“Well,”
he said into the microphone in the driest voice he owned,
“I believe we have a problem.”
The audience laughed.
“I asked y’all to decide,”
Cash went on,
“and near as I can tell, y’all have decided it’s a tie.”
More laughter and a few shouts from the balcony for one man or the other and a lot of applause that could have meant anything.
Cash let it run, then held up one finger.
“Now, the way we settle a tie in Arkansas,”
he said,
“is we make both fellows do the other fellow’s job.”
The Ryman went up again.
Jerry Lee threw back his head and howled.
Clint, still sitting at the grand piano, closed his eyes for a moment, like a man who has just been told the stagecoach he is on has no brakes.
The terms, as Cash announced them to the delighted crowd, were simple.
Jerry Lee would go first.
He would have to play one slow song all the way through without once speeding up, standing up, or kicking anything.
Then, Clint would have to play one song the way Jerry Lee played, standing, fast, loud, the whole show, bench and all.
The audience would judge who suffered more.
Jerry Lee sat down at the grand piano with the air of a man walking into a dentist’s office.
He cracked his knuckles.
He rolled his shoulders.
He looked at Clint, who had moved to the stool Cash had been sitting on and was watching with his arms folded and absolutely no expression on his face, which was somehow worse than laughing.
Jerry Lee started to play a slow gospel hymn, one he had grown up playing in the Assembly of God church back in Ferriday.
And for about 30 seconds, it was genuinely lovely, a reminder to anyone who had forgotten that underneath all the fireworks, the killer was one of the finest natural piano players in America.
Then, very slightly, it began to speed up.
He caught himself.
He slowed down.
The audience laughed.
He played another eight bars at the proper tempo, visibly concentrating, his jaw set.
And then, his left hand, as if it had a mind of its own, slipped in one tiny boogie figure underneath the hymn, just a little rumble in the bass, and he slapped it with his right hand like a man swatting a mosquito, and the whole rhyme and came apart.
He started again.
He got as far as the second verse.
His right foot began to tap.
The tap turned into a stomp.
The stomp turned into the hymn going twice as fast as any congregation had ever sung it.
And by the final chorus, he was half off the bench with his hair in his face again, playing the gospel song like it was on fire, while 2,000 people laughed and clapped, and Cash at the side of the stage bent over double.
When he finished, Jerry Lee threw both hands in the air and shouted into the microphone,
“I can’t do it.”
“The Lord made me fast, Johnny.”
“Take it up with him.”
Now, it was Clint’s turn.
And this, everybody who was there agreed afterwards, was the moment the evening went from a good night to a legendary one.
He stood up from Cash’s stool, walked back to the grand piano, and stood there looking at it for a long moment.
He did not sit down.
The rules said standing.
He took off his tan jacket, very slowly, folded it, and handed it to Jerry Lee, who took it with enormous ceremony and draped it over his own arm like a waiter.
He rolled up his sleeves.
He pushed a hand through his hair and messed it up deliberately, the closest thing to Jerry Lee’s golden pompadour he could manage, which got a scream of laughter from the balcony.
Then, he set his feet like a man about to lift something heavy, put both hands on the keys, and started to pound.
It was not good.
That was the glory of it.
He knew the boogie pattern, because every piano player who grew up in the ’40s knew the boogie pattern, and his left hand got it going well enough.
But the rest of him had never done anything like this in his life.
He banged at the right hand of the keyboard with a grim determination that looked exactly like a man trying to hammer a stubborn fence post into frozen ground.
He attempted a glissando, drew the back of his hand down the keys, and produced a sound like somebody dropping a drawer of cutlery.
The audience was already in hysterics.
Jerry Lee was shouting encouragement from the side.
“That’s it!”
“Make it holler, cowboy!”
And then, Clint decided to go for the big finish.
He decided to kick the bench.
He did it the way he had watched Jerry Lee do it, a sharp backward kick with the heel of his boot, meaning to send the bench skidding dramatically away.
But the bench was behind him at an angle, and his boot caught only the corner of it.
And instead of skidding away, it spun a half turn and settled right back behind his knees.
Clint, fully committed to the move, kept playing and tried to kick it again.
It spun back again.
He looked down at it.
The audience roared.
He glared at the bench with the exact expression he had used on half a dozen villains in half a dozen pictures.
The long, narrow, deadly squint.
And 2,000 people absolutely lost their minds at the sight of the man with no name staring down a piece of furniture.
Then, he tried Jerry Lee’s most famous trick.
He lifted his right boot to play a run with his heel.
What nobody had accounted for was that he was 6’4″ and a great deal of him was leg, and the keyboard of that old grand piano sat at a height designed for people considerably closer to the ground.
His boot came up, overshot the keys entirely, clipped the edge of the piano lid with a hollow wooden bang, and threw him completely off balance.
He windmilled one arm.
He grabbed for the piano.
His hand came down on the keys in a single enormous crashing chord that was, several musicians in the band later insisted, the one genuinely Jerry Lee Lewis sound he made all night.
And then he went straight down backwards, sat down hard on exactly the spot where the bench had been a second earlier, discovered that the bench had rolled away again, and landed flat on his back on the stage of the Ryman Auditorium with his boots in the air.
The noise that came out of the Ryman at that moment was not laughter so much as an explosion.
People were bent over in the pews.
People were holding on to each other.
Up in the balcony, a man laughed so hard he slid off the end of his pew and sat on the floor, which set off everyone around him all over again.
Jerry Lee Lewis had dropped Clint’s jacket and was standing with both hands on his knees, laughing so hard no sound was coming out of him at all.
And Johnny Cash, the man in black, who had spent his entire career cultivating an air of dignified rumbling seriousness, had his hand over his face and his shoulders shaking, and did not even try to pretend to be a host who had everything under control.
Clint lay there on his back for a moment, completely still, looking up at the old ceiling.
The audience began to worry, just slightly, whether he was all right.
Then, without getting up and without changing his expression in the slightest, he lifted one long leg straight up in the air, reached the keyboard with the toe of his boot, and pressed down one single low note.
He let it ring.
Then, he lowered his boot, folded his hands across his chest like a man laid out on a cooling board in one of his own westerns, and said, into the silence, loud enough for the nearest microphone to catch it,
“I believe that’s about all the Jerry Lee I’ve got in me.”
If the laugh before had been an explosion, this one was the building falling down.
It went on for over a minute.
The stage manager said afterwards it was the longest sustained laugh the show recorded in its entire run.
It was Jerry Lee who helped him up.
He walked over, still wheezing, reached down, grabbed Clint’s hand, and hauled him upright with a grunt.
And then, to the delight of the whole room, dusted off the back of Clint’s shirt with great care, like a tailor fussing over a customer.
He retrieved the tan jacket from the floor and handed it back.
Then he turned to the audience and raised Clint’s arm in the air like a referee raising a boxer’s.
“Ladies and gentlemen,”
he announced,
“I have been playing this instrument for 25 years, and I have never, not once, seen anybody suffer for it like this man just suffered.”
“I say he wins.”
Cash walked out to center stage and took the microphone.
“Jerry Lee,”
he said,
“that’s the first time in your life you ever let anybody else win anything.”
“Well, Johnny,”
said Jerry Lee,
“he fell down.”
“That’s showmanship.”
“That boy’s got more rock and roll in him than he knows.”
Then Cash did one more thing, and it turned into the part of the night that people who were there talked about with a different look on their faces.
He asked them to play together.
One piano, four hands, any song they liked.
Clint said he didn’t know any of Jerry Lee’s songs.
Jerry Lee said he didn’t know any of Clint’s because, as far as he knew, Clint didn’t have any.
So, they sat down side by side on that runaway bench, which a stagehand had finally captured and wedged against the piano with a sandbag, and they found a common ground neither of them expected.
It turned out that both of them, as boys, a Louisiana farm kid and a California kid moving from town to town during the Depression, had learned the same old boogie-woogie tunes from the same old records.
Clint took the bottom of the keyboard and laid down the walking left hand, steady and unhurried, the way he had played in the corridor that afternoon.
Jerry Lee took the top and set it on fire.
And for 3 minutes, the patient cowboy and the wild man from Ferriday played one song together as if they had been doing it for years.
Clint holding the ground and Jerry Lee dancing on top of it, each of them making the other one sound better than either had sounded alone.
At the end, Jerry Lee hit the last chord with his fist, and Clint hit it at exactly the same moment with his, and the old Ryman came to its feet for the fourth time that night.
After the taping, when most of the audience had filed out into the cool Nashville night still laughing, Clint was found by the stage manager sitting on the edge of the stage with his legs hanging over, rubbing the back of his head with a small, slightly rueful smile on his face that almost nobody ever got to see on camera.
Jerry Lee found him there a few minutes later and sat down beside him without asking, the two of them looking out over the empty pews.
For a while, neither of them said anything.
“I’ll tell you something,”
Jerry Lee finally said.
“That thing you did, the slow thing, where you just sat there and made them wait.”
He shook his head.
“I couldn’t do that if you paid me a million dollars.”
“I tried tonight.”
“You saw me.”
“I got about eight bars in and my own hands mutinied.”
Clint said he’d noticed.
“I’ve been playing in front of people since I was a boy,”
Jerry Lee went on.
“Church, then juke joints, then the whole country, then nowhere for about 10 years when nobody’d have me, then back again.”
“And every one of those rooms, I played like I had to grab them by the collar before they walked out.”
“Like if I let up for 1 second, they’d remember they didn’t like me.”
He was quiet a moment.
“You play like you don’t care if anybody’s listening at all.”
“I don’t, mostly,”
Clint said.
“That’s the only way I know how to do it.”
“Soon as I think anybody’s listening, my hands get stupid.”
He looked at the grand piano sitting alone on the stage under the work lights.
“You play to be heard,”
he said.
“I play so I can hear myself think.”
“Neither one’s the right way.”
“They’re just two different reasons for sitting down at the same instrument.”
Jerry Lee thought about that for a long moment.
Then he laughed, softly this time.
“You know you fell down in front of Johnny Cash,”
he said.
“Yes,”
said Clint,
“on television.”
“Yes.”
“Folks are going to see that for the rest of your life.”
Clint considered this with complete seriousness.
“At least they’ll know I can play the piano,”
he said.
“Nobody’s ever going to believe that part otherwise.”
Johnny Cash came out a few minutes later with three bottles of soda from the machine in the hallway and sat down on the other side of them.
And the three of them stayed on the edge of that stage for close to an hour talking about the records they had loved as boys and the first pianos they had ever touched and the rooms they had played in before anybody knew their names while the crew rolled up the cables around them.
The episode aired a few weeks later, and the clip of Clint on his back with his boot in the air pressing one single note became, for a while, one of those things people described to one another at work the next morning.
Paint Your Wagon opened that same month to reviews that were exactly as unkind about his singing as he had expected.
Several people who worked on the Cash show later said they suspected that was why he had been so willing to fall down in front of 2,000 people.
“A man who has already been laughed at by the critics,”
one of them said,
“has nothing left to lose by making the audience laugh on purpose.”
What happened in the years that followed gave that silly October night a strange kind of weight.
Clint never did become a public piano player, but the piano kept creeping into his pictures.
In 1971, he built his first picture as a director, Play Misty for Me, around a late-night jazz disc jockey, and over the years, whenever a scene put a piano in a bar, he tended to sit down at it himself.
In 1982, he made Honkytonk Man, about a dying Depression-era country singer, and did his own singing again.
And this time, some of the critics were kinder.
In 1988, he made Bird, about Charlie Parker, the saxophone player he had first heard in an Oakland theater as a teenager.
More and more, from the 1990s on, he composed the themes for his own films himself.
Quiet piano melodies with a great deal of space left between the notes.
And in 2003, he directed a documentary for public television called Piano Blues, a long, loving film about the players he had admired all his life, in which he spent much of the running time sitting at a piano beside legends, listening far more than he talked, and every so often, when asked, playing a few slow bars himself.
Jerry Lee Lewis kept playing, too, loud and fast and standing up for another five decades.
In 1986, he was part of the very first class ever inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
He became the last survivor of the young men who had recorded together at Sun Records in Memphis in the ’50s, outliving even Johnny Cash, who died in 2003.
And he was still performing, still kicking back the bench well into his ’80s.
He died in October 2022 at the age of 87.
Asked once, many years later, about that night at the Ryman, Clint told the story the way he told most stories, in about four sentences.
“Jerry Lee said cowboys don’t play piano.”
“They sit on them,”
he said.
“I tried to prove him wrong, ended up sitting on the floor instead.”
He paused.
“Best night of piano I ever had.”
Somewhere in the Ryman Auditorium, the story goes, there is still a scuff on the stage boards near the spot where the grand piano stood that night.
Nobody can prove it came from the heel of a cowboy boot.
Nobody who was there has ever tried very hard to prove it didn’t.
If you enjoyed this one, hit subscribe for more stories like it, and let us know in the comments which two legends you’d want to see go head-to-head next.